September 20, 200422 yr Jeter needs 2 more HR to tie his career high at 24 .... everybody is hitting now
September 20, 200422 yr Giants-Dodgers>Yankees-Sox sure :thumbup ...damn who lied to u? 565101[/snapback] Bahahahahahahahahaha.....there is no rivalry better than Yanks/Sox. I'm sure LA/SF rivalry is fun and all, but it's got nothing on Yanks/Sox
September 20, 200422 yr Red Sox getting PWNED today 13-0 in Bot 6th. 563475[/snapback] 13-1* on a David Ortiz solo blast. No Hitter is gone.... thank God. I wouldnt hear the end of it..... :thumbup 563494[/snapback] You're a Red Sox fan?
September 20, 200422 yr this series wont be the same at fenway 565102[/snapback] Yeah, it won't be. If Schill goes, that'll be a W.
September 20, 200422 yr Yankees just need to take their game right now to Fenway and it will be a repeat of this weekend.
September 20, 200422 yr Red Sox getting PWNED today 13-0 in Bot 6th. 563475[/snapback] 13-1* on a David Ortiz solo blast. No Hitter is gone.... thank God. I wouldnt hear the end of it..... :thumbup 563494[/snapback] You're a Red Sox fan? 565585[/snapback] Yep.
September 20, 200422 yr Why does it seem like every game ends in dramatic fashion?? These two teams better meet in the ALCS.? Best rivalry in sports, no question. 563100[/snapback] Giants-Dodgers>Yankees-Sox 563197[/snapback] They're not even remotely close in terms of national interest. I can't really say how the games go when the Giants play the Dodgers, cause I don't pay much attention. But with the Red Sox-Yankees, I do pay attention, and every game is close. Well, except today. Giants-Dodgers might have just as much historically, or maybe even more, but today that rivalry is pretty much a nonentity for the rest of the country. 563548[/snapback] national interest doesn't matter. All that matters is how it is to the players and fans. And the Yankees- Red Sox rivalry is too much of a one way rivalry, There's nothing like the intensity of a Giants Dodgers game, and it goes way back. Yankees and Red Sox is a one way rivalry. The Yankees completely dominate it and I know a lot of Yankee fans that think of the Red Sox as just another team.
September 20, 200422 yr Red Sox getting PWNED today 13-0 in Bot 6th. 563475[/snapback] 13-1* on a David Ortiz solo blast. No Hitter is gone.... thank God. I wouldnt hear the end of it..... :thumbup 563494[/snapback] You're a Red Sox fan? 565585[/snapback] Yep. 566181[/snapback] Awesome! Another one!
September 20, 200422 yr Why does it seem like every game ends in dramatic fashion?? These two teams better meet in the ALCS.? Best rivalry in sports, no question. 563100[/snapback] Giants-Dodgers>Yankees-Sox 563197[/snapback] They're not even remotely close in terms of national interest. I can't really say how the games go when the Giants play the Dodgers, cause I don't pay much attention. But with the Red Sox-Yankees, I do pay attention, and every game is close. Well, except today. Giants-Dodgers might have just as much historically, or maybe even more, but today that rivalry is pretty much a nonentity for the rest of the country. 563548[/snapback] national interest doesn't matter. All that matters is how it is to the players and fans. And the Yankees- Red Sox rivalry is too much of a one way rivalry, There's nothing like the intensity of a Giants Dodgers game, and it goes way back. Yankees and Red Sox is a one way rivalry. The Yankees completely dominate it and I know a lot of Yankee fans that think of the Red Sox as just another team. 566296[/snapback] Hmm, remind me how many times the Giants and Dodgers have decided the fate of the NL in a 7 game no holds barred series?
September 20, 200422 yr Why does it seem like every game ends in dramatic fashion?? These two teams better meet in the ALCS.? Best rivalry in sports, no question. 563100[/snapback] Giants-Dodgers>Yankees-Sox 563197[/snapback] They're not even remotely close in terms of national interest. I can't really say how the games go when the Giants play the Dodgers, cause I don't pay much attention. But with the Red Sox-Yankees, I do pay attention, and every game is close. Well, except today. Giants-Dodgers might have just as much historically, or maybe even more, but today that rivalry is pretty much a nonentity for the rest of the country. 563548[/snapback] national interest doesn't matter. All that matters is how it is to the players and fans. And the Yankees- Red Sox rivalry is too much of a one way rivalry, There's nothing like the intensity of a Giants Dodgers game, and it goes way back. Yankees and Red Sox is a one way rivalry. The Yankees completely dominate it and I know a lot of Yankee fans that think of the Red Sox as just another team. 566296[/snapback] Hmm, remind me how many times the Giants and Dodgers have decided the fate of the NL in a 7 game no holds barred series? 566309[/snapback] oooooh, one series and it's suddenly the best rivalry in baseball? Give me a break. Fact: if it weren't for the fact that the Yanks and Red Sox were on the east coast (and one team in New York), nobody would be mentioning it as the best rivalry in baseball the best rivalries: 1. Giants- Dodgers 2. Cubs- Cardinals 3. Yankees- Red Sox
September 20, 200422 yr One series? Try 86 years worth of games. How many famous events are there from Giants-Dodgers postseason matchups? Two? You can name off a laundry list of huge baseball events that are directly Red Sox-Yankees related.
September 20, 200422 yr Had baseball the popularity out west as it does in the northeast and the center of the news media was LA then the Giants-Dodgers would be known as the best rivalry. Same for the midwest and Cubs-Cardinals.
September 20, 200422 yr oooooh, one series and it's suddenly the best rivalry in baseball? Give me a break. Fact: if it weren't for the fact that the Yanks and Red Sox were on the east coast (and one team in New York), nobody would be mentioning it as the best rivalry in baseball the best rivalries: 1. Giants- Dodgers 2. Cubs- Cardinals 3. Yankees- Red Sox 566316[/snapback] Wow. You really have no idea what you're talking about. Yankees-RedSox is the best rivalry is baseball...period. Do a poll and you'd be the only person to say that the Dodgers-Giants is bigger. PLEASE.
September 21, 200422 yr come on this is a yankees-redsox thread... go start another 566380[/snapback] This is what the troll does
September 21, 200422 yr the yankees can increase their lead tonight with a win and can be a good 5 and a half or 6 and a half before their series at Fenway
September 21, 200422 yr the yankees can increase their lead tonight with a win and can be a good 5 and a half or 6 and a half before their series at Fenway 566528[/snapback] ...If only the offense wakes up. I wish we hadn't scored as many runs the past two days so we could get them now. Boston is losing, so it would be possible to not lose ground, which is always nice :cool
September 21, 200422 yr oooooh, one series and it's suddenly the best rivalry in baseball? Give me a break.? Fact: if it weren't for the fact that the Yanks and Red Sox were on the east coast (and one team in New York), nobody would be mentioning it as the best rivalry in baseball the best rivalries: 1. Giants- Dodgers 2. Cubs- Cardinals 3. Yankees- Red Sox 566316[/snapback] Wow. You really have no idea what you're talking about. Yankees-RedSox is the best rivalry is baseball...period. Do a poll and you'd be the only person to say that the Dodgers-Giants is bigger. PLEASE. 566353[/snapback] Yankees Red Sox have a p***y fight in the ALCS (ooooh, a 70 year old man gets thrown to the ground, that's it), and all of a sudden it's the best rivalry? The greatest brawls in baseball history were Giants Dodgers. The most intense and dramatic moments were Giants Dodgers. In chronological order: 2003: Giants first, Dodgers second 2002: Giants go on September tear to beat out Dodgers for Wild Card 2001: Dodgers take 2 of 3 in final weekend to spoil Giants playoff hopes (in which Bonds hits 71, 72, and 73) 2000: Giants first, Dodgers second 1997: Giants go on September tear while Dodgers collapse, momentum turner is Brian Johnson's home run 1994: what would have been a wild pennant race ends due to strike 1993: Giants win 103 games, but get knocked out on 12-1 loss to the Dodgers on final day of season 1991: Giants win two of three in final weekend to play spoiler 1982: Dodgers spoil Giants hopes on second to last day of season, Giants get revenge the next day by spoiling the DOdgers hopes with a Joe Morgan homer 1971: Giants beat Dodgers by one game 1966: Dodgers beat Giants by 1.5 games 1965: Dodgers first, Giants second 1962: Giants go on on September tear while Dodgers collapse, forcing a best of 3 playoff, where the Giants score four runs in the bottom of the ninth to win series 1959: Giants led Dodgers by 3 games on Sept. 6, but Dodgers finished 15-5, including 3-game sweep of S.F., to win pennant. 1954: Dodgers heavy favorites, but Giants win National League, Dodgers finishing in second 1952: Dodgers first, Giants second 1951: No need explaining this one 1924: Dodgers finish 1.5 games out of Giants 1920: Dodgers first, Giants second 1914: Dodgers first, Giants second 1889: Giants defeat Dodgers in World Series How about all the brawls? The p***y fights that the Yanks and Red Sox have had are nothing in comparison to the brawls the GIants and Dodgers have had over the years. Juan Marichal- Johnny Roseboro, Mike Marshall, Alex Travino, and Scott Garrelts, Reggie Smith and the fan, there is nothing like it. The Yanks- Red Sox is an east coast media creation. But the Giants Dodgers is and always will be the best rivalry in baseball.
September 21, 200422 yr Hmm, that's quite a bit of divisional bs. How many times have the teams met in the playoffs? Also, the one moment I'll give you is Bobby Thomson. However, Sawx-Yanks have the distinction of the Greatest Curse in Sports against the Greatest Team in Sports (historically). More great players have battled it out in this rivalry than any other. No team has more players step up than the Yanks against the Sox, no team has players choke more than the Sox against the Yanks. Bucky Dent anyone? How about Pedro's collapse? How many years just this decade have they produced series to remember? And oh, btw, Dodgers-Giants is an April-September thing. Not only are the Sox and Yanks good enough that the rivalry spews into October EVERY YEAR, they even have more bitter rivalry than other sports that are in season when they are bidding against each other for free agents and maneuvering for trades. When was the last time the Dodgers and the Giants bid against each other on a major free agent? When was the last time the Dodgers made a trade for the SOLE purpose of spiting the Giants, or vice versa? Giants-Dodgers I agree gives for some fun on the field from April to September the 19 times they meet a year, but Sawx-Yanks is all out war 365 days a year extra special those 19 regular season times and amazing ridiculous levels in the 7 games they play yearly in the playoffs.
September 21, 200422 yr you basically proved another point: how much of a rivalry is it when one team comes out on top? In recent years the Yanks and Sox have had more moments, but historically Let's look at the things that make a good rivalry: Mutual deep & bitter hatred: While there is no deeper hatred in baseball than Sox fans of Yankee fans, Yankee fans don't hate the Sox nearly as much as Sox fans hate the Yanks, Giants fans hate the Dodgers, or Dodger fans hate the Giants. Plus nothing has come close to the brawls Giants and Dodger players have had. Competition: Let's face it, there is no competition between the Sox and Yankees. The Sox may try to compete, but everyone knows the Sox will come up short every time. Giants and Dodgers go back and forth, and at least one is always in competition, many times with each other. And when one's not in competition, it's the spoiler for the other History: The Yankees Red Sox rivalry goes back to 1920, when Babe Ruth was sold to the Yankees. The Giants Dodgers goes back to 1889, when the NL champions giants and AA champions Dodgers faced in the first every all-metro world series. Plus name one other rivalry in sports where one or both teams moved, and the rivalry got better? Dramatic moments: The Yankees- Red Sox have Aaron Boone, and Bucky Dent. The Giants-Dodgers have Joe Morgan, Bobby Thompson, Brian Johnson, the four run ninth in 62 and a lot more. and BTW, including one game and three game playoffs, the Giants and Dodgers have met the same amount of times as Yankees and Red Sox in the postseason
September 21, 200422 yr I'm not even going to bother with you. You're a Giants fan, so you obviously feel that the Dodgers-SF rivalry is better.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.