I have a team in an 8 team league. I have Peyton Manning and Donovan Mcnabb for QB's. unfortunately I didnt really consider the fact that Manning didnt play at all during the preseason and would probably be rusty for week 1 and I had him start instead of Mcnabb. I ended up losing my week 1 game and actually would have won if I had started McNabb instead of Manning. so yeah my question is should I keep them both and just start them depending on the matchup? or should I trade one of them to a team who needs a better QB? it's a private league. we play with team defense and individual defense players. it takes 25 passing yards for one point and 10 reception yards for one point. we also get awarded points for return yards. (10 = 1) just giving that out to see if its any help. heres my lineup to see if I should trade for something:

 

QB Peyton Manning

WR TJ Houshmandzedah

WR Greg Jennings

RB Brandon Jacobs

RB Joseph Addai

TE Antonio Gates

W/R Edgerrin James

W/R Hines Ward

BN Donovan Mcnabb

BN Reggie Williams

BN Benjamin Watson

BN Ronnie Brown

BN Roscoe Parish

 

K Stephen Gostkowski

 

DEF New England

 

D Jarred Allen

DB Atari Bigby

DB Antonio Cromartie

DL Patrick Willis

DL Demarcus Ware

Trade McNabb - his value is not going to be higher than it is right now after a dominating performance over an awful Rams team.

 

Peyton may have been rusty but he is now the no1 QB in fantasy with Brady out so I would start Manning every week, regardless of the match-up

Trade McNabb - his value is not going to be higher than it is right now after a dominating performance over an awful Rams team.

 

Peyton may have been rusty but he is now the no1 QB in fantasy with Brady out so I would start Manning every week, regardless of the match-up

 

yeah I was thinking about that. I messed up and didnt finish posting my lineup. check it out now and see what I should go for. I'm still a casual football fan and this is only my 2nd year playing fantasy fb, so I am not too knowledgable in it. thanks

Make sure when you trade McNabb, you get a good backup QB for Peytons bye week and incase he gets hurt.