April 23, 200422 yr http://www.forums.mlb.com/n/mb/message.asp...g=10540.1&ctx=0 "Match them up player for player. You've gotta go with the Phils. Phils have 1B, C, LF, RF. Marlins have 3B, CF and SS. 2B is a wash. Starting pitching is even and bullpen pure talent wise belongs to the Phils. Phils were the team with four 14 game winners. The Phillies' set up man had 38 saves last year. Hernandez is an experienced middle reliever and Wagner is the second best closer in the game at this point. NO pre-season magazine had the Marlins rated ahead of the Phils. I guess they're all closet Phillies' fans. Even last year the Phils were better statistically. The same ERA and the Phils had more runs scored. The stone cold truth is if the Phillies play ball, the Marlins don't make the playoffs this year. Even a deficit in talent does not acount for 2-17." How can any real baseball fan say that bobby abreu is a better player than Miguel Cabrera. And last i checked burrel was overrated, and him and niner are a wash. Sorry Luis Castillo is a better second baseman any day of the week. I will give them the c and 1b. And then say that the marlins pitching staff doesnt even compare is a joke. The phillies are a joke, there fans are a joke. They are some of the worst informed fans i have seen. And i love the quote about the Phillies being a better team statiscally, cuz all i care about is this statistic, WS titles won last year Fla 1, Phi 0. I think thats about as important of a stat as u get
April 23, 200422 yr I think the problem with their fans is that the Marlins have beat up on their team so much that it has sent them into a state of fantasy & denial. Seriously. Reading through some of that is scary. But, then again, it is a MLB.com message board, pretty much any baseball fan can go on it. Hell, look at the fish's MLB.com message board, it's not exactly the greatest board in the world most of the time, i prefer this board anyday. I remember someone saying that the fans on this board are to the marlins what the Raider Nation is to the Raiders, etc. I'm sure most Phillies fans aren't like those on that MLB.com message board.
April 23, 200422 yr I never understood the hype over the Phillies either. They have the best player of either team (Thome), but the top of our lineup is twice as good. They don't have as many power threats as we do in the middle of the lineup and bottom of the order is pretty even. Defensively the Marlins have the upperhand. Starting pitching you could make a case for being split mainly because our starters haven't always lived up to their talent. Relief pitching, well, coming into the season they had the edge but bullpens are very overrated. They only pitch a third or less of the game and are often inconsistent year-after-year. What's really amazing about our club is that while everyone raves about the pitching our lineup is the best in the division and better than anyone in the NL not named the Cardinals.
April 23, 200422 yr I think the problem with their fans is that the Marlins have beat up on their team so much that it has sent them into a state of fantasy & denial. Seriously. Reading through some of that is scary. But, then again, it is a MLB.com message board, pretty much any baseball fan can go on it. Hell, look at the fish's MLB.com message board, it's not exactly the greatest board in the world most of the time, i prefer this board anyday. I remember someone saying that the fans on this board are to the marlins what the Raider Nation is to the Raiders, etc. I'm sure most Phillies fans aren't like those on that MLB.com message board. Philaphans.com has a very defeatist attitude as well. That's Philly pro sports.
April 23, 200422 yr http://www.forums.mlb.com/n/mb/message.asp...g=10540.1&ctx=0 "Match them up player for player. You've gotta go with the Phils. Phils have 1B, C, LF, RF. Marlins have 3B, CF and SS. 2B is a wash. Starting pitching is even and bullpen pure talent wise belongs to the Phils. Phils were the team with four 14 game winners. The Phillies' set up man had 38 saves last year. Hernandez is an experienced middle reliever and Wagner is the second best closer in the game at this point. NO pre-season magazine had the Marlins rated ahead of the Phils. I guess they're all closet Phillies' fans. Even last year the Phils were better statistically. The same ERA and the Phils had more runs scored. The stone cold truth is if the Phillies play ball, the Marlins don't make the playoffs this year. Even a deficit in talent does not acount for 2-17." How can any real baseball fan say that bobby abreu is a better player than Miguel Cabrera. And last i checked burrel was overrated, and him and niner are a wash. Sorry Luis Castillo is a better second baseman any day of the week. I will give them the c and 1b. And then say that the marlins pitching staff doesnt even compare is a joke. The phillies are a joke, there fans are a joke. They are some of the worst informed fans i have seen. And i love the quote about the Phillies being a better team statiscally, cuz all i care about is this statistic, WS titles won last year Fla 1, Phi 0. I think thats about as important of a stat as u get World Series titles all time won: Marlins 2 Phillies 1 To Phillie Fans: Talk to us when you win your second World Series.
April 24, 200422 yr You know, the Phillies missed a golden opportunity when it came time to naming that new park of theirs. It should've been Lifebuoy Field :shifty (Ask a local if you don't know what that's about)
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.