Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Cinco de Mayo, 2007 - Padres @ Marlins - 7:05 p.m.

Featured Replies

hanley is a beast

 

Don't get me wrong, I appreciate Olivo's arm, but he isn't earning his paycheck. His inability to literally catch a baseball negates whatever other defensive strengths he has.

 

I have no idea who the player would be, but the Marlins need to start thinking about finding a replacement after this season.

with other catching situations in the league being what they are...olivo has still played head and shoulders above alot of other guys...even if he cant catch the ball all the time

around the horn dp...uggla is off big time

 

Hit and run.

 

hanley is a beast

 

Don't get me wrong, I appreciate Olivo's arm, but he isn't earning his paycheck. His inability to literally catch a baseball negates whatever other defensive strengths he has.

 

I have no idea who the player would be, but the Marlins need to start thinking about finding a replacement after this season.

with other catching situations in the league being what they are...olivo has still played head and shoulders above alot of other guys...even if he cant catch the ball all the time

Not really.

let me put it this way...the catching tandom of olivo/treanor is better than about 60% of other teams in the league

hanley is a beast

 

Don't get me wrong, I appreciate Olivo's arm, but he isn't earning his paycheck. His inability to literally catch a baseball negates whatever other defensive strengths he has.

 

I have no idea who the player would be, but the Marlins need to start thinking about finding a replacement after this season.

with other catching situations in the league being what they are...olivo has still played head and shoulders above alot of other guys...even if he cant catch the ball all the time

 

If a catcher cannot be consistently counted on to catch a ball, he is worthless. Period.

 

There's no "negating the running game" argument. Or "he can hit argument." Catchers with a bad defensive rap over the past decade have all been able to catch the ball, it's been throwing runners out that has been the problem.

 

If Olivo can't do priority #1, his ability to satisfy priority #2 is unimportant.

hanley is a beast

 

Don't get me wrong, I appreciate Olivo's arm, but he isn't earning his paycheck. His inability to literally catch a baseball negates whatever other defensive strengths he has.

 

I have no idea who the player would be, but the Marlins need to start thinking about finding a replacement after this season.

with other catching situations in the league being what they are...olivo has still played head and shoulders above alot of other guys...even if he cant catch the ball all the time

 

If a catcher cannot be consistently counted on to catch a ball, he is worthless. Period.

 

There's no "negating the running game" argument. Or "he can hit argument." Catchers with a bad defensive rap over the past decade have all been able to catch the ball, it's been throwing runners out that has been the problem.

 

If Olivo can't do priority #1, his ability to satisfy priority #2 is unimportant.

so in other words, what you are saying...is the olivo is useless because he isnt a defensive catcher...well...i disagree...the fact he CAN hit and throws runners out at a high rate make him very valuable and id be disappointed if we let him go if we didnt have any sort of a plan B...and just for the record...sandy alomar jr still sucks

hanley is a beast

 

Don't get me wrong, I appreciate Olivo's arm, but he isn't earning his paycheck. His inability to literally catch a baseball negates whatever other defensive strengths he has.

 

I have no idea who the player would be, but the Marlins need to start thinking about finding a replacement after this season.

with other catching situations in the league being what they are...olivo has still played head and shoulders above alot of other guys...even if he cant catch the ball all the time

 

If a catcher cannot be consistently counted on to catch a ball, he is worthless. Period.

 

There's no "negating the running game" argument. Or "he can hit argument." Catchers with a bad defensive rap over the past decade have all been able to catch the ball, it's been throwing runners out that has been the problem.

 

If Olivo can't do priority #1, his ability to satisfy priority #2 is unimportant.

so in other words, what you are saying...is the olivo is useless because he isnt a defensive catcher...well...i disagree...the fact he CAN hit and throws runners out at a high rate make him very valuable and id be disappointed if we let him go if we didnt have any sort of a plan B...and just for the record...sandy alomar jr still sucks

 

Yeah, that's exactly what I'm saying, that if a catcher can't catch it doesn't matter a lick what the rest of his resume is. If he's got such a great bat, he'll find another position.

 

Look at Piazza, look at Willingham, look at Biggio.

 

To his credit, Mitre has been decent

 

So far

 

Sure has.

hanley is a beast

 

Don't get me wrong, I appreciate Olivo's arm, but he isn't earning his paycheck. His inability to literally catch a baseball negates whatever other defensive strengths he has.

 

I have no idea who the player would be, but the Marlins need to start thinking about finding a replacement after this season.

with other catching situations in the league being what they are...olivo has still played head and shoulders above alot of other guys...even if he cant catch the ball all the time

 

If a catcher cannot be consistently counted on to catch a ball, he is worthless. Period.

 

There's no "negating the running game" argument. Or "he can hit argument." Catchers with a bad defensive rap over the past decade have all been able to catch the ball, it's been throwing runners out that has been the problem.

 

If Olivo can't do priority #1, his ability to satisfy priority #2 is unimportant.

so in other words, what you are saying...is the olivo is useless because he isnt a defensive catcher...well...i disagree...the fact he CAN hit and throws runners out at a high rate make him very valuable and id be disappointed if we let him go if we didnt have any sort of a plan B...and just for the record...sandy alomar jr still sucks

 

Yeah, that's exactly what I'm saying, that if a catcher can't catch it doesn't matter a lick what the rest of his resume is. If he's got such a great bat, he'll find another position.

 

Look at Piazza, look at Willingham, look at Biggio.

oh yeah...i think we should def throw olivo out in right field and let treanor catch...no...even better...i think you should be the catcher...i mean, you are a cathing defensive guru no? look...i understand your criticisms of olivo...it can be frustrating...but im pretty sure no one in here can name someone available that would be more valuable to our team that A. we can afford B. wants to play here C. isnt older than 35

hanley is a beast

 

Don't get me wrong, I appreciate Olivo's arm, but he isn't earning his paycheck. His inability to literally catch a baseball negates whatever other defensive strengths he has.

 

I have no idea who the player would be, but the Marlins need to start thinking about finding a replacement after this season.

with other catching situations in the league being what they are...olivo has still played head and shoulders above alot of other guys...even if he cant catch the ball all the time

 

If a catcher cannot be consistently counted on to catch a ball, he is worthless. Period.

 

There's no "negating the running game" argument. Or "he can hit argument." Catchers with a bad defensive rap over the past decade have all been able to catch the ball, it's been throwing runners out that has been the problem.

 

If Olivo can't do priority #1, his ability to satisfy priority #2 is unimportant.

so in other words, what you are saying...is the olivo is useless because he isnt a defensive catcher...well...i disagree...the fact he CAN hit and throws runners out at a high rate make him very valuable and id be disappointed if we let him go if we didnt have any sort of a plan B...and just for the record...sandy alomar jr still sucks

 

Yeah, that's exactly what I'm saying, that if a catcher can't catch it doesn't matter a lick what the rest of his resume is. If he's got such a great bat, he'll find another position.

 

Look at Piazza, look at Willingham, look at Biggio.

oh yeah...i think we should def throw olivo out in right field and let treanor catch...no...even better...i think you should be the catcher...i mean, you are a cathing defensive guru no? look...i understand your criticisms of olivo...it can be frustrating...but im pretty sure no one in here can name someone available that would be more valuable to our team that A. we can afford B. wants to play here C. isnt older than 35

 

And this is why this place sucks.

 

You can't even attempt anything intelligent before the inevitable "why don't YOU be the manager" cop-out is thrown.

 

Congrats on understanding where I was going. :thumbup

name someone better swifty and im with you, if you cant, quit ya complaining

 

Somone who's a better catcher?

 

Umm, there are about 27 of them. But just one? Joe Mauer.

 

Someone better in the system? Probably no one, arguably Treanor and definitely why we cannot have Olivo regarded as any sort of solution in our expected competitive future.

He's not worth 2 million plus incentives either.

 

And that's almost 100% truth.

 

Winfield seems like just an awesome guy to sit down and listen to his stories for an hour or two.

name someone better swifty and im with you, if you cant, quit ya complaining

 

Somone who's a better catcher?

 

Umm, there are about 27 of them. But just one? Joe Mauer.

 

Someone better in the system? Probably no one, arguably Treanor and definitely why we cannot have Olivo regarded as any sort of solution in our expected competitive future.

name someone better that is available...and no...our competitive future is based on keeping cabs, getting our pitching healthy and throwing strikes...if those happen...we will be a very competitive team for years and years

name someone better swifty and im with you, if you cant, quit ya complaining

 

Somone who's a better catcher?

 

Umm, there are about 27 of them. But just one? Joe Mauer.

 

Someone better in the system? Probably no one, arguably Treanor and definitely why we cannot have Olivo regarded as any sort of solution in our expected competitive future.

name someone better that is available...and no...our competitive future is based on keeping cabs, getting our pitching healthy and throwing strikes...if those happen...we will be a very competitive team for years and years

 

Texas disagrees with you that one fantastic player can win you ballgames.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.