Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins offer Benitez one year

Featured Replies

I'm willing to make a sizable wager that Pavano has nowhere near the year he had last year. As a matter of fact, ill go on to say, he'll be closer to .500 or even have a losing record because he's maddeningly inconsistent. Every time he pitches all i see is the game in Boston where he gives up nothing....I want Hudson more then even Leiter because we don't need no one year rentals.

 

Sign Mando and Jacque Jones

Trade for Hudson

We'll be NL East Champs.

and Benitez and Leiter gives us a team that will be no less competitve than we were this season (because IMO Leiter > Pavano),

621445[/snapback]

 

 

I pretty much agree with everything you say except for this part. In no way can it be argued that Pavano is better than Leiter. Pavano's biggest success last year was how deep he went into games. He protected our weak bullpen especially in the middle innings. Leiter who cannot throw more than 5 or maybe 6 innings is worse. He is much older and doesn't have the stuff that Pavano has. We would be closer to even if we signed Clement to replace Pavano.

Of course he's our best option at catcher and he's the best option of alot of teams and that's why he's over-valued, the point is that he is not the best option by far. it reamins to be seen but if LoDuca secures a contract anywhere near the arbitration numbers floating around of 6 - 8 million a season then he is not worth it. If we keep LoDuca we are stuck with Encarnacion, LoDuca is our last bargaining chip. The Red Sox are the ideal team to ship LoDuca to, they have the dough, they don't have prospects to try and get any other available catcher in the league. Try and package Encarnacion and maybe through in a million and you just cleared alot of room to sign a real offensive contribution to the team.

 

 

As far as getting both Leiter and Hudson not only is that not feasible it doesn't make any sense. Hudson will price himself way beyond the Marlins' budget after the season and he will collect on that. And in one year we will have to fill his void again and then realize how big of a mistake it was to give away our trop prospects to market him in Teal for one year.

 

Leiter is in no way better than Pavano. Pavano on top of being in Cy Young contention also ate alot of innings. With Saenz gone, Spooney coming back from TJ and everyone but Mota a question mark it's going to be more imperative than ever to have some starting pitchers that can go the distance. I'd like to have Leiter and I think 6 - 7 million is a reasonable rate to retain his services and how much he should probably get, but he will be lucky to get 6 innings never mind 7 or 8 innings every start. If you think Leiter can duplicate what Pavano did last year you are mistaken.

 

Benitez, Leiter, Conine, LoDuca, Encarnacion, Lowell

 

That's alot of guys aren't bargains...small market /low revenue teams whatever you want to call it can't have too many guys on the team that aren't bargains.

621484[/snapback]

 

 

 

We also have to consider what viable options we have to fill in with. If we continue to trade for mid-season help, it will leave the farm system bare and the Marlins out of contention. Easley and Mota will back for atleast one more year. Beyond that, we need to see where we are strong and where we are weak down on the farm. If we are strong in one area, it might be okay to take a flyer on a major leaguer with questionable durability or performance at that position. If we are weak, we must absolutly avoid another Logan Kensing situation.

 

Starting pitching: We have very few prospects I'd trust 20 starts and 120 innings with. Maybe Justin Wayne, Nate Bump or Trevor Hutchinson if conditioned as starters and given the 5th job out of camp. All of our prospects who have the talent to turn in solid seasons for us have yet to pitch a game in AA or AAA (Kensing was the third-best prospect on that Jupiter club last year and was brought up only because of his sinking fastball and maturity). Right now, we are weak at this position although we should be strong for many years into the future.

 

Relief pitching: Randy Messenger should be ready and has good stuff. He coud be a nice third option. As relievers, Yorman Bazardo or Taylor Tankersley could be rushed to the majors sooner than their peers. There are many players who could match the performance of Perisho or Seanez. A short list: Hutchinson, Bump, Franklyn Gracesqui, Ben Howard and Mike McNutt. Neither a strength or a weakness. A lot of former top prospects who have lost their way and could be solid middle relievers.

 

Catching: Not necessarily the defensive position, but, hey, our 2004/2005 starter can't block the plate and our 2003 starter couldn't call a game. Josh Willingham destroyed the top pitching prospects in the AA Southern League, one of the toughest pitcher's leagues in the minors, this past year. At 26 he's not a 'franchise catcher' in the way Pudge was for the Rangers or the Molinas project to be. Amazingly his career path resembles LoDuca's very much (held back because of injuries and defensive concerns). While Willingham is far from perfect and we lacking depth behind him, this is a position of stength for us.

 

Infield: With Castillo, Gonzalez, Lowell with Easley and Cabrera in reserve, does it matter? Yes. Lowell suffered a significant injury 15 months ago. Gonzalez is in the final year of his contract and could be the #1 SS on the market (it's a weak class next year) if he'd make more contact. Castillo is showing signs of slowing down. The good news is that slick-fielding shortstops who hit .250 with some pop are a dime a dozen. Josh Wilson may not have the upside of most, but he is certainly a capable stop-gap and worthy of a look at reserve infielder. Robert Andino hit for .281 in AA last year without any sort of power or plate discipline. The rest of the cast are older fringe prospects. This is a weakness and needs to be addressed although the draft. However it should not hurt the Marlins this year.

 

Outfield/First Base: Chris Aguila was our only first-year player to play significant innings last year. While he tended to strike out more than we liked, he showed some promise and has passed Chip Ambres and others . Derek Wathan is suffering through Kevin Millar syndrome. Every time you hit .300 you repeat that level the year. OK, not exactly. Millar had to repeat AA and AAA while Wathan has been in AAA for three years and hit .300 just once in his professional career, but .280 and .296 is close enough. At the very least he would be an upgrade over Lenny Harris or Mike Mordecai at pinch-hitter or utilityman. Beinfest expects our top prospect, RF Jermey Hermida, to be ready late 2005. That seems a little too soon for a guy coming off an injury-plagued season. Jason Stokes receives high accoclades for his "light-tower power" and deservingly so. But we've been down this road before, it's called: "Josh Windmill Booty Freeway". Other talented athletes include Jai Miller and speedster Eric Reed. While there are many questionmarks, this is our strongest and deepest position. However we might be letting the fact Aguila hit major league pitching well over the final week overshadow tha talents of others who were never given a chance.

Benitez, Leiter, Hudson.

 

We get two of those three, and I'm giddy about our chances for next year.

621435[/snapback]

 

Our offense still isn't all that...I don't see the improvement in the overall team. It's the equivalent of keeping the former team together. The Sox called to inquire about LoDuca but Beinfest hasn't shown any interest in trading his over-rated azz. Our offense needs a serious improvement. LoDuca and his substandard defense, with his .280 average and 9 homers next season isn't going to merit anything close to what he is expected to get.

621440[/snapback]

 

Stop hating on Lo Duca so much people. He's better than anything we could get, so that means he has to stay if we want to remain competitive. We're not going to give him an arbitration number, we're going to try to get a 2-3 year deal done so we can control his salary. Also, his whole career was in a pitchers park that's unforgiving to right handed hitters, at the very least, Lo Duca is in a better park for his hitting style.

 

And yeah, I agree that the offense still isn't a threat that makes other pitchers wake up in cold-sweats, but a healthy Conine and Encarnacion will be better than an injured Conine and Encarnacion, so there's room for improvement. Not to mention that Lowell and Luis will be better next year...and Cabrera will keep improving.

 

My point is that since 1-8 our lineup is locked in for next year (Lo Duca isn't, but he's not going anywhere), the only places we can spend are the 3 starter and the 5 starter and the bullpen. If we were to get Leiter and Hudson, we'd have the best rotation in the majors, if we were to get Benitez and Hudson, we'd be built for the playoffs with some serious power pitching in the rotation and bullpen, and Benitez and Leiter gives us a team that will be no less competitve than we were this season (because IMO Leiter > Pavano), and as long as Beckett/Burnett stay healthy, I think that means we're at least playing meaningful games into September.

621445[/snapback]

 

Of course he's our best option at catcher and he's the best option of alot of teams and that's why he's over-valued, the point is that he is not the best option by far. it reamins to be seen but if LoDuca secures a contract anywhere near the arbitration numbers floating around of 6 - 8 million a season then he is not worth it. If we keep LoDuca we are stuck with Encarnacion, LoDuca is our last bargaining chip. The Red Sox are the ideal team to ship LoDuca to, they have the dough, they don't have prospects to try and get any other available catcher in the league. Try and package Encarnacion and maybe through in a million and you just cleared alot of room to sign a real offensive contribution to the team.

 

 

As far as getting both Leiter and Hudson not only is that not feasible it doesn't make any sense. Hudson will price himself way beyond the Marlins' budget after the season and he will collect on that. And in one year we will have to fill his void again and then realize how big of a mistake it was to give away our trop prospects to market him in Teal for one year.

 

Leiter is in no way better than Pavano. Pavano on top of being in Cy Young contention also ate alot of innings. With Saenz gone, Spooney coming back from TJ and everyone but Mota a question mark it's going to be more imperative than ever to have some starting pitchers that can go the distance. I'd like to have Leiter and I think 6 - 7 million is a reasonable rate to retain his services and how much he should probably get, but he will be lucky to get 6 innings never mind 7 or 8 innings every start. If you think Leiter can duplicate what Pavano did last year you are mistaken.

 

Benitez, Leiter, Conine, LoDuca, Encarnacion, Lowell

 

That's alot of guys aren't bargains...small market /low revenue teams whatever you want to call it can't have too many guys on the team that aren't bargains.

621484[/snapback]

One problem with your theory. Jason Varitek appears to be resigning with the Sox and Doug Mirabelli can start and he isn't any slouch if Varitek left.

621489[/snapback]

 

 

The Sox had called Beinfest about LoDuca recently, so I doubt they and Tek and are moving forward with the negotiations. Tek is looking for 5 years at 50 million. I'd laugh in his face if I was Epstein.

Benitez, Leiter, Hudson.

 

We get two of those three, and I'm giddy about our chances for next year.

621435[/snapback]

 

Our offense still isn't all that...I don't see the improvement in the overall team. It's the equivalent of keeping the former team together. The Sox called to inquire about LoDuca but Beinfest hasn't shown any interest in trading his over-rated azz. Our offense needs a serious improvement. LoDuca and his substandard defense, with his .280 average and 9 homers next season isn't going to merit anything close to what he is expected to get.

621440[/snapback]

 

Stop hating on Lo Duca so much people. He's better than anything we could get, so that means he has to stay if we want to remain competitive. We're not going to give him an arbitration number, we're going to try to get a 2-3 year deal done so we can control his salary. Also, his whole career was in a pitchers park that's unforgiving to right handed hitters, at the very least, Lo Duca is in a better park for his hitting style.

 

And yeah, I agree that the offense still isn't a threat that makes other pitchers wake up in cold-sweats, but a healthy Conine and Encarnacion will be better than an injured Conine and Encarnacion, so there's room for improvement. Not to mention that Lowell and Luis will be better next year...and Cabrera will keep improving.

 

My point is that since 1-8 our lineup is locked in for next year (Lo Duca isn't, but he's not going anywhere), the only places we can spend are the 3 starter and the 5 starter and the bullpen. If we were to get Leiter and Hudson, we'd have the best rotation in the majors, if we were to get Benitez and Hudson, we'd be built for the playoffs with some serious power pitching in the rotation and bullpen, and Benitez and Leiter gives us a team that will be no less competitve than we were this season (because IMO Leiter > Pavano), and as long as Beckett/Burnett stay healthy, I think that means we're at least playing meaningful games into September.

621445[/snapback]

 

Of course he's our best option at catcher and he's the best option of alot of teams and that's why he's over-valued, the point is that he is not the best option by far. it reamins to be seen but if LoDuca secures a contract anywhere near the arbitration numbers floating around of 6 - 8 million a season then he is not worth it. If we keep LoDuca we are stuck with Encarnacion, LoDuca is our last bargaining chip. The Red Sox are the ideal team to ship LoDuca to, they have the dough, they don't have prospects to try and get any other available catcher in the league. Try and package Encarnacion and maybe through in a million and you just cleared alot of room to sign a real offensive contribution to the team.

 

 

As far as getting both Leiter and Hudson not only is that not feasible it doesn't make any sense. Hudson will price himself way beyond the Marlins' budget after the season and he will collect on that. And in one year we will have to fill his void again and then realize how big of a mistake it was to give away our trop prospects to market him in Teal for one year.

 

Leiter is in no way better than Pavano. Pavano on top of being in Cy Young contention also ate alot of innings. With Saenz gone, Spooney coming back from TJ and everyone but Mota a question mark it's going to be more imperative than ever to have some starting pitchers that can go the distance. I'd like to have Leiter and I think 6 - 7 million is a reasonable rate to retain his services and how much he should probably get, but he will be lucky to get 6 innings never mind 7 or 8 innings every start. If you think Leiter can duplicate what Pavano did last year you are mistaken.

 

Benitez, Leiter, Conine, LoDuca, Encarnacion, Lowell

 

That's alot of guys aren't bargains...small market /low revenue teams whatever you want to call it can't have too many guys on the team that aren't bargains.

621484[/snapback]

 

It's stupid to debate this because Lo Duca isn't going anywhere, but Lo Duca and Encarnacion will be a greater offensive contribution than Treanor and any of the outfielders we'd be in the running for. Don't even say JD Drew or Magglio or Beltran, not only could we not afford them if we're using your Hudson logic, they likely wouldn't want to play here after seeing our track record for trading away key pieces in the offseason.

 

And Leiter is a hell of a lot better than Pavano. Yes, Pavano's 2004 was statistically better than Leiter's, but not by as much as you'd think:

 

Leiter was 10-8 with a 3.21 ERA (ERA for a starter is more evaluatory than for a reliever), opponents hit .218 off of him, he started 30 games, averaged 109 pitches per start, and he had a K/9 of 6.09. He also only allowed 65 runs, and 16 HR's.

 

Pavano was 18-8 with a 3.00 ERA, but he had a K/9 of 5.63 and he allowed 80 runs in 31 games, averaging 102 pitches and opponents hit .253 off of him. Like Leiter, he also only allowed 16 HR's. But while Pavano pitched only about 50 innings more, he allowed about 80 more hits than Leiter.

 

Not to mention that since 2000 Leiter has essentially put up identical numbers, so it's hard to say he's in decline, and since the 2002 season, he's lowered his ERA, and his 2004 ERA was his lowest since 2000. That's called consistency. Pavano's just been frustratingly inconsistent. Leiter > Pavano.

621507[/snapback]

 

 

We wouldn't be in the hunt for Drew and Ordonez? Encarnacion and LoDuca will make easily 9 - 10 million combined next season, probably more. The biggest spenders aren't going to go after those two, the Yanks, Sox, Angels don't need either of them. And thinking that they won't sign with the Marlins because of our history is no more credible than thinking that every latino in baseball will sign with us at discounted benefits because we are in Miami. As far as my 'Hudson' logic, the analogy doesn't hold any water. Hudson would only be here for one year and in order to get him we would have to give up top prospects. So if he didn't resign, we'd suffer a huge setback. Without any certainty of whether or not Hudson could stay that trade would be horrible. What's the worse that can happen if Drew or Ordonez say no? Plus it's obvious that at this point without having committed to Benitez, LoDuca, or Pavano we have a bit more available resources than we will at this point next season if we bring back Enc, LoDuca, Benitez and possibly Leiter. If we are going to give out big contracts it has to be now when we still have the option of replacing a few pieces.

 

If we can't do better that's fine, we're stuck with them but Beinfest should be trying to improve this offense and giving wads of money to LoDuca isn't one of them. I'd take Treanor/Willingham and Drew over LoDuca and Encarnacion any day of the week.

 

You are looking at the situation all wrong with the Leiter, Pavano comparisons. In order to judge what kind of performance we should expect from the Marlins' staff next year you look at what statistical pieces can be replaced. Even if we resigned Pavano I doubt he would be able to match his stats from last year and we might take a hit there next season. But to think that Leiter will come close to what Pavano did last season is laughable. You can bring up all the stats you want but the most important are ERA and in my mind innings.

 

You can argue that he had a higher K/IP but that fact backfires because power pitchers like Leiter need to throw more pitches and as a result you get a guy that on a good day might go all of 6 innings. Secondly, why does this stat matter when you are a 39 year old pitcher???? The stat serves best in evaluating young talent, before MLB and in the early years in the bigs...it might serve a bit of use in making sure to put a pitcher with a low K/IP on a good defensive infield so it's not really an issue even in that sense. Plus we have only one capable returning starter next season in our pen, and that's Mota...with Burnett and Beckett's track history Leiter's short outings aren't going to help much. There was a reason he had only 17 decisions last season and part of that was because he couldn't log enough innings in many games.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.