March 30, 200620 yr Trying to compare the south to the northeast... that's funny. But really, do we really want to get into the measuring game? Everyone even mildly familiar with South Florida is laughing their collective asses off at that analogy. I'll leave it at that. Yes, Miami does have over 5 million in its ginormous CSA. Like I showed you, from Jupiter to Homestead, its over 100 miles in distance, and all that is considered Miami's CSA. Yeah, or you could ditch the CSA, which is a technical red herring, altogether, and instead consider the Dade-Broward market alone; you'd have 4+million population at half the diameter. For a moment, though, let's use the faulty analogy presented to consider the 'ginormous' 100-mile-diameter Miami-Fort Lauderdale-West Palm Beach CSA and its 5+ million population, and compare that to the 100-mile-radius market encompassing San Antonio that the 'expert' managed to concoct and its 3.9 million population. Simple math tells us his proposed market is more than four times larger in terms of geographical land mass. And this totally discounts the geometric reality that we're comparing a thin rectangle that's 100 miles long at its widest point to a big, fat, sparsely-populated circle. The San Antonio market isn't even in the same league. Where on this forum have I tried to make San Antonio the best option? I haven't. All that article says is San Antonio can support another professional team. No where in this post have I even made the attempt to say San Antonio > Miami in terms of economy, population, stature. And I commend you for that. One would have to be preparing his Kool-Aid with a dirty radiator to suggest that the two markets are even remotely comparable in terms of population, or any of those other measures.
March 30, 200620 yr Yeah, or you could ditch the CSA, which is a technical red herring, altogether, and instead consider the Dade-Broward market alone; you'd have 4+million population at half the diameter. For a moment, though, let's use the faulty analogy presented to consider the 'ginormous' 100-mile-diameter Miami-Fort Lauderdale-West Palm Beach CSA and its 5+ million population, and compare that to the 100-mile-radius market encompassing San Antonio that the 'expert' managed to concoct and its 3.9 million population. Simple math tells us his proposed market is more than four times larger in terms of geographical land mass. And this totally discounts the geometric reality that we're comparing a thin rectangle that's 100 miles long at its widest point to a big, fat, sparsely-populated circle. The San Antonio market isn't even in the same league. Not that it means anything, but if you want to stick to the hundred mile thing, it'd me more accurate to use a 100 mile diameter between SA and Austin (south end of SA to North end of Austin, around Round Rock should be about right). That'd include about 3.4 million as my rough guess, in the same type rectangle, just more densly populated at the ends instead of the middle. Same type/size of area, 2/3 the population (roughly). This is also pretty much the area that is expected to be 5 million strong by 2020 (multiple studies have shown this, about half not commissioned by south texas, the I-35 corridor between SA and Austin is expected to be basically the strongest growth population wise for the next 10-15 years, % not sheer number). Oh, and the 100 mile radius thing, while I admit is BS when talking about MLB and any sort of after work activity, is not that strange to talk about in Texas. Many people commute to work further than that, and an insane number make that drive on weekends to visit friends and family. One would have to be preparing his Kool-Aid with a dirty radiator to suggest that the two markets are even remotely comparable in terms of population, or any of those other measures. Quite true. For now. Miami clearly betters SA on most thing, and a few growth categories SA clearly beats Miami. In 15 years, they'll be much more comparable.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.