I will take the guy with a better ERA and more wins.
will you also take the guy with five more losses and lower K count, higher WHIP, higher opponent batting average, lower IP?
I'm not trying to sound like I'm rubbing it in, but I'm just saying that Carpenter deserved this just as much as Willis did. Frankly I'm surprised that the voters didn't go for Clemens because of his ERA but I guess that frowned on alot of short outtings.
I really thought it was a toss up between all three pitchers, it had to land somewhere and it just something about Chris appealed to the voters.