Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

i don't if this has been up yet

Featured Replies

BERARDINO: Delgado, Lo Duca will face comparisons to Pudge, Lee

Published January 29, 2005

 

 

It's a fascinating question, one with as many layers as any you could pose about South Florida's ever-intriguing baseball franchise.

 

Which combination of players would you rather have: Paul Lo Duca and Carlos Delgado or Pudge Rodriguez and Derrek Lee?

 

Since winning their second World Series in 2003, the Marlins have made a number of tweaks and adjustments to their roster. As all teams do.

 

Armando Benitez has come and gone. Juan Encarnacion has left and returned. Ramon Castro has risen and fallen and subsequently disappeared. Three-quarters of the World Series rotation (Carl Pavano, Brad Penny and Mark Redman) now works elsewhere.

 

But essentially, the two biggest changes have come at first base and catcher.

 

Last winter, in the name of financial intelligence, the Marlins cut ties with a pair of Gold Glove defenders who also happen to swing potent bats. That would be Rodriguez and Lee, who wound up signing for a combined $62.5 million with the Tigers and Cubs, respectively.

 

One year later, the Marlins are aglow with the possibilities of a lineup that includes Lo Duca and Delgado. Like the men they replaced, one is signed for three years, the other four.

 

Combined price tag: $70 million.

 

With the savings, the Marlins could have bought themselves another Al Leiter. Or maybe signed Benitez to a two-year contract before last season instead of renting the most dominant closer in franchise history.

 

There's also the harder-to-measure idea that retaining Rodriguez and Lee a year ago might have helped the team avoid a third-place fade in the National League East. Instead 2004 goes down as a wasted year that only brought A.J. Burnett, Josh Beckett, Miguel Cabrera, Dontrelle Willis, Juan Pierre and other franchise jewels one year closer to free agency.

 

Who knows? Maybe the stadium deal is done by now if Rodriguez and Lee had stayed.

 

And so the question is posed again: Whom would you rather have?

 

On the surface, you might assume it's the current combination, hands-down. Delgado is easily the most accomplished offensive weapon in the group, at least as measured by his nine-year average of 36 home runs and 114 RBI.

 

Neither Lee nor Rodriguez ever has reached those plateaus in a single season, much less over a nine-year span.

 

And Lo Duca, well, he impressed everyone during the final two months last season with the way he handled the pitching staff and produced clutch hit after clutch hit. At least until wearing down in the September death march.

 

Over the past three seasons, Lo Duca has hit a combined .312 with runners in scoring position. Same as Delgado.

 

Rodriguez? He's at .339 in that span with runners in scoring position, but Lee's .263 drags their combined output 15 points lower than their replacements.

 

However, there are other measures, some relatively newfangled, perhaps even controversial, that favor the original pair.

 

Their combined on-base and slugging percentage, for instance, which in theory removes the relative strengths and weaknesses of their teammates from the equation. Over the past two seasons, the Rodriguez-Lee combo has produced an .871 OPS. That's 22 points higher than the Delgado-Lo Duca number.

 

How about runs created, another of the great Bill James' pet tools for measuring offensive production? Over the past two years, the Rodriguez-Lee combo has averaged 194.5 runs created. That's five more per year than their replacements.

 

There's also win shares, another James formula in which he breaks down every on-field result (including defense) and divvies up the credit for a team's win total. Over the past two years, Rodriguez-Lee has totaled 91 win shares compared with 89 for Delgado-Lo Duca.

 

Of course, we haven't even gotten around to comparing their average age -- at 31, Rodriguez-Lee is a year younger -- or the combined 12 Gold Gloves for Rodriguez-Lee against their replacements' zero. Or the fact Rodriguez and Lee helped the 2003 Marlins win a World Series in addition to the three American League West titles Rodriguez's Texas Rangers won in the '90s.

 

Delgado and Lo Duca? They're still looking for their first taste of the postseason.

 

Asked this week if he saw any karma in the fact his friend Rodriguez had to leave in order for him to land here, Delgado smiled.

 

"Yeah, you're right, if he was here probably I wouldn't be here," Delgado said. "But I live today like it is today. I don't think about yesterday."

 

Great philosophy. But it's so tempting to look back anyway.

 

 

 

 

 

I just want to know what you guys think??

Let me give up a headsup on how to find out of something's already been posted.

 

In the upper right part of this website's screen is a "Search" function. Copy and paste a few words or a phrase from what you want to post. In a few seconds you'll know if it's been posted or not.

  • Author

Let me give up a headsup on how to find out of something's already been posted.

 

In the upper right part of this website's screen is a "Search" function. Copy and paste a few words or a phrase from what you want to post. In a few seconds you'll know if it's been posted or not.

677105[/snapback]

thanks :thumbup

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.