Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

MarlinsBaseball.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

If the Marlins finish at or close to .500, does it hurt or help the rebuild?

Featured Replies

This question came up in another thread and I thought it was an excellent topic. No need to say "Don't bother it will never happen anyways"... if it did somehow happen, does the Marlins finishing at or close to .500 actually help or hurt the rebuild at this point? 

 

 

I say helps for the same reason @SonOfJack says, plus it builds the winning mentality the team needs going forward (believe I said that in the other thread, too).

 

Kinda fun that this current run of games is making us even consider this possibility. lol

 

 

I echo @SonOfJack   If this team pulls together and finishes with that record it will be due to great contributions from players that we want to be a part of the future.  That is the rebuild taking place before our eyes.  We aren’t going to get top five picks for three years and then flip a switch and go worst to first.  Yea it happens but I wouldn’t count on that happening.  

 

 

  • Author
I am not saying this will keep up because I still doubt it, but I am getting deja vu of 2006 currently.

 

Mattingly manager of the year and then gets fired anyways? Tbh this isn't out of the question. 

 

 

I am not saying this will keep up because I still doubt it, but I am getting deja vu of 2006 currently.

 

 

 

Mattingly manager of the year and then gets fired anyways? Tbh this isn't out of the question. 

 

I've been saying the team reminds me of the 2006 team for a little bit now. Started specifically when the team got the first win against the Mets to start the six game streak and we were 11-31 at that time (after the first game). 11-31 was the worst record the 2006 team got to, and this current team actually was 10-31. Through 58 games, 22-36 right now, one game better than the 2006 team. ?

 

 

If this team gets to .500 and doesnt trade off the veteran pieces it accomplishes nothing but gives you lower draft positions and lower draft pools for next year.

 

If you trade off veterans and still reach .500 then its a good thing.

 

 

If this team gets to .500 and doesnt trade off the veteran pieces it accomplishes nothing but gives you lower draft positions and lower draft pools for next year.

 

If you trade off veterans and still reach .500 then its a good thing.

 

Which veterans do you have in mind?  Castro, Granderson, Prado, Romo?   I could see pinching a prospect in exchange for Romo.  Not sure any of the others would fetch anything significant. 

 

 

Which veterans do you have in mind?  Castro, Granderson, Prado, Romo?   I could see pinching a prospect in exchange for Romo.  Not sure any of the others would fetch anything significant. 

 

I'd add in Conley if he gets hot.

 

Guerrero too honestly.  

 

Honestly I dont think they should hold out any bullpen arm thats desired if it can net you a fairly decent prospect, since bullpens are easy as fuck to figure out long term.  

 

Sell high on any and all of them.

 

Walker for sure.

 

 

I'd add in Conley if he gets hot.

 

Guerrero too honestly.  

 

Honestly I dont think they should hold out any bullpen arm thats desired if it can net you a fairly decent prospect, since bullpens are easy as fuck to figure out long term.  

 

Sell high on any and all of them.

 

Walker for sure.

 

Oh yes.  Totally on board with selling any bullpen pieces

 

 

Honestly I dont think they should hold out any bullpen arm thats desired if it can net you a fairly decent prospect, since bullpens are easy as fuck to figure out long term.  

 

100% agree with this.

 

That's two days in a week we agree, I am worried.

 

 

  • Author

I think the only negative comes from how much you value the higher draft picks. Getting another one or two top picks would be nice but other than that I see no negatives in this team improving faster than expected.

 

With that said they would also have to balance out contention with still "staying the course." Can't Loria this thing and suddenly trade Sixto and Mesa for a reliever rental at the deadline. This is a big one and would really show the difference between ownerships. 

 

 

Can't Loria this thing and suddenly trade Sixto and Mesa for a reliever rental at the deadline. This is a big one and would really show the difference between ownerships. 

 

I hope they aren't dumb enough to try and become buyers this year, regardless of how the team is playing come July.

 

 

I’m going to go with ‘helps’ assuming that it’s a result of getting production from our “future core”. If the reason we are .500 is because of guys like Harold Ramirez, Andy, Alfaro, Diaz*, Harrison*, and the SP staff, this is a HUGE positive to the rebuild as we will be checking off boxes along the way. 

 

Regarding the draft picks, if this was the NFL that would be a concern. There are too many ways to acquire talent in baseball (International, trade deadline, Rule 5) for that to outweigh positives from guys already in the system 

 

 

I'd add in Conley if he gets hot.

 

Guerrero too honestly.  

 

Honestly I dont think they should hold out any bullpen arm thats desired if it can net you a fairly decent prospect, since bullpens are easy as fuck to figure out long term.  

 

Sell high on any and all of them.

 

Walker for sure.

 

Agree here 100%. Id also add Urena, Nick Anderson (and Caleb Smith depending on market value) to that list 

 

 

I think the only negative comes from how much you value the higher draft picks. Getting another one or two top picks would be nice but other than that I see no negatives in this team improving faster than expected.

 

With that said they would also have to balance out contention with still "staying the course." Can't Loria this thing and suddenly trade Sixto and Mesa for a reliever rental at the deadline. This is a big one and would really show the difference between ownerships. 

 

Depends.

 

If they buy rentals or old players they are dumber than boxes of rocks and it truly is Loria 2.0.

 

If they want to buy controlled pieces, different story.

 

Just dont pull a Pirates (even cheaper ownership) and acquire a Chris Archer and then play the card of see we are acquiring talent (after trading away Cole for pennies in the winter prior)

 

 

I’m going to go with ‘helps’ assuming that it’s a result of getting production from our “future core”. If the reason we are .500 is because of guys like Harold Ramirez, Andy, Alfaro, Diaz*, Harrison*, and the SP staff, this is a HUGE positive to the rebuild as we will be checking off boxes along the way. 

 

Regarding the draft picks, if this was the NFL that would be a concern. There are too many ways to acquire talent in baseball (International, trade deadline, Rule 5) for that to outweigh positives from guys already in the system 

 

You cant rely on the Rule 5 draft and International rules are changing again with this cycle to make the playing field much more even.

 

 

You cant rely on the Rule 5 draft and International rules are changing again with this cycle to make the playing field much more even.

 

Right. I’m not saying completely ignore the draft. But it’s also not like the NFL or NBA where the draft is king and a couple wins here and there could cost you future picks in order to get your future QB/cornerstone. 

 

The hit rate in the MLB draft is so scattered that’s its almost irrelevant in terms of what to be rooting for - success for guys in upper levels of your system vs draft position 

 

 

  • Author
The "this team is 50 years away" crowd sure has quieted down the past few weeks.

 

They must think we have done some time traveling here. 

 

 

Right. I’m not saying completely ignore the draft. But it’s also not like the NFL or NBA where the draft is king and a couple wins here and there could cost you future picks in order to get your future QB/cornerstone. 

 

The hit rate in the MLB draft is so scattered that’s its almost irrelevant in terms of what to be rooting for - success for guys in upper levels of your system vs draft position 

 

the MLB draft success rate is increasing every year, especially in earlier rounds.

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.