As some of you are aware, White Sox Interactive has either banned or suspended the Marlins fans at their forum for the high crimes of (A) sticking up for the Billy Koch trade and (B) sticking up for the Marlins ownership. What you probably are not aware of is that over the years a lot of White Sox fans have also been banned or suspended for simply disagreeing with the positions taken by the alleged moderators there while others, such as myself, have quit posting there. Actually, those moderators are really trolls under any other name.
Here?s a case in point from last fall. After Sox GM Kenny Williams traded career minor leaguer Aaron Miles to the Colorado Rockies for Juan Uribe, there was a great hue and cry amongst Sox fans certain that this was a horrible trade, that the Sox had been ?fleeced.? Well, I looked at the Rockies websites and forums and found that Rockies fans were equally conviced that their team was the one that was ?fleeced? and talked to a couple Rockies fans of my acquaintance who believed that Uribe was a much better player than his stats indicated and that they thought that Uribe was a continually improving player who was literally on the verge of greatness.
Well, I listened to what the Rockies fans had to say and after looking through Uribe?s record in the major and minor leagues and whatever else I could come up with, I decided that they were right. Juan Uribe really was a major pick-up for the White Sox. That being the case, I wrote up a post that summarized my conclusions and placed it on the WSI Forum in the form of a new thread..
The next day, I checked the WSI Forum and found that my post/new thread was missing. I then saw that I had received a msg from one of the moderators. I was informed that my post/thread had been deleted and that if I did that sort of thing again, I would be banned from the forum. In the follow-up, it was revealed that the moderator had determined that my post had been made with the intent of creating controversy on the forum and not for any legitimate reason. In other words, my Uribe post was the work of a troll, not a serious Sox fan.
Now, you are probably wondering just what kind of sense that makes. Well, its like this. The feeling amongst the WSI Staff was that Uribe was a dud, that the GM had screwed up big time was pretty much universal. In other words, there was a consensus, the idea that Uribe was worthless was the conventional wisdom among the WSI Staff. In the view of the staff, everyone who was any sort of legitimate Sox fan ?knew? that this was a bad trade. Therefore, the only persons who would post that this was a great trade, that Uribe was a good player with the potential for greatness, just had to be a troll. Only a troll would write such a post. Since trolls and troll activities have to be severely regulated, the moderator believed that my Uribe post had to be deleted. From what I've heard from other Sox fans, there have been a number of other instances of posts/threads being deleted at WSI simply because they went against the conventional wisdom as defined by the WSI Staff.
Its because of nonsense like this (which has only gotten worse with the passage of time) that I decided to quit posting at WSI. The WSI moderators are often no better than trolls and other delinquents. If anything, the WSI moderators often engage in behavior that?s worse than the crime.