September 25, 200620 yr See, 2003, like I said, it's a great idea in theory, but in practice, it's just not going to work. We've had the Latino superstars down here and let them come and go (Pudge, Delgado, Castillo) we have a latino ultra-superstar right now (Miggy) and another in the making (Hanley). To me, I don't think the manager is a difference maker. We don't have a player established with the franchise ready to become the manager that will excite the fan-base (like Ozzie with the Sox). We tried bringing in a psuedo-name in Girardi, and he's got more name value in terms of marketing than Manny Acta or Freddi Gonzalez...
September 25, 200620 yr Author Interesting post. I highly doubt that the main reason that they would hire a latino manager would be to increase attendance. No one in the history of going to baseball games ever said to themselves, "I wasn't going to go to the game tonight, but Tony La Russa is managing and I want to watch him make a double switch." You're giving managers way too much credit in regard to their ability to help at the gate. I do believe that management is thinking that a latino manager could better communicate with our young latin players. I tend to agree although that isn't to say a white or black or asian manager couldn't do just as good a job. But because of the language barrier it might help slightly. Either way you look at it though, it is just a baseball manager. Their impact on the overall season is maybe a couple of games one way or the other. Just please make sure the new, likely latino, manager doesn't bunt with their hottest hitters or use sergio mitre in the 8th inning of one run games. Has there been a communication problem? It's not like they have many deep conversations in baseball. So long as some of the coaches speak Spanish (or Japanese, or whatever the players speak) there's nothing very complicated to be said. Do all the "Latino" players need it or very little. I think it's all meaningless. I have seen people from different countries, speaking enough of each others language to communicate about baseball. Without any problems. Take Miggy , for instance, he doesn't seem to have suffered from the Anglo managers he has had. And what do you do if you get a Japanese or Korean player? Have 2 managers, or more, one for each ethnic group? Get the best guy available, who will keep them motivated (with help from his coaches), put the right guys in the right positions, etc. Don't even think about his ethnicity, and don't give him a language test (After all, nobody understood McKeon, and he did just fine). There's very little oral communication involved. I happen to agree with you. My contention is merely IF they hire someone who is Latino (again, for about the third or fourth time) and the best candidate, it conceivably could open up marketing avenues they have not been able to exploit before. I thought Juanky was actually onto something with opening up a second radio broadcaster who offered the games in spanish. Perhaps Cape knows more on this, but I believe while the tv deal is longterm, the radio deal with QAM is not.
September 25, 200620 yr Author (After all, nobody understood McKeon, and he did just fine). :lol :lol I have to agree, I laughed like hell when I read that line
September 25, 200620 yr Interesting post. I highly doubt that the main reason that they would hire a latino manager would be to increase attendance. No one in the history of going to baseball games ever said to themselves, "I wasn't going to go to the game tonight, but Tony La Russa is managing and I want to watch him make a double switch." You're giving managers way too much credit in regard to their ability to help at the gate. I do believe that management is thinking that a latino manager could better communicate with our young latin players. I tend to agree although that isn't to say a white or black or asian manager couldn't do just as good a job. But because of the language barrier it might help slightly. Either way you look at it though, it is just a baseball manager. Their impact on the overall season is maybe a couple of games one way or the other. Just please make sure the new, likely latino, manager doesn't bunt with their hottest hitters or use sergio mitre in the 8th inning of one run games. Has there been a communication problem? It's not like they have many deep conversations in baseball. So long as some of the coaches speak Spanish (or Japanese, or whatever the players speak) there's nothing very complicated to be said. Do all the "Latino" players need it or very little. I think it's all meaningless. I have seen people from different countries, speaking enough of each others language to communicate about baseball. Without any problems. Take Miggy , for instance, he doesn't seem to have suffered from the Anglo managers he has had. And what do you do if you get a Japanese or Korean player? Have 2 managers, or more, one for each ethnic group? Get the best guy available, who will keep them motivated (with help from his coaches), put the right guys in the right positions, etc. Don't even think about his ethnicity, and don't give him a language test (After all, nobody understood McKeon, and he did just fine). There's very little oral communication involved. I happen to agree with you. My contention is merely IF they hire someone who is Latino (again, for about the third or fourth time) and the best candidate, it conceivably could open up marketing avenues they have not been able to exploit before. I thought Juanky was actually onto something with opening up a second radio broadcaster who offered the games in spanish. Perhaps Cape knows more on this, but I believe while the tv deal is longterm, the radio deal with QAM is not. I coulda sworn the WQAM deal was reupped a year or two ago.
September 25, 200620 yr Author I coulda sworn the WQAM deal was reupped a year or two ago. It was, and I don't remember precisely, but seems to me I remember it not being for a long duration, one, two, three years, not eight or ten, etc.
September 25, 200620 yr (After all, nobody understood McKeon, and he did just fine). :lol :lol I have to agree, I laughed like hell when I read that line Same here. :lol
September 25, 200620 yr If in 1997, when Livan joined the team and proceeded to reel off I believe his first 8-9 starts in the majors into wins.........on a great team in the thick of a playoff race.....the Hispanic fans still didn't show up.....then I don't think a Latino manager would add anything to attendance. We have the same problem with Latino attendance that we do with anglo attendance. . . It's good to know that there's some media down here that you think aren't Marlins haters though. I'm with you. Alot of the things the team does is directed at getting the Latino fannies in the seats and it just hasn't worked out very well. I think it is wrong to direct anything at one particular ethnic group. It has the opposite effect on all the other groups. We don't have an over abundance of Spanish speaking players on this team. And the ones that do speak Spanish seem to be doing just fine with the FO and coaching staff we have now. That being said, Big Cat had my vote last year to become the Marlins hitting coach. He still has my vote.
September 25, 200620 yr To me, the best manager is the one who will fit the position, no matter what their ethnicity. Spinning it to the reverse double standard, hiring a latin manager just because of the large latin population makes as much sense of hiring a white manager because of a large white population (say, Minnesota, for example). That wouldn't go over well, now would it? It's not the manager's job to go out and market the team, that's the job of the FO. You know, San Diego and San Antonio have large latin populations, so all there teams there should hire a latin manager? If you're a black manager and you finish with a bad record, you are a bad manager. If you're a white manager and you finish with a bad record, you are a bad manager. If you're a hispanic manager and you finish with a bad record, you are a bad manager. If you're an Asian manager and you finish with a bad record, you are a bad manager. Notice the trend?
September 25, 200620 yr If in 1997, when Livan joined the team and proceeded to reel off I believe his first 8-9 starts in the majors into wins.........on a great team in the thick of a playoff race.....the Hispanic fans still didn't show up.....then I don't think a Latino manager would add anything to attendance. We have the same problem with Latino attendance that we do with anglo attendance. I guess I admire your ability to differentiate Hispanics of European and African decent from non-Hispanics European and African decent. Lets say Hanley Ramirez and Matt Diaz weren't baseball players and were in the stands. Would you be consider them Hispanic or non-Hispanic?
September 25, 200620 yr If in 1997, when Livan joined the team and proceeded to reel off I believe his first 8-9 starts in the majors into wins.........on a great team in the thick of a playoff race.....the Hispanic fans still didn't show up.....then I don't think a Latino manager would add anything to attendance. We have the same problem with Latino attendance that we do with anglo attendance. I guess I admire your ability to differentiate Hispanics of European and African decent from non-Hispanics European and African decent. Lets say Hanley Ramirez and Matt Diaz weren't baseball players and were in the stands. Would you be consider them Hispanic or non-Hispanic? I totally see your point. Just as an example, there is a generation of Cubans who came here long before many on this board were born. They grew up in an era when Spanish was not commonly spoken throughout Miami or heard on TV. English was/is their primary language, they have no accent and most who came during that era are white with European backgrounds. They now have children and/or grandchildren who do not fit any latin stereotype. Some of them go to Marlins games as do some latins who look more like David Ortiz or anywhere in between?so I don?t get how people think they can look around and know. Oh, and Matt Diaz is Hispanic whether he knows how to pronounce his name or not. So are Jeremy Hermida and Bronson Arroyo.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.