May 3, 200620 yr ...A week later, let's see if anyone's opinion has changed based on tonight's performances. Each contestant had 2 songs, and I believe each had their own highs and lows. The question is, America--Who do you think deserves to go home? The Contestants: Elliott Yamin Chris Daughtry Katharine McPhee Paris Bennett Taylor Hicks
May 3, 200620 yr Author I think it's either Paris or Chris. Once it gets down to Katharine, Taylor and Elliott, it will be a tough vote. I like all three...but still stand by my decision that Taylor and Elliott will be the final 2.
May 3, 200620 yr probably Paris leaves.... just on a popularity vote at this point. Everyone seemed to do one good song & one not-so-hot. - I didn't care for the Phil Collins song Katherine did, but the other one was very cute. - Taylor's Play That Funky Music White Boy was nothing more than a sing-along, & that's where he gets in danger of being too much silly & not enough singing. His second song was terrific though & Simon noted that very same point. - Paris was okay. Liked her second song better than Kiss by Prince. - Elliot was good, he may be the only one who did 2 good songs actually, although I didn't catch most of his 2nd one. - Chris... I may just be too biased against him to be objective at this point. 1st song was pretty good, 2nd one was typical oversinging & his voice was gone by then.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.