August 2, 200620 yr The funny thing that the anti-christians always argue is that creationism shouldnt be taught bc it cant be proved by science bla bla bla. However, I've heard creationism and the existence of god being proven with the use of scientific formulas by usign the multiverse theory and the observation of light in different dimensions (which is just as ridiculous as evolution mind you and is attempted to be proven with numbers and scientific fact). So there you have it a scientific theory that proves the existence of God and the possibility of creationism. I read this is an article in a science magazine my high school used to subscribe to. I'm sure its somewhere on the net as well, because everything is. But either way, should this mean creationism should now be taught in science class? Since there is a scientific theory that attempts to prove it funny part is, I am christian, I do believe in god. I do believe creation being his will. I do believe that we evoled as well into the image he wished us to become. I dont believe my religion should be forced upon you, your children or another's children. I believe there is a seperation outside of schooling, unless it is catholic school like I went to.
August 2, 200620 yr (I'm playing Devil's advocate here) So we should believe what Science tells us? There is just as much a leap of faith to believe Evolution and the Big Bang as there is to believe that some supernatural figure just decided out of the blue to create animals and humans in a span of a week. And I think your interpretation of science is wrong. Science is there to be disproved. How do you think advances are made? Sure Issac Newton was a great mind. But his theory of the mechanical universe was so off base that it is included only as a theory to represent the past minds. (done playing Devil's advocate) My point here is Science takes just as much faith to believe as religion does. But there is a difference between 1)a regular theory(I have a theory that soda can actually let people fall asleep), 2) a scientific theory that went through rigorous disproval process and then has become generally accepted by the scientific community, and 3)a scientific law(which also run counter to a lot of religous views so perhaps the debate isnt about whether evolution can be doubted or not?). Creationism=#1, Evolution=#2, Matter can neither created nor destroyed=#3. Put it this way. Gravitity is also a theory. Should we teach our children that it is just a theory and that some people have a theory that they can walk off a building and not drop? funny part is, I am christian, I do believe in god. I do believe creation being his will. I do believe that we evoled as well into the image he wished us to become. I dont believe my religion should be forced upon you, your children or another's children. I believe there is a seperation outside of schooling, unless it is catholic school like I went to. Exactly. :notworthy
August 2, 200620 yr (I'm playing Devil's advocate here) So we should believe what Science tells us? There is just as much a leap of faith to believe Evolution and the Big Bang as there is to believe that some supernatural figure just decided out of the blue to create animals and humans in a span of a week. And I think your interpretation of science is wrong. Science is there to be disproved. How do you think advances are made? Sure Issac Newton was a great mind. But his theory of the mechanical universe was so off base that it is included only as a theory to represent the past minds. (done playing Devil's advocate) My point here is Science takes just as much faith to believe as religion does. But there is a difference between 1)a regular theory(I have a theory that soda can actually let people fall asleep), 2) a scientific theory that went through rigorous disproval process and then has become generally accepted by the scientific community, and 3)a scientific law(which also run counter to a lot of religous views so perhaps the debate isnt about whether evolution can be doubted or not?). Creationism=#1, Evolution=#2, Matter can neither created nor destroyed=#3. Put it this way. Gravitity is also a theory. Should we teach our children that it is just a theory and that some people have a theory that they can walk off a building and not drop? funny part is, I am christian, I do believe in god. I do believe creation being his will. I do believe that we evoled as well into the image he wished us to become. I dont believe my religion should be forced upon you, your children or another's children. I believe there is a seperation outside of schooling, unless it is catholic school like I went to. Exactly. :notworthy Not sure how you can say that Evolution went throught rigorous disproval process. And you are very right, it has been accepted by the scientific community in general. That doesn't mean is correct
August 2, 200620 yr (I'm playing Devil's advocate here) So we should believe what Science tells us? There is just as much a leap of faith to believe Evolution and the Big Bang as there is to believe that some supernatural figure just decided out of the blue to create animals and humans in a span of a week. And I think your interpretation of science is wrong. Science is there to be disproved. How do you think advances are made? Sure Issac Newton was a great mind. But his theory of the mechanical universe was so off base that it is included only as a theory to represent the past minds. (done playing Devil's advocate) My point here is Science takes just as much faith to believe as religion does. But there is a difference between 1)a regular theory(I have a theory that soda can actually let people fall asleep), 2) a scientific theory that went through rigorous disproval process and then has become generally accepted by the scientific community, and 3)a scientific law(which also run counter to a lot of religous views so perhaps the debate isnt about whether evolution can be doubted or not?). Creationism=#1, Evolution=#2, Matter can neither created nor destroyed=#3. Put it this way. Gravitity is also a theory. Should we teach our children that it is just a theory and that some people have a theory that they can walk off a building and not drop? funny part is, I am christian, I do believe in god. I do believe creation being his will. I do believe that we evoled as well into the image he wished us to become. I dont believe my religion should be forced upon you, your children or another's children. I believe there is a seperation outside of schooling, unless it is catholic school like I went to. Exactly. :notworthy Not sure how you can say that Evolution went throught rigorous disproval process. And you are very right, it has been accepted by the scientific community in general. That doesn't mean is correct Because like all scientific theories, there is a constant strive to compare empircal data to see if it runs counter to any existing theory. How much immense knowledge do we have on genetics, DNA, fossils, bone structure, etc etc. Darwin's original theory has only been beefed up or improved upon by immense amount of data, not disproven by it. If it was, we would know. Essentially the creationists would have us believe that although scientists have torn down many theories in areas such as physics, psychology, atronomy, and biology...they somehow have decided to let evolution go because of their anti-religious views. btw, nobody is saying evolution is law. But there is much more evidence supporting the theory than there is for creationism. Not all theories are equal. I trust a scientists theory before I trust the Pope's theory. Heck, maybe we should start teaching that women are made out of water. Let me ask you this: 1. Gravity is just a theory. It is not necessarily correct. If someone told you that since it is not necessarily correct, then another theory exists that man can fly just by jumping off of a building. Would you seriously entertain that principle? 2. Who would you trust if you had to have a medical condition taken care of, medical science or a priest who can perform miracles?
August 2, 200620 yr It boils down to this for me: Creationism is a religious theory. There is no religion class in public schools. Therefore, creationism is not taught. Evolution is a scientific theory. There is science class in public schools. Therefore, evolution is taught. If you really want to teach your kids to learn about creationism, there are very many ways of doing that which don't involve forcing people to learn it in a class where it has no relavence. For the record, I personally believe that God set the wheels in motion and evolution took over from there. But that's not important here.
August 2, 200620 yr (I'm playing Devil's advocate here) So we should believe what Science tells us? There is just as much a leap of faith to believe Evolution and the Big Bang as there is to believe that some supernatural figure just decided out of the blue to create animals and humans in a span of a week. And I think your interpretation of science is wrong. Science is there to be disproved. How do you think advances are made? Sure Issac Newton was a great mind. But his theory of the mechanical universe was so off base that it is included only as a theory to represent the past minds. (done playing Devil's advocate) My point here is Science takes just as much faith to believe as religion does. But there is a difference between 1)a regular theory(I have a theory that soda can actually let people fall asleep), 2) a scientific theory that went through rigorous disproval process and then has become generally accepted by the scientific community, and 3)a scientific law(which also run counter to a lot of religous views so perhaps the debate isnt about whether evolution can be doubted or not?). Creationism=#1, Evolution=#2, Matter can neither created nor destroyed=#3. Put it this way. Gravitity is also a theory. Should we teach our children that it is just a theory and that some people have a theory that they can walk off a building and not drop? funny part is, I am christian, I do believe in god. I do believe creation being his will. I do believe that we evoled as well into the image he wished us to become. I dont believe my religion should be forced upon you, your children or another's children. I believe there is a seperation outside of schooling, unless it is catholic school like I went to. Exactly. :notworthy Not sure how you can say that Evolution went throught rigorous disproval process. And you are very right, it has been accepted by the scientific community in general. That doesn't mean is correct Because like all scientific theories, there is a constant strive to compare empircal data to see if it runs counter to any existing theory. How much immense knowledge do we have on genetics, DNA, fossils, bone structure, etc etc. Darwin's original theory has only been beefed up or improved upon by immense amount of data, not disproven by it. If it was, we would know. Essentially the creationists would have us believe that although scientists have torn down many theories in areas such as physics, psychology, atronomy, and biology...they somehow have decided to let evolution go because of their anti-religious views. btw, nobody is saying evolution is law. But there is much more evidence supporting the theory than there is for creationism. Not all theories are equal. I trust a scientists theory before I trust the Pope's theory. Heck, maybe we should start teaching that women are made out of water. Let me ask you this: 1. Gravity is just a theory. It is not necessarily correct. If someone told you that since it is not necessarily correct, then another theory exists that man can fly just by jumping off of a building. Would you seriously entertain that principle? 2. Who would you trust if you had to have a medical condition taken care of, medical science or a priest who can perform miracles? #1: Laugable to compare the theory of Gravity and Evolution #2: Both (If my life was on the line, I would pursue both avenues)
August 2, 200620 yr (I'm playing Devil's advocate here) So we should believe what Science tells us? There is just as much a leap of faith to believe Evolution and the Big Bang as there is to believe that some supernatural figure just decided out of the blue to create animals and humans in a span of a week. And I think your interpretation of science is wrong. Science is there to be disproved. How do you think advances are made? Sure Issac Newton was a great mind. But his theory of the mechanical universe was so off base that it is included only as a theory to represent the past minds. (done playing Devil's advocate) My point here is Science takes just as much faith to believe as religion does. But there is a difference between 1)a regular theory(I have a theory that soda can actually let people fall asleep), 2) a scientific theory that went through rigorous disproval process and then has become generally accepted by the scientific community, and 3)a scientific law(which also run counter to a lot of religous views so perhaps the debate isnt about whether evolution can be doubted or not?). Creationism=#1, Evolution=#2, Matter can neither created nor destroyed=#3. Put it this way. Gravitity is also a theory. Should we teach our children that it is just a theory and that some people have a theory that they can walk off a building and not drop? funny part is, I am christian, I do believe in god. I do believe creation being his will. I do believe that we evoled as well into the image he wished us to become. I dont believe my religion should be forced upon you, your children or another's children. I believe there is a seperation outside of schooling, unless it is catholic school like I went to. Exactly. :notworthy Not sure how you can say that Evolution went throught rigorous disproval process. And you are very right, it has been accepted by the scientific community in general. That doesn't mean is correct Because like all scientific theories, there is a constant strive to compare empircal data to see if it runs counter to any existing theory. How much immense knowledge do we have on genetics, DNA, fossils, bone structure, etc etc. Darwin's original theory has only been beefed up or improved upon by immense amount of data, not disproven by it. If it was, we would know. Essentially the creationists would have us believe that although scientists have torn down many theories in areas such as physics, psychology, atronomy, and biology...they somehow have decided to let evolution go because of their anti-religious views. btw, nobody is saying evolution is law. But there is much more evidence supporting the theory than there is for creationism. Not all theories are equal. I trust a scientists theory before I trust the Pope's theory. Heck, maybe we should start teaching that women are made out of water. Let me ask you this: 1. Gravity is just a theory. It is not necessarily correct. If someone told you that since it is not necessarily correct, then another theory exists that man can fly just by jumping off of a building. Would you seriously entertain that principle? 2. Who would you trust if you had to have a medical condition taken care of, medical science or a priest who can perform miracles? #1: Laugable to compare the theory of Gravity and Evolution #2: Both (If my life was on the line, I would pursue both avenues) Why is it laughable to compare gravity and evolution? And who would you trust if you only had enough time to go to one of them?
August 2, 200620 yr (I'm playing Devil's advocate here) So we should believe what Science tells us? There is just as much a leap of faith to believe Evolution and the Big Bang as there is to believe that some supernatural figure just decided out of the blue to create animals and humans in a span of a week. And I think your interpretation of science is wrong. Science is there to be disproved. How do you think advances are made? Sure Issac Newton was a great mind. But his theory of the mechanical universe was so off base that it is included only as a theory to represent the past minds. (done playing Devil's advocate) My point here is Science takes just as much faith to believe as religion does. But there is a difference between 1)a regular theory(I have a theory that soda can actually let people fall asleep), 2) a scientific theory that went through rigorous disproval process and then has become generally accepted by the scientific community, and 3)a scientific law(which also run counter to a lot of religous views so perhaps the debate isnt about whether evolution can be doubted or not?). Creationism=#1, Evolution=#2, Matter can neither created nor destroyed=#3. Put it this way. Gravitity is also a theory. Should we teach our children that it is just a theory and that some people have a theory that they can walk off a building and not drop? funny part is, I am christian, I do believe in god. I do believe creation being his will. I do believe that we evoled as well into the image he wished us to become. I dont believe my religion should be forced upon you, your children or another's children. I believe there is a seperation outside of schooling, unless it is catholic school like I went to. Exactly. :notworthy Not sure how you can say that Evolution went throught rigorous disproval process. And you are very right, it has been accepted by the scientific community in general. That doesn't mean is correct Because like all scientific theories, there is a constant strive to compare empircal data to see if it runs counter to any existing theory. How much immense knowledge do we have on genetics, DNA, fossils, bone structure, etc etc. Darwin's original theory has only been beefed up or improved upon by immense amount of data, not disproven by it. If it was, we would know. Essentially the creationists would have us believe that although scientists have torn down many theories in areas such as physics, psychology, atronomy, and biology...they somehow have decided to let evolution go because of their anti-religious views. btw, nobody is saying evolution is law. But there is much more evidence supporting the theory than there is for creationism. Not all theories are equal. I trust a scientists theory before I trust the Pope's theory. Heck, maybe we should start teaching that women are made out of water. Let me ask you this: 1. Gravity is just a theory. It is not necessarily correct. If someone told you that since it is not necessarily correct, then another theory exists that man can fly just by jumping off of a building. Would you seriously entertain that principle? 2. Who would you trust if you had to have a medical condition taken care of, medical science or a priest who can perform miracles? #1: Laugable to compare the theory of Gravity and Evolution #2: Both (If my life was on the line, I would pursue both avenues) Why is it laughable to compare gravity and evolution? And who would you trust if you only had enough time to go to one of them? #1 - You don't see many scientist challenging the theory of gravity (the same can't be said on the evolution) #2 - on that case, I would go to the doctor and pray that God help the man/woman help me. It is my personal believe, that I don't need any mediators to communicate or get help from God. Not sure what is the point of the question or what are you trying to prove/disprove.
August 2, 200620 yr I think the real question here isnt one vs the other but at what point does the faith of one person have the right to enter into the life of a different person and dictate what they are taught or learn.
August 3, 200620 yr (I'm playing Devil's advocate here) So we should believe what Science tells us? There is just as much a leap of faith to believe Evolution and the Big Bang as there is to believe that some supernatural figure just decided out of the blue to create animals and humans in a span of a week. And I think your interpretation of science is wrong. Science is there to be disproved. How do you think advances are made? Sure Issac Newton was a great mind. But his theory of the mechanical universe was so off base that it is included only as a theory to represent the past minds. (done playing Devil's advocate) My point here is Science takes just as much faith to believe as religion does. But there is a difference between 1)a regular theory(I have a theory that soda can actually let people fall asleep), 2) a scientific theory that went through rigorous disproval process and then has become generally accepted by the scientific community, and 3)a scientific law(which also run counter to a lot of religous views so perhaps the debate isnt about whether evolution can be doubted or not?). Creationism=#1, Evolution=#2, Matter can neither created nor destroyed=#3. Put it this way. Gravitity is also a theory. Should we teach our children that it is just a theory and that some people have a theory that they can walk off a building and not drop? funny part is, I am christian, I do believe in god. I do believe creation being his will. I do believe that we evoled as well into the image he wished us to become. I dont believe my religion should be forced upon you, your children or another's children. I believe there is a seperation outside of schooling, unless it is catholic school like I went to. Exactly. :notworthy Not sure how you can say that Evolution went throught rigorous disproval process. And you are very right, it has been accepted by the scientific community in general. That doesn't mean is correct Because like all scientific theories, there is a constant strive to compare empircal data to see if it runs counter to any existing theory. How much immense knowledge do we have on genetics, DNA, fossils, bone structure, etc etc. Darwin's original theory has only been beefed up or improved upon by immense amount of data, not disproven by it. If it was, we would know. Essentially the creationists would have us believe that although scientists have torn down many theories in areas such as physics, psychology, atronomy, and biology...they somehow have decided to let evolution go because of their anti-religious views. btw, nobody is saying evolution is law. But there is much more evidence supporting the theory than there is for creationism. Not all theories are equal. I trust a scientists theory before I trust the Pope's theory. Heck, maybe we should start teaching that women are made out of water. Let me ask you this: 1. Gravity is just a theory. It is not necessarily correct. If someone told you that since it is not necessarily correct, then another theory exists that man can fly just by jumping off of a building. Would you seriously entertain that principle? 2. Who would you trust if you had to have a medical condition taken care of, medical science or a priest who can perform miracles? #1: Laugable to compare the theory of Gravity and Evolution #2: Both (If my life was on the line, I would pursue both avenues) Why is it laughable to compare gravity and evolution? And who would you trust if you only had enough time to go to one of them? #1 - You don't see many scientist challenging the theory of gravity (the same can't be said on the evolution) #2 - on that case, I would go to the doctor and pray that God help the man/woman help me. It is my personal believe, that I don't need any mediators to communicate or get help from God. Not sure what is the point of the question or what are you trying to prove/disprove. #1 is totally and 100% wrong. Nobody believes Newtonian physics anymore (Einstein turned those principles on their head, and now Einstein has been challenged). Even laws can be changed, as long as the explanatory virtues still fit within the scope of the new overreaching principles of instrumentalism that claims to explain it. Gravity has been challenged again and again and the principles behind it have been changed.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.