Jump to content

Featured Replies

Posted

First off, I wouldnt be surprised if this topic has been done before...if it has, sorry, direct me to it please...

 

But has anyone tried putting together an All-Time Marlins team? Who's our best at every position, pitchers and bullpen included? And would you guys go by stats or other intangible attributes? Any ideas?

I am going to try this right now...

 

C-Charles Johnson

1-Carlos Delgado

2-Luis Castillo

3-Mike Lowell

SS-Edgar Renteria

LF-Miguel Cabrera

CF-Juan Pierre

RF-Gary Sheffield

 

SP-Kevin Brown

SP-Al Leiter

SP-Dontrelle Willis

SP-Josh Beckett

SP-Alex Fernandez

 

SU-Armando Benitez

SU-Robb Nenn

CL-Bryan Harvey

I'll go by what they did as a Marlin, and not just what their talent is (so, I'd disqualify Piazza and Pudge)

 

C-CJ

1B-Carlos Delgado

2B-Luis (probably the easiest choice on the list)

SS-Edgar Renteria

3B-Mike Lowell

LF-Miguel Cabrera

CF-Juan Pierre

RF-Gary Sheffield

 

SP-Josh Beckett

SP-Kevin Brown

SP-Dontrelle Willis

SP-Livan Hernandez

SP-AJ Burnett

 

Closer-Brian Harvey

  • Author

I started this, might as well give my take...

 

Manager - Gotta go with Jim Leyland, I respect Jack McKeon enough to keep him around as a bench coach or something

 

C- Ivan Rodriguez

1B- Carlos Delgado

2B- Luis Castillo

3B- Mike Lowell

SS- Edgar Renteria

LF- Miguel Cabrera

CF- Devon White

RF- Gary Sheffield

 

Bench- Paul Lo Duca, Charles Johnson, Moises Alou, Jeff Conine, Lenny Harris, Derrek Lee

 

SP- Josh Beckett

SP- Kevin Brown

SP- Dontrelle Willis

SP- Livan Hernandez

SP- Carl Pavano

 

Bullpen - Todd Jones, Antonio Alfonseca (I'll let '05 slide), Robb Nen, Bryan Harvey

Closer - Armando Benitez

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...