Everything posted by PhishPhan
-
FO Out to Lunch
Yes they did, with key components of the previous administration. This is UNC before UNC was UNC. They had a World Series team and turned it into a third place NL East team. 745779[/snapback] Your boy Pudge wasn't here. 745782[/snapback] I didn't say all of them. Ugie wasn't here either. But a lot of the pieces were. Cabs. Josh, Louie, D-Lee, Seabass, etc. The FO built a team around what the old guys left behind, but this FO hasn't done anything completely on its own, and they also haven't shown they know how to or can field a playoff team annually. The old administration didn't either, but I am not calling them good either, just saying they left key pieces to the 2003 team behind. Who has this administration drafted, or signed? The next Beckett? Cabs? Etc.? Right now our best prospects include a couple mid to late 20 years olds. 745793[/snapback] Oh, so the FO didn't do everything. Neither did Lee. 745802[/snapback] I never said Lee or Pudge did everything. I am just saying that people really should second guess the FO for letting Pudge and D-Lee go. D-Lee would have cost us about what we just signed Paulie too, and Pudge would have cost us less than what we signed Delgado to. And for people who say he didn't have money at the time, how do you explain we had money this year figuring Loria says he lost money last year, meaning he had less money to start this year? 745813[/snapback] Over the long run, we still get way more value for Delgado with his contract because 4 years in Miami at Catcher will tear one down. At 35-36, Pudge would be ineffective and probably won't produce near where Carlos will be able to produce at 35-36. 745819[/snapback] So care to explain what the FO was thinking of signing Lo Duca long term then?
-
FO Out to Lunch
Blame bad pitching and playing in the division with the two juggernauts sort of skews the ability to make the playoffs, no? That'd be like saying the 2003 Marlins were losers because they didn't win the regular-season Division crown. 745809[/snapback] True, but he still never made it. Anyway Lowell hit .196/.275/.348 in the playoffs and we gave him a long term contract. :whistle
-
FO Out to Lunch
Yes they did, with key components of the previous administration. This is UNC before UNC was UNC. They had a World Series team and turned it into a third place NL East team. 745779[/snapback] Your boy Pudge wasn't here. 745782[/snapback] I didn't say all of them. Ugie wasn't here either. But a lot of the pieces were. Cabs. Josh, Louie, D-Lee, Seabass, etc. The FO built a team around what the old guys left behind, but this FO hasn't done anything completely on its own, and they also haven't shown they know how to or can field a playoff team annually. The old administration didn't either, but I am not calling them good either, just saying they left key pieces to the 2003 team behind. Who has this administration drafted, or signed? The next Beckett? Cabs? Etc.? Right now our best prospects include a couple mid to late 20 years olds. 745793[/snapback] Oh, so the FO didn't do everything. Neither did Lee. 745802[/snapback] I never said Lee or Pudge did everything. I am just saying that people really should second guess the FO for letting Pudge and D-Lee go. D-Lee would have cost us about what we just signed Paulie too, and Pudge would have cost us less than what we signed Delgado to. And for people who say he didn't have money at the time, how do you explain we had money this year figuring Loria says he lost money last year, meaning he had less money to start this year?
-
FO Out to Lunch
D-Lee: 2005: Runners on- .300/.609/.933 RISP- .667/.800/1.333 RISP w/ 2 out- .500/.667/.750 2004: Runners on- .302/.387/.550 RISP- .276/.382/.531 RISP w/ 2 out- .230/.427/.410 Bases load- .357/.333/.929 If you get the hits that matter early there is no "close and late". :thumbup What did he do as a Marlin, before he hit in a hitter's park behind two feared hitters and one of the best hitting third baseman in baseball? 745770[/snapback] Won a World Series. 745773[/snapback] Derrek Lee's 2003 playoff stats: .208 BA/.269 OBP/.292 SLG 1 HR 8 RBI 2 SB Obviously, he's quite clutch. :plain 745800[/snapback] What's Carlos's? Oh nevermind he is a career loser. :mischief
-
FO Out to Lunch
Yes they did, with key components of the previous administration. This is UNC before UNC was UNC. They had a World Series team and turned it into a third place NL East team. 745779[/snapback] Your boy Pudge wasn't here. 745782[/snapback] I didn't say all of them. Ugie wasn't here either. But a lot of the pieces were. Cabs. Josh, Louie, D-Lee, Seabass, etc. The FO built a team around what the old guys left behind, but this FO hasn't done anything completely on its own, and they also haven't shown they know how to or can field a playoff team annually. The old administration didn't either, but I am not calling them good either, just saying they left key pieces to the 2003 team behind. Who has this administration drafted, or signed? The next Beckett? Cabs? Etc.? Right now our best prospects include a couple mid to late 20 years olds.
-
FO Out to Lunch
D-Lee: 2005: Runners on- .300/.609/.933 RISP- .667/.800/1.333 RISP w/ 2 out- .500/.667/.750 2004: Runners on- .302/.387/.550 RISP- .276/.382/.531 RISP w/ 2 out- .230/.427/.410 Bases load- .357/.333/.929 If you get the hits that matter early there is no "close and late". :thumbup What did he do as a Marlin, before he hit in a hitter's park behind two feared hitters and one of the best hitting third baseman in baseball? 745770[/snapback] Won a World Series. 745773[/snapback] So did the FO. 745776[/snapback] Yes they did, with key components of the previous administration. This is UNC before UNC was UNC. They had a World Series team and turned it into a third place NL East team.
-
FO Out to Lunch
D-Lee: 2005: Runners on- .300/.609/.933 RISP- .667/.800/1.333 RISP w/ 2 out- .500/.667/.750 2004: Runners on- .302/.387/.550 RISP- .276/.382/.531 RISP w/ 2 out- .230/.427/.410 Bases load- .357/.333/.929 If you get the hits that matter early there is no "close and late". :thumbup What did he do as a Marlin, before he hit in a hitter's park behind two feared hitters and one of the best hitting third baseman in baseball? 745770[/snapback] Won a World Series.
-
FO Out to Lunch
You can't argue with someone who's premise is purposely based on a false assumption and ignores the realities of what transpired around it. It's a waste of time. For example while it's true Delgado has committed three errors he purposely, with forethought simply to further his ugly rant, he ignores the fact that two of those errors were committed on one play. Or that it was fiscally impossible for the Marlins to commit almost $65 million to Rodriguez and Lee in the beginning of 2004 with Hampton and Pudge still owed nearly $25 million over the next two years (see why Delgado and Leiter are playing for peanuts this year), or his false assumption that the LA trade didn't load up the team for a run at the playoffs last season when everyone knows the major reason the Marlins didn't have an honest chance to play in October was four hurricanes which burdened the team's schedule to the point where they had to play 31 games in 29 days not to mention playing "home games" in Chicago and exhausting the players. So you guys can keep arguing with this hater or you come to your senses and ignore him. Make your own choice, I've made mine. 745745[/snapback] They are still paying Hampton and Pudge this year, much like last year, but they were able to sign Delgado and Al, as well as guys for the pen. Loria said he lost money last year, so if anything he had less money this year than starting 2004. To say it was impossible to sign Pudge and Lee to start 2004 versus signing everyone they did this year to start 2005 makes me scratch my head since Loria says he has less money this year than last year, if anything he should have cut payroll if he is sturggling financially so much. Truth of the matter is, the FO took a gamble, decided D-Lee and Pudge were good pieces, but the Marlins could do things without them, and they didn't. And once again, a fan on here blames something other than the players, coaches, umps, etc. etc. etc. Just another thing to hang everything on.
-
FO Out to Lunch
LEE CANNOT HIT WHEN IT COUNTS. 745705[/snapback] Isn't it Bill Robinson's fault? At least a lot of people on here try to tell me the inability to hit when it matters is the hitting coach's fault. 745731[/snapback] Well, at least you're effectively admitting defeat. Lee couldn't hit ever when it counts, even before Robinson got here :thumbup 745741[/snapback] D-Lee: 2005: Runners on- .300/.609/.933 RISP- .667/.800/1.333 RISP w/ 2 out- .500/.667/.750 2004: Runners on- .302/.387/.550 RISP- .276/.382/.531 RISP w/ 2 out- .230/.427/.410 Bases load- .357/.333/.929 If you get the hits that matter early there is no "close and late". :thumbup
-
FO Out to Lunch
LEE CANNOT HIT WHEN IT COUNTS. 745705[/snapback] Isn't it Bill Robinson's fault? At least a lot of people on here try to tell me the inability to hit when it matters is the hitting coach's fault.
-
FO Out to Lunch
It wasnt a huge improvement. 745707[/snapback] Were they a WS team with Nomar and no Dougie M.?
-
FO Out to Lunch
First basemen normally have a longer "life" span than catchers do so thats where the age fits in 745698[/snapback] 1 year down and Pudge did very very good. He's thinned up, and started this year pretty solidly as well.
-
FO Out to Lunch
PhishPhan The 2004 Boston Red Sox and defense? 745680[/snapback] When did they get better? When they got rid of Nomar and got Doug M. at first, no?
-
FO Out to Lunch
you're really a dumbass tool phishphan. go back to being a braves fan. and then go here: http://sports.espn.go.com/mlbhist/players/...75&type=batting and scroll all the way to the bottom where it says close and late which is obviously when it matters and check out D-Lee's stats for the last three years. 745649[/snapback] http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/spli...78&type=batting Go here and look at Carlos's and you tell me if you see a huge jump worth millions and millions of dollars over the next 4 years paying the guy until he is 36. 745663[/snapback] yeah they look pretty damn good to me. you argue that we gave Carlos too lengthy of a contract but yet you wanted us to give Pudge what he wanted. You make no sense. Pudge demanded 4 years. If the FO gave it to him he would have been playing until he was 36 at CATCHER no less which is much more demanding than First Base. You're all over the place with your criticism of the FO and it gets real old real fast. They ain't perfect but every front office makes mistakes. 745676[/snapback] But see that is where the problem with the FO lies, you pointed it out exactly. They didn't want to pay a catcher until he was 36, but they are okay with paying a first baseman MORE until he is 36. I think if they wanted to pay someone until they were 36 you go with the proven guy who was a spark plug on your way to a championship. Instead they went with an unproven guy in their park and in the NL and with their players, not knowing how he'd interact, for more money and just as long.
-
FO Out to Lunch
you're really a dumbass tool phishphan. go back to being a braves fan. and then go here: http://sports.espn.go.com/mlbhist/players/...75&type=batting and scroll all the way to the bottom where it says close and late which is obviously when it matters and check out D-Lee's stats for the last three years. 745649[/snapback] http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/spli...78&type=batting Go here and look at Carlos's and you tell me if you see a huge jump worth millions and millions of dollars over the next 4 years paying the guy until he is 36. 745663[/snapback] It isnt just about stats. Stats dont say the whole story. Heck I dont know, maybe Delgado is a stat padder too but his name alone helps this team out so much more than DLee could. 745666[/snapback] Well he brought them up, I just wanted to show him that 20 points in your average may not be worth how ever millions of dollars extra we paid Delgado than we could have paid D-Lee, not to mention the difference in defense. All I know the 2004 Marlins offense was a lot like the 2003 Marlins offense, just minus D-Lee and Pudge, and look at the world of difference.
-
FO Out to Lunch
The answer is right there. If you don't understand it, that is your own problem. You inability to read is shocking. I answered the question a number of posts ago. 745652[/snapback] No, see, I want a simple answer. You've been answering but spinning. I want a name, with nothing before, and nothing after - or is that not in your power? Not even Shammy would defend Lee against Delgado. 745658[/snapback] But the thing about baseball is it is more than just hitting. You play defense too. If you lose meaning of words inside of a sentence I pity you. The 2003 Marlins and the 2004 Red Sox were both teams with sound defenses. Having a 1b commit 3 errors in 11 games is not exactly the healthiest thing in the world. Carlos is better than D-Lee right not batting, but million and millions of dollars better? I don't know that. And will he still be better 4 years from now when he is 36? That might be stretching it.
-
FO Out to Lunch
you're really a dumbass tool phishphan. go back to being a braves fan. and then go here: http://sports.espn.go.com/mlbhist/players/...75&type=batting and scroll all the way to the bottom where it says close and late which is obviously when it matters and check out D-Lee's stats for the last three years. 745649[/snapback] http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/spli...78&type=batting Go here and look at Carlos's and you tell me if you see a huge jump worth millions and millions of dollars over the next 4 years paying the guy until he is 36.
-
FO Out to Lunch
Who do other pitchers fear: Lee or Delgado? Question My poor question, it's still unanswered. 745612[/snapback] Can you not read? Delgado, but if you make 3 errors every 11 games... well you do the math. 745602[/snapback] 745643[/snapback] I can read just fine. Here, read this: Who do other pitchers fear more: Lee or Delgado? 745648[/snapback] Delgado, but if you make 3 errors every 11 games... well you do the math. 745602[/snapback] The answer is right there. If you don't understand it, that is your own problem. You inability to read is shocking. I answered the question a number of posts ago.
-
FO Out to Lunch
Who do other pitchers fear: Lee or Delgado? Question My poor question, it's still unanswered. 745612[/snapback] Can you not read? Delgado, but if you make 3 errors every 11 games... well you do the math. 745602[/snapback]
-
FO Out to Lunch
Phish, you were probably not a fan in 2003, or 02, or 01.... Derrek Lee does not hit when it matters 745607[/snapback] Well thats not D-Lee's fault, its Bill Robinson's... at least that is what I am led to believe on this board. :plain D-Lee: 2005: Runners on- .300/.609/.933 RISP- .667/.800/1.333 RISP w/ 2 out- .500/.667/.750 2004: Runners on- .302/.387/.550 RISP- .276/.382/.531 RISP w/ 2 out- .230/.427/.410 Bases load- .357/.333/.929 Yeah he really stinks when he can get the runs home and it matters. I'd love to see how you spin this Mav.
-
FO Out to Lunch
I didnt like not resigning Pudge but at the time, Ramon Castro was looking like a legit catcher who was ready to break it. Thats not the front office's fault 745574[/snapback] Who do you blame then, the scouts? Someone had to decide along the line that Pudge was washed up and Castro was going to do at least okay. I bet they thought he would do better than what he did.
-
FO Out to Lunch
Delgado is better 1B than Derrek Lee. 745554[/snapback] Offensively. Would you dare say defensively? And how much better? Millions and millions of dollars better? You have to look at the difference we'd pay them. We wouldn't have needed to sign D-Lee for as much as Carlos, I don't think. Is that offensive skill difference big enough to satisfy you? D-Lee proved he is a 30 HR hitter in the Fin, and A+ defensively. 745567[/snapback] Have you been watching Delgado so far? He picks balls almost as effectively as DLee did. If Lee's defense with us was an A+, Delgado's has been an A-. Considering the gap between Delgado's offense and Lee's offense is significantly greater than that, yes, Delgado is worth the money. As I like to do from time to time, let's take one out of the Book of Das: Who do other pitchers fear: Lee or Delgado? Question 745576[/snapback] "Hey Josh, catch this no look pass!" Aww nice try Carlos, that knocks you from an A to an A-. Delgado has 3 errors so far this year D-Lee zero. Delgado, but if you make 3 errors every 11 games... well you do the math. By the end of his contract Delgado will be 36. I doubt his defense will magically get better, and I am sure his bat will slow a bit. D-Lee proved to be much more than adequate in Dolphins Stadium, and he would have come cheaper and provided better defense. The 2003 Marlins and 2004 Red Sox showed that defense is key.
-
FO Out to Lunch
At this point it is very easy to be a Monday morning QB like you. :thumbdown 745560[/snapback] How else would you liked to judge a FO? Only at the time? Because if you do that the sentiments on this board showed after the LA trade last year that we were primed to make another playoff run, time showed that not to be true. And people like to suck up to the FO after the fact for 2003, whats wrong with second guessing them?
-
FO Out to Lunch
Delgado is better 1B than Derrek Lee. 745554[/snapback] Offensively. Would you dare say defensively? And how much better? Millions and millions of dollars better? You have to look at the difference we'd pay them. We wouldn't have needed to sign D-Lee for as much as Carlos, I don't think. Is that offensive skill difference big enough to satisfy you? D-Lee proved he is a 30 HR hitter in the Fin, and A+ defensively.
-
FO Out to Lunch
Derrick Lee 2004: .278/.356/.504 32 HRs 98 RBIs 2005: .324/.447/.568 2 HRs 11 RBIs Pude Rodriguez 2004: .334/.383/.510 19 HRs 86 RBIs 2005: .364/.378/.455 I wonder why anyone would want these guys. :plain 745515[/snapback] DLee's numbers improved because of a stadium change... that and he hits when it dont count... ask most marlins fans and now most cubs fans as for pudge, giving up a 4 year deal is ludacris 745536[/snapback] 98 RBIs is a lot of RBIs for hitting when it doesn't count if you ask me. And if memory serves me right he hit pretty good in Pro Player, at least power wise. And the man knows how to get on base. How long did we sign Lo Duca for? Who's better? Also, what do you think about that Delgado deal? You can defend the FO on this case, but I think they thought they would be able to find replacements, and last year they didn't. This year we'll see.