Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Amezaga or Andino

Featured Replies

For lack of anything better to talk about, let's consider this scenario: Dan Uggla is actually a lot closer to being the .256 avg, .311 OBP, player he was in the second half of the season (or worse, the .630 OPS player he was in September), than he is to being the player that made us all hop onto his bandwagon during the first half of the season. After all, he was a Rule V pick and there isn't exactly a long history of success in such picks.

 

I'm not saying I'm off the Uggla bandwagon, but it's always good to be prepared for any eventualities. That said, do you think we would start Amezaga or Andino at 2B this year if Uggla struggles for the first couple of months? I imagine he'll be given at least 2 months to right his ship in case he starts off slowly, but if he continues to struggle after that...

It may be a big reason we're keeping Andino around. I see Uggla's BA/OBP numbers coming down a lot, but I still think he'll hit 17-20HR

If Uggla falls apart, I'd suspect he's keeping the spot warm for Coughlan more than Andino or Amezaga.

 

As we saw with Lowell in '05, and Reggie last year, Beinfest will absolutely not sit a player he expects to be a regular, no matter what the statistics say should be done.

Beinfest will absolutely not sit a player he expects to be a regular, no matter what the statistics say should be done.

 

I can understand that the gm has some say but arent the players on the field the ones selected by the manager

Even if he struggles, he's a better player than Amezaga or Andino will ever be. My vote is for dropping Uggla in the order IF he's not for real. I've seen nothing to suggest that is the case though.

Beinfest will absolutely not sit a player he expects to be a regular, no matter what the statistics say should be done.

 

I can understand that the gm has some say but arent the players on the field the ones selected by the manager

 

Not when it's painfully evident that our organization has pushed and pushed to have a yes-man in the dugout and anything less gets you canned.

 

Beinfest clearly calls the shots. Not that I have any issue with that, it's just how it is with us.

Beinfest will absolutely not sit a player he expects to be a regular, no matter what the statistics say should be done.

 

I can understand that the gm has some say but arent the players on the field the ones selected by the manager

 

Not when it's painfully evident that our organization has pushed and pushed to have a yes-man in the dugout and anything less gets you canned.

 

Beinfest clearly calls the shots. Not that I have any issue with that, it's just how it is with us.

 

because it happened last year with Girardi with his millitant attitude and napoleon syndrome?

 

no one seemed to mind Jack's moves when he was around

I think it is ridiculous to even consider Uggla's replacements at this point. Uggla just came out of an AS rookie record breaking season!

Beinfest will absolutely not sit a player he expects to be a regular, no matter what the statistics say should be done.

 

I can understand that the gm has some say but arent the players on the field the ones selected by the manager

 

Not when it's painfully evident that our organization has pushed and pushed to have a yes-man in the dugout and anything less gets you canned.

 

Beinfest clearly calls the shots. Not that I have any issue with that, it's just how it is with us.

 

because it happened last year with Girardi with his millitant attitude and napoleon syndrome?

 

no one seemed to mind Jack's moves when he was around

 

I don't see what you're talking about.

 

Girardi wasn't a yes-man. He got fired.

 

McKeon allegedly had a "him or me" meeting with Loria over Beinfest...guess who won.

 

Beinfest has had quite a few conflicts in his tenure here. Additionally, yesterday, Gonzalez announcing that he'll have a closer named by Wednesday and then is essentially told "here's your closer now" indicates who's calling the shots.

 

The past has also shown us that the one constant through all the non-pride swallowing seasons dating back to '05, has been Beinfest. Beinfest was here when Lowell didn't get sat down. Beinfest has an enormous obsession with Reggie (notice Reggie didn't get burried until Girardi was certainly fired) and Beinfest is making his calls already with Freddi.

 

Again, I'm not saying I have a problem with it, but if you don't think Beinfest is a little controlling, then there's something wrong.

 

Plenty of GM's do it, Billy Beane, for example, essentially admits to in in Moneyball so it's not as if I'm accusing Beinfest of something egregious, it's just what it is and it is painfully evident.

 

So, back on topic, past history suggests that it will take some form of catastrophic injury to dispalce Uggla this season.

Beinfest will absolutely not sit a player he expects to be a regular, no matter what the statistics say should be done.

 

I can understand that the gm has some say but arent the players on the field the ones selected by the manager

 

Not when it's painfully evident that our organization has pushed and pushed to have a yes-man in the dugout and anything less gets you canned.

 

Beinfest clearly calls the shots. Not that I have any issue with that, it's just how it is with us.

 

because it happened last year with Girardi with his millitant attitude and napoleon syndrome?

 

no one seemed to mind Jack's moves when he was around

 

I don't see what you're talking about.

 

Girardi wasn't a yes-man. He got fired.

 

McKeon allegedly had a "him or me" meeting with Loria over Beinfest...guess who won.

 

Beinfest has had quite a few conflicts in his tenure here. Additionally, yesterday, Gonzalez announcing that he'll have a closer named by Wednesday and then is essentially told "here's your closer now" indicates who's calling the shots.

 

The past has also shown us that the one constant through all the non-pride swallowing seasons dating back to '05, has been Beinfest. Beinfest was here when Lowell didn't get sat down. Beinfest has an enormous obsession with Reggie (notice Reggie didn't get burried until Girardi was certainly fired) and Beinfest is making his calls already with Freddi.

 

Again, I'm not saying I have a problem with it, but if you don't think Beinfest is a little controlling, then there's something wrong.

 

Plenty of GM's do it, Billy Beane, for example, essentially admits to in in Moneyball so it's not as if I'm accusing Beinfest of something egregious, it's just what it is and it is painfully evident.

 

So, back on topic, past history suggests that it will take some form of catastrophic injury to dispalce Uggla this season.

 

Not because of Beinfest. It is just the right thing to do

Beinfest has had quite a few conflicts in his tenure here. Additionally, yesterday, Gonzalez announcing that he'll have a closer named by Wednesday and then is essentially told "here's your closer now" indicates who's calling the shots.

 

well its a little different when the trade was made yesterday, a trade where you are bringing in someone with not only ML experience but closer experience to a staff that has absolutly none in the bigs

 

I do know that Beinfest calls all the shots and rightfully so but I think you are putting down the manager's role to nothing right now

Beinfest has had quite a few conflicts in his tenure here. Additionally, yesterday, Gonzalez announcing that he'll have a closer named by Wednesday and then is essentially told "here's your closer now" indicates who's calling the shots.

 

well its a little different when the trade was made yesterday, a trade where you are bringing in someone with not only ML experience but closer experience to a staff that has absolutly none in the bigs

 

I do know that Beinfest calls all the shots and rightfully so but I think you are putting down the manager's role to nothing right now

 

I'm not the first, do me a favor, read Moneyball.

This organization hasn't gotten rid of Andino because there is nothing to get rid of him for. We aren't keeping him to be Uggla's replacement but he will likely be dealt if the right deal comes along.

Beinfest has had quite a few conflicts in his tenure here. Additionally, yesterday, Gonzalez announcing that he'll have a closer named by Wednesday and then is essentially told "here's your closer now" indicates who's calling the shots.

 

well its a little different when the trade was made yesterday, a trade where you are bringing in someone with not only ML experience but closer experience to a staff that has absolutly none in the bigs

 

I do know that Beinfest calls all the shots and rightfully so but I think you are putting down the manager's role to nothing right now

 

I'm not the first, do me a favor, read Moneyball.

 

eh I'll pass thank you

Beinfest has had quite a few conflicts in his tenure here. Additionally, yesterday, Gonzalez announcing that he'll have a closer named by Wednesday and then is essentially told "here's your closer now" indicates who's calling the shots.

 

well its a little different when the trade was made yesterday, a trade where you are bringing in someone with not only ML experience but closer experience to a staff that has absolutly none in the bigs

 

I do know that Beinfest calls all the shots and rightfully so but I think you are putting down the manager's role to nothing right now

 

I'm not the first, do me a favor, read Moneyball.

Even Scout's Honor with its traditional bent contrasts with the popular view of a field manager's power

Beinfest has had quite a few conflicts in his tenure here. Additionally, yesterday, Gonzalez announcing that he'll have a closer named by Wednesday and then is essentially told "here's your closer now" indicates who's calling the shots.

 

well its a little different when the trade was made yesterday, a trade where you are bringing in someone with not only ML experience but closer experience to a staff that has absolutly none in the bigs

 

I do know that Beinfest calls all the shots and rightfully so but I think you are putting down the manager's role to nothing right now

 

I'm not the first, do me a favor, read Moneyball.

Even Scout's Honor with its traditional bent contrasts with the popular view of a field manager's power

fantastic read

I think Uggla won't repeat 2006. But if he does, a slumping Uggla will still be better than an Andino could ever hope to be.

at least andino would be solid defensively, hell, he and hanley could make a fantastic dp combo...

I think Uggla won't repeat 2006. But if he does, a slumping Uggla will still be better than an Andino could ever hope to be.

at least andino would be solid defensively, hell, he and hanley could make a fantastic dp combo...

You're saying Uggla is not solid defensively? I'm quite happy with the Hanley-Uggla-Jacobs DP, thanks.

I think Uggla won't repeat 2006. But if he does, a slumping Uggla will still be better than an Andino could ever hope to be.

at least andino would be solid defensively, hell, he and hanley could make a fantastic dp combo...

You're saying Uggla is not solid defensively? I'm quite happy with the Hanley-Uggla-Jacobs DP, thanks.

not at all...uggla plays hard and has a very strong arm...but should he ever go down or struggle, i think andino would be fine at 2nd

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.