December 14, 200322 yr -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Posted on Sun, Dec. 14, 2003 PROFESSIONAL SPORTS Some stadiums burden, not boon Dade, promising tourists and jobs, wants to spend millions on a Marlins stadium. But some county stadiums have failed to deliver. BY LESLEY CLARK lclark@herald.com Homestead had major-league dreams when it plunked down $21 million more than a decade ago to build a baseball stadium -- aspirations that evaporated when the Cleveland Indians decided to hold spring training elsewhere. Now the ballpark sits largely unused, derided as a ``pink elephant.'' Taxpayers in the city, though, pony up half a million dollars every year to keep the elephant in re-sale condition -- its paint fresh, its field mowed -- as the city searches for a buyer. Homestead isn't the only community to succumb to the lure of the sports siren, promising prestige, jobs and tourists to cities that put up tax dollars for stadiums. Taxpayers in Miami-Dade County spend more than $20 million a year on operating subsidies and debt service for three sports facilities -- Homestead-Miami Speedway, AmericanAirlines Arena and the money-losing Miami Arena, long ago abandoned by the Miami Heat and the Florida Panthers. Most of the bonds will take another two decades to pay off, and in some cases the return to taxpayers is negligible. Yet the county is poised to tap taxpayers once again, embracing a plan to spend $73 million in hotel bed taxes to build a stadium for the Florida Marlins, who say they're losing millions on rent and lost opportunities sharing a stadium with the Miami Dolphins. ''The reality of baseball for the Marlins is that unless they can play in their own stadium they'll be leaving,'' said Miami-Dade Mayor Alex Penelas, who announced the Marlins proposal just hours after the team was feted for its second World Series win. 'I don't want to be the one fielding the question `Why did you let the Marlins leave?' '' said Penelas, who is seeking the Democratic nomination for the U.S. Senate. Supporters of public financing argue that sports teams enrich communities and that few team owners are wealthy enough to build facilities without help. The sports world points to Pro Player Stadium as the case study: The Robbie family financed its construction but, burdened by debt, unloaded the football stadium and the team less than a decade later. The Marlins are putting up some of their own cash for the stadium, Penelas said. And he noted that the county's contribution will come from a 6 percent bed tax levied on tourists and reserved for convention centers, the arts and professional sports. ''We've got these dedicated funds set aside. It's all part of building a community,'' Penelas said. HOMESTEAD LESSONS Critics, though, point to Homestead as a precautionary tale. Not only is the city that narrowly averted bankruptcy saddled with the baseball stadium, abandoned by Major League Baseball after Hurricane Andrew, it has also spent years propping up a racetrack. Only now -- eight years after it opened -- is Homestead-Miami Speedway beginning to pay for itself, its rent to the city covering most of the annual principal and interest on the bonds. Homestead taxpayers, though, are stuck with the $750,000-plus annual tab for the racetrack's property tax. Miami-Dade County taxpayers still pay for a bond on the racetrack, too. ''Sometimes these sports facilities can really cost a community money,'' said Homestead City Manager Curt Ivey, who inherited both projects. ECONOMIC BENEFITS Backers of the facilities argue that sports teams spur economic development and provide jobs. Ivey cites an estimate by the owners of the racetrack that its premier event, a NASCAR race, generates $117 million annually for the city. Visitors eat at local restaurants, shop in stores and fill up their gas tanks. ''Now that it's going, all in all, it's a good thing for us,'' Ivey said. ``It's like hosting the Super Bowl.'' As for the county, it does have a profit-sharing agreement with the Heat for AmericanAirlines Arena, but the team has yet to make enough money to share with the county, finance officials said. Voters, though, apparently aren't buying the argument that tax dollars should be spent on facilities for private sports teams. A recent telephone poll conducted for The Herald and The St. Petersburg Times found 80 percent of registered voters statewide oppose using state tax dollars to build a ballpark for the Marlins. Critics argue that the money would be better spent elsewhere, pointing to studies that have found that major sports facilities create few jobs and, in some cases, cost more than they contribute. Miami-Dade County Commissioner Jimmy Morales suggests looking no further than the downtown Miami Arena. The 14,500-seat stadium has struggled to find tenants since the sports teams fled for flashier and roomier facilities, and its losses are estimated at about $1 million a year. Even during its heyday, Morales said, the arena never attracted development beyond parking lots. ''Studies I've seen nationally show minimal impact with stadiums,'' Morales said. ``And the local evidence is overwhelming. Point me to one place where a stadium has provided economic development in Dade County.'' LOOKING DOWNTOWN Miami Commissioner Johnny Winton, whose district includes the neighborhood where the Miami Arena sits, blames the initial agreement for the arena's woes -- the arena was built for the Miami Heat, but the team was only required to sign a 10-year lease. ''With a baseball stadium or a Miami arena, when you lose your primary tenant, you're dead,'' Winton said. ``I'm absolutely opposed to putting up public money for professional sports unless there's a guarantee from someone that the occupant is going to be using the facility or paying rent for as long as it takes to retire the bonds.'' Miami-Dade required the Heat to sign a 30-year lease, and Penelas said the Marlins would be required to pay until the bond is satisfied. ''That goes without saying, absolutely,'' Penelas said. ``We're going to do it right.'' http://www.miami.com/mld/miamiherald/news/local/7486502.htm
December 14, 200322 yr Homestead should have had something signed with the Indians that would have kept them in that stadium. But they didn't and now it just sits out there and does nothing. :thumbdown
December 14, 200322 yr Homestead should have had something signed with the Indians that would have kept them in that stadium. But they didn't and now it just sits out there and does nothing. :thumbdown Just like that racetrack. That is why that article is bad. A spring training facility in Homestead, and a racetrack to be used like once or twice a year are projects that are set to doom. But a baseball stadium? More potential than Miguel Cabrera.
December 15, 200322 yr Realistically, how is it that a racetrack and spring training facility could be compared to a Major League park that is busy 6 months a year? When you have a negative bias, as does the Miami Herald, then it becomes an easy comparison to make, especially if you are hell bent to submarine the Marlins. :thumbdown The idea of a "statewide" poll to determine stadium interest is absurd. What voters outside South Florida would be interested in paying taxes for a stadium not in their locale? Anyone could have predicted the result before the poll was given. To cite the poll result as a referendum on the stadium is ridiculous and demonstrates the Herald's negative stadium bias. :thumbdown Having the Marlins commit to the stadium until the bonds are paid off does make good sense though, and should provide all the insurance the tax payers need to goo forward with the project. Loria and the Marlins have quite a bit of skin in the game, and have shown they're committed to fielding a successful team. :thumbup
December 15, 200322 yr That is why that article is bad. A spring training facility in Homestead, and a racetrack to be used like once or twice a year are projects that are set to doom Alot of racetracks in Nascar are out in the middle of nowhere and are only used maybe once or twice every year. I'm not going to turn this into a Nascar thread( ), but once Indy and Nascar has come and gone....you'll just have to wait till next year.
December 15, 200322 yr I've been meaning to post on this all day but never got around to it. Glad someone else did. This article is so replete with half-truths and missing information if it wasn't so damaging to the Marlins it would be laughable. Clearly the Herald intends to go with their main man, Wayne H. and do everything in their power to keep the Marlins from getting a stadium. Their version of what happened to the Miami Arena is so distorted, so absent a true retelling of what transpired that it is scandalous. What really happened was a member of the Huizenga clan gained controlled of the Arena's management company paved the way for the Panthers to move to Broward. I could go on and on but I won't, at least not tonight. We should probably expect at least one negative (biased) piece a week in the Herald between now and March 15.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.