Edwin seems like a kinda stubborn manager. Does he think this team is winning early on because of the line up? I mean, having an automatic out hitting second is fantastic.
For now, the line up should be, in my opinion:
Bonifacio
Coghlan
Hanley
Sanchez
Stanton
Dobbs
Buck
Infante
pitcher
When Morrison gets back, you can move guy around again, but for the love god, WHY SO STUBBORN?????
I agree his lineup is terrible, he has a hitter hitting .300 with an almost .400 OBP batting 8th!?! WHO does that?
IMO the lineup should be
Bonifacio
Infante
Coghlan
Stanton
Sanchez
Ramirez
Dobbs
Buck
pitcher
Stanton should always be before our best hitter, a pitcher should never want to try and pitch around Stanton. Putting Gaby/LoMo after Stanton puts pressure on the pitcher to throw strikes at Stanton to not want to face Gaby/LoMo. Rookies should not be put in situations where they will be pitched around, that does not help them time strikes from major league pitchers.
We can all agree that Stanton has had almost nothing good to hit all year. And the few times he does get a good pitch usually he is completely fooled by it.
I don't get why Edwin dropped Mike from clean up so fast but has left Hanley who looks worse everyday at the plate batting 3rd for a month now.
in 36 PA in the cleanup spot Stanton has 6 hits 4 doubles. 0 HR, 3 RBI and an OBP of .250
in 34 PA in the 5 hole, Stanton has 9 hits, 1 double, 1 triple, 3 HR, 7 RBI and an OBP of .382
mind u a very small sample size, but he's hitting better 5th and has looked a lot more comfortable at the plate. and its not like gaby is doing a bad job there
Like you stated the sample size is rather small and Gaby will do good batting in any slot. Stanton started out slow last year also, it looks like he needs time to get his timing right. I also dont think him looking more comfortable has anything to do with his spot in the lineup. I feel he has just seen more pitches and is getting his timing down. He will see a ton more hittable pitches at cleanup and that is ultimately what we want to see him get.