What's new

Marlins mailbag: Will team spend in free agency? Should Miami extend Brian Anderson?

SonOfJack

el gringo loco
Joined
May 10, 2017
Messages
11,721
Reaction score
838
Points
123
It’s time for an offseason edition of the Miami Marlins mailbag! Any and all questions can be sent in via Twitter to @DuseReport.

@FrankyLitz11: Wells, as a fan since inception, I still feel I have absolutely nothing to look forward to in 2020. The starting pitching is decent, at best. The bullpen is a disaster and the hitting is AA at best. Diaz looks to be another Brinson, not much buzz around Harrison, what’s next?

DUSE
: The harsh reality is that after 105 losses, there’s probably not going to be massive improvement next season. Sure, the team “should” be better, but does that mean 65-75 wins? Derek Jeter has been coy about giving a date for contention, but the window has seemingly been 2021.
In terms of making that push forward, there’s a few things to be hopeful for in 2020.

-- Can Sixto Sanchez/Edward Cabrera live up the hype? They’ll likely be here by some point next season and the Marlins need them to be the real deal.

-- Will Isan Diaz take a leap in production? While he had his moments, 2019 was mostly a disappointment in his debut. That doesn’t mean he’s a bust by any means, but when you hit .173/.259/.307 (53 wRC+) with a -1.2 WAR, that can’t be quickly brushed aside. The second baseman has significant potential and can turn it around, but manager Don Mattingly said himself that Diaz will have to fight for a job in spring training.

-- Can Monte Harrison and Jesus Sanchez provide some pop in the lineup? The two top-100 prospects should be in the majors at some point next season and Miami needs both outfielders to perform if they want to speed up the rebuild.

@thepacman321: Do the Marlins think that Harold is an everyday OF? Does Monte & Nick Neidert have shots at making the team outta Spring Training? Are Riddle, Tyron Guerrero, & Brinson outta chances?

DUSE
: Making his debut in May, Harold Ramirez had a nice rookie season hitting .276/.312/.416 (92 wRC+) with 11 home runs and 20 doubles in 446 plate appearances. With the ability to play both corner spots and be serviceable in center for short stints, he provides decent versatility. I think he’s likely more of a fourth outfielder in the future, but he should have opportunities early in the season.
Monte Harrison and Nick Neidert will both be on the roster at some point next season, but I think they’d have to really dominate in spring training for them to make the Opening Day roster. Keep in mind, both players missed significant time with injuries last season, so starting the season in Triple-A and gradually working them up might not be the worst thing.
For the final three — it seems hard to envision JT Riddle in the Marlins’ long-term plans at this point. While Tayron Guerrero has elite fastball velocity, his lack of command and secondary pitches really hurt him this past season, so he’s a question mark. Miami has publicly shown confidence in Lewis Brinson, but added that he needs to produce, so his opportunities may be running out.

@DylanCanesFan: Wells, what’s your thoughts on the Marlins approach to free agency this year? You think they make a major progression from signing the [Neil] Walker’s to going after someone like Abreu?

@jay_warman: Do you think it’s a good idea to go after Jose Abreu?

@Gabaldon81: Are we signing anyone at all?! Any sign of good faith??

DUSE
: The Marlins desperately need to add a power hitter who can hit 25-30 home runs — either at first base or at a corner outfield spot. After spending $75 million last season, the Marlins have roughly $32 million coming off the books this offseason, plus $22 million the following year when Wei-Yin Chen’s contract expires, so they could make a move.
Jose Abreu would certainly fit the bill for Miami. This past season, the 32-year-old first baseman hit .284/.330/.503 (117 wRC+) with 33 home runs and 38 doubles for the Chicago White Sox. His hard contact rates were also impressive, ranking in the top-seven percent in both exit velocity and hard hit percentage.
What would it take to land him? Abreu made $16 million this past season and will likely be seeking a pay raise in what will could be his last major contract. The Marlins shouldn’t cripple themselves financially for the long term, but overpaying on a shorter three-year deal could be an option. Keep in mind, the Marlins will see an annual financial boost once the new TV contract is finalized.

Having a bat of his magnitude would help protect the younger players in the lineup and be a sign of good faith for a fan base that’s seen 203 losses over the past two years. A Cuba native, Abreu would also generate fan interest as well in Miami.

@blamethemovies: I’m curious if we come around to signing BA to an extension in the offseason.

DUSE
: I’m a proponent of signing Brian Anderson to an extension, but time will tell on that front. Before breaking his hand near the end of the season, he was on pace for nearly 25 home runs/40 doubles and was playing Gold Glove caliber defense at both third base and right field. He’s been exactly what you want for a rebuilding team and has proven he’s a key piece moving forward.
The perception of the franchise over the past 20+ years has been that it gets rid of players once they develop into strong assets and are too expensive. Early extensions have become commonplace in baseball and would allow Miami to buy out a year of free agency at an affordable price. Making a financial commitment to a player like Anderson, who’s earned it, would go a long way toward Jeter and company building trust in the South Florida community.
 

Bret Hart

No.1 Korean Fish Fan
Joined
Apr 26, 2006
Messages
3,929
Reaction score
6
Points
38
I'm still weighing up Riddle's role. If he were ok, OF and INF depth in major would be stable in a way.
 

SilverBullet

Wind Surge
Moderator
Joined
Jul 5, 2005
Messages
27,167
Reaction score
757
Points
113
A Brian Anderson extension will go a long way in building trust with the community and the fan base?

I'm not sure that's true outside of actual serious fans. People will just say "they'll still trade him anyways and who is Brian Anderson I've never heard of him etc etc."
 

SonOfJack

el gringo loco
Joined
May 10, 2017
Messages
11,721
Reaction score
838
Points
123
A Brian Anderson extension will go a long way in building trust with the community and the fan base?

I'm not sure that's true outside of actual serious fans. People will just say "they'll still trade him anyways and who is Brian Anderson I've never heard of him etc etc."
Yeah that is exactly what would happen.

Hopefully they do extend him, but it won't do shit in terms of building trust.
 

rmc523

Hammerhead
Joined
Dec 28, 2010
Messages
1,995
Reaction score
139
Points
63
A Brian Anderson extension will go a long way in building trust with the community and the fan base?

I'm not sure that's true outside of actual serious fans. People will just say "they'll still trade him anyways and who is Brian Anderson I've never heard of him etc etc."
Agreed. Until he finishes a contract, it'll be "oh they'll get rid of him".......and even if they did extend him and he finished the contract and left, then people would still say "look they couldn't keep him!"

And not to rehash the discussion, but they traded Yelich who was on an extension.

That said, they should extend him if they can, IMO.

----

I also have the same opinion of the Abreu being Cuban would generate fan interest......I really don't think people care that much.

----

On a side note, why is there no more Multi-quote button?
 

SilverBullet

Wind Surge
Moderator
Joined
Jul 5, 2005
Messages
27,167
Reaction score
757
Points
113
but they traded Yelich who was on an extension.
I've noticed that plenty of people on extensions still get traded. People assume it means they're never going away and that's not always the case. An extension locks them in at a guaranteed rate for a longer time but it doesn't mean they'll never be traded and in some cases, like Yelich, their extension actually makes them an even more desirable trade piece.

Oh and yes on Abreu supposedly generating interest in the Cuban community. That ship has sailed. Not happening unless the team is winning. If they're winning the Cuban people will love him but people won't care that he's Cuban if the team still sucks.
 

taiwanmarlin

LumberKing
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
7,022
Reaction score
80
Points
48
People will just say "they'll still trade him anyways and who is Brian Anderson I've never heard of him etc etc."
But this regime not yet doing something like that, the only player they signed to extension was Rojas and he's still a Marlins.
 

rmc523

Hammerhead
Joined
Dec 28, 2010
Messages
1,995
Reaction score
139
Points
63
I've noticed that plenty of people on extensions still get traded. People assume it means they're never going away and that's not always the case. An extension locks them in at a guaranteed rate for a longer time but it doesn't mean they'll never be traded and in some cases, like Yelich, their extension actually makes them an even more desirable trade piece.

Oh and yes on Abreu supposedly generating interest in the Cuban community. That ship has sailed. Not happening unless the team is winning. If they're winning the Cuban people will love him but people won't care that he's Cuban if the team still sucks.
Oh I know this. I'm just saying that's what the general public will say.
 

THRILLHO

Hammerhead
Joined
Dec 15, 2007
Messages
2,401
Reaction score
140
Points
63
All joking aside. As much as people like to dwell on Yelichs coming of age, the Marlins did well on Ozuna. He posted a wRC+ of 143 in his last year in Miami. Followed it with 107 and 110 in St. Louis and now they’re supposedly letting him walk. That’s a win for the marlins. Stanton was massive salary relief. He barely played this season. Trading him right after 59 HRs was going to get them about as much as they could have possibly hoped for. You really do win some and lose some.
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom