OK, here are Mitre's minor league stats:
Year W L ERA G GS INN H R ER BB SO
2001 A- 8 4 3.07 15 15 91.0 85 37 31 18 71
2002 A- 8 10 2.83 27 27 168.2 166 72 53 27 96
2003 AA- 7 9 3.34 25 24 145.2 162 75 54 41 128
2004 AAA- 6 3 2.98 18 15 102.2 97 38 34 39 95
2005 AAA- 5 6 4.33 13 13 70.2 72 34 34 22 55
Career minor-league record of 34-32: Decidedly average.
Career IPs: 580; Hits given up: 582: That's more than 1 hit per inning in his MINOR league career. Decidedly below-average.
His strikeout rates aren't terrible, but don't inspire confidence either. However, if he is a sinker-baller, those typs tend to increase their strikeouts as they age...so more of those may be coming in the future.
Average control; not a problem necessarily, but not a strength.
Overall I see a slightly above-average minor league pitcher. However, he was the Cubs #1 pitching prospect for years: There must be a reason, right? Also, he's Girardi's #2 pitcher: There must be a reason, right? I haven't seen him pitch, which is why I was wondering if someone who had could tell me if there's somethng that he brings to the table that you can't measure in stats.
Or, is he Girardi's #2 simply because he's the 3rd most experienced starter on the team and his name isn't Moehler?