Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Valid

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Valid

  1. Calling them overhyped and overpriced is silly. I mean, they haven't even gotten paid yet.
  2. Well I'm not talking about deals. I'm talking about monster trade offers. Two different things. Saying "it never works" is silly. Like, you're basically saying that Seager, Pederson, etc. would work out for any other team but the Marlins.
  3. Hey, if Jose is going to sign here long-term, awesome. But he will probably command somewhere in the neighborhood of $300 million. Not sure if I see the Marlins giving that to a pitcher who has already had injury issues.
  4. What bad trade did we make in 2012? And in 2014, we traded Disco for Latos. Everyone thought it was a great deal. It didn't work out. It happens. And I don't give a damn about him "identifying" with the fans and the community. I care about winning baseball games, and if you can make a deal that gives you a better opportunity to do that now and in the future, you do it. And lol at you calling the Dodgers prospects "overhyped." You are clearly speaking from the heart rather than the mind. Look, I don't want to trade Jose either, but again, if a great deal comes along, you have to at least consider it.
  5. Oh so because the Cabrera trade didn't work out, we should never make another big trade again? And how wouldn't it benefit the team nearly as much as keeping Jose (which we might not even do once he comes up for FA)? Explain.
  6. Maybe because a Godfather-type package could (and probably would) actually benefit this team in the long run? It's acceptable to trade anybody if you get a monster offer that could plug a bunch of holes with elite young talent and make other players expendable in the process.
  7. Yeah. Let's forget the fact that the Yankees can offer one of the best packages. Let's cross them off our list because we don't like them.
  8. That lineup is beyond nasty. Never thought I'd be this open to trading Fernandez.
  9. Yep. Either haul would be really nice. I love Jose, but if we can get THAT kind of a deal for him, you do it. It patches up our roster with more young talent and makes other players expendable to land even more pieces.
  10. While I wholeheartedly agree that trading him would suck, it's hard to not be enamored with the types of returns we could potentially get. Severino, Bird and Judge, for example, is awfully tempting.
  11. This has nothing to do with disagreeing. You are either a.) missing the point, or b.) being incredibly stubborn. Just because a team takes offers does not mean a player is being shopped. All players are available. It would be silly for a team not to listen to offers on their best players. If someone called and made an offer on Stanton, we'd listen. Also, every tweet we have seen from beat writers is that the Marlins are asking for a king's ransom for Jose and that they aren't shopping him. You are the only one who seems to think otherwise.
  12. You're still not understanding the point, are you?
  13. Well, that's not the question here. The question is whether or not players would come to Miami, and they certainly would if offered the money. And for what it's worth, Loria opened up his checkbook last year and prior to 2012. The idea that he doesn't spend at all is a myth. He may not do it consistently, but he does on occasion.
  14. This should be clear as day to everyone on this forum. I don't know why it's so hard for some people to understand. If the Astros came to the Marlins and said, "Hey, we'll give you Correa, Springer and McCullers for Jose," the Marlins would be stupid not to at least have a conversation about it.
  15. Yeah you're right. Teams never, ever take phone calls on superstar players, and superstar players never, ever get shopped/traded. EVERYONE in the league is available for the right price. General managers and executives wouldn't be doing their jobs if they didn't at least listen to offers.
  16. But you said players don't want to come to Miami. If the Marlins pay them, they will come. That has been proven several times already. I think we as fans put more stock into front-office culture than players do. In all actuality, they really don't care that much.
  17. And you know this how? Have you talked to every front office around the league?
  18. Well, I mean, at the time, it was. Maybin and Miller were two blue-chip prospects. Not the Marlins' fault that both of them bombed in Florida.
  19. Yeah but he's been outperforming his peripherals for three years now. Might just be one of "those" guys (kind of like how Nolasco's peripherals always looked better than his tangible results).
  20. Jeff Baker? Is that you?
  21. Very doubtful.
  22. Happ...fuck that guy.
  23. Oh definitely, and to be perfectly honest, with Alvarez out (gone?), he'd probably be our second-best starter. But hey; we need to shore up the staff somehow, and Gallardo is probably the best realistic option available.
  24. Gallardo's declining strikeout rate is definitely worrisome, but he still gets a ton of ground balls and only allowed 15 homers last year in a hitter's park. Plus, he eats innings. I think getting him would be pretty cool on the right deal.
  25. But for $100 million? I'm all for making a push for Samardzija, but for a reasonable amount. Giving a guy who posted a 4.96 ERA and 4.23 FIP last season (with scary GB/FB stats, as well) $100 million is an incredibly risky move.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.