Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Yankees-Red Sox

Featured Replies

you basically proved another point: how much of a rivalry is it when one team comes out on top?

In recent years the Yanks and Sox have had more moments, but historically

Let's look at the things that make a good rivalry:

Mutual deep & bitter hatred:

While there is no deeper hatred in baseball than Sox fans of Yankee fans, Yankee fans don't hate the Sox nearly as much as Sox fans hate the Yanks, Giants fans hate the Dodgers, or Dodger fans hate the Giants. Plus nothing has come close to the brawls Giants and Dodger players have had.

Competition:

Let's face it, there is no competition between the Sox and Yankees. The Sox may try to compete, but everyone knows the Sox will come up short every time. Giants and Dodgers go back and forth, and at least one is always in competition, many times with each other. And when one's not in competition, it's the spoiler for the other

History:

The Yankees Red Sox rivalry goes back to 1920, when Babe Ruth was sold to the Yankees. The Giants Dodgers goes back to 1889, when the NL champions giants and AA champions Dodgers faced in the first every all-metro world series. Plus name one other rivalry in sports where one or both teams moved, and the rivalry got better?

Dramatic moments:

The Yankees- Red Sox have Aaron Boone, and Bucky Dent. The Giants-Dodgers have Joe Morgan, Bobby Thompson, Brian Johnson, the four run ninth in 62 and a lot more.

and BTW, including one game and three game playoffs, the Giants and Dodgers have met the same amount of times as Yankees and Red Sox in the postseason

566601[/snapback]

Yeah, and how often did they meet to decide the pennant?

 

Also, I'm not destroying my own point when saying the Yanks always win. They do win always, and that's part of the allure. When will the Sawx finally win? Look at some of the most active rivalries in sports in the passed few years, they've all featured long winning streaks. That's what makes them fun.

 

I'm not going to keep arguing because neither of us will change our minds. However, come mid-October, I'll be watching the Red Sox beat the Yankees while at least one of the two west teams (if not both) are watching with me because their seasons are equally over.

you basically proved another point: how much of a rivalry is it when one team comes out on top?

In recent years the Yanks and Sox have had more moments, but historically

Let's look at the things that make a good rivalry:

Mutual deep & bitter hatred:

While there is no deeper hatred in baseball than Sox fans of Yankee fans, Yankee fans don't hate the Sox nearly as much as Sox fans hate the Yanks, Giants fans hate the Dodgers, or Dodger fans hate the Giants.? Plus nothing has come close to the brawls Giants and Dodger players have had.

Competition:

Let's face it, there is no competition between the Sox and Yankees.? The Sox may try to compete, but everyone knows the Sox will come up short every time.? Giants and Dodgers go back and forth, and at least one is always in competition, many times with each other.? And when one's not in competition, it's the spoiler for the other

History:

The Yankees Red Sox rivalry goes back to 1920, when Babe Ruth was sold to the Yankees.? The Giants Dodgers goes back to 1889, when the NL champions giants and AA champions Dodgers faced in the first every all-metro world series.? Plus name one other rivalry in sports where one or both teams moved, and the rivalry got better?

Dramatic moments:

The Yankees- Red Sox have Aaron Boone, and Bucky Dent.? The Giants-Dodgers have Joe Morgan, Bobby Thompson, Brian Johnson, the four run ninth in 62 and a lot more.

and BTW, including one game and three game playoffs, the Giants and Dodgers have met the same amount of times as Yankees and Red Sox in the postseason

566601[/snapback]

Yeah, and how often did they meet to decide the pennant?

 

Also, I'm not destroying my own point when saying the Yanks always win. They do win always, and that's part of the allure. When will the Sawx finally win? Look at some of the most active rivalries in sports in the passed few years, they've all featured long winning streaks. That's what makes them fun.

 

I'm not going to keep arguing because neither of us will change our minds. However, come mid-October, I'll be watching the Red Sox beat the Yankees while at least one of the two west teams (if not both) are watching with me because their seasons are equally over.

566653[/snapback]

Let's just agree the Giants-Dodgers and Yankees-Red Sox rivalries are nothing alike. The Yankees- Red Sox rivalry is equal to the Yankees being the school bully and the Red Sox is the kid who always tries to stand up to him and the bully always winds up beating the crap out of him, while the Giants and Dodgers are just two kids on the playground that just really hate each other and keep going at it over and over again.

BTW, I'll be surprised if the Yanks and Red Sox both make it out of the first round. The A's are due while the Twins have an automatic win every 4 games, so if the Twins win games 2, 3, or 4, they're in the second round.

My prediction: Come LCS time, none of these four teams will still be around.

Yeah, both rivalries are completely different in numerous senses. They compare in sport only.

 

I still think Sox-Yanks ALCS is happening again this year. The Twins have a guaranteed win twice in their series, and they could upset the Yanks. And while the A's are due, no one can beat Pedro-Schill in a short series with the Sox offense IMO.

Yeah, both rivalries are completely different in numerous senses. They compare in sport only.

 

I still think Sox-Yanks ALCS is happening again this year. The Twins have a guaranteed win twice in their series, and they could upset the Yanks. And while the A's are due, no one can beat Pedro-Schill in a short series with the Sox offense IMO.

566688[/snapback]

however now it's looking like Boston-Minnesota and Oakland-New York. Johan Santana is on the most dominant run in ages, and if the Twins can win games 2, 3, or 4, they win the series.

While the A's vs. Yanks, the A's have the big four. Not to mention the A's have a lefthanded dominated lineup and playing three games in lefty-friendly Yankee Stadium against an all right handed pitching staff, I'm giving the A's the edge there.

Meh the A's Big Three (we'll see on Harden) have yet to perform in the postseason to their capabilities, their O is weak, their pen is susceptible. I hope they beat the Yanks but I don't see it happening.

 

The thing about Twins-Sox is that Santana might not win the game if he's matched up against Pedro or Schill. They can't measure up with whichever of that two headed monster doesn't pitch Game 1, and if the Sawx are smart they'll go 3 man rotation with Wake who is clutch in the playoffs, send Lowe to the pen where he can help alot, and pitch Schill and Pedro twice first round.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.