Who is the Best 2nd Base of All Time?

[FreshFish]

Ken Boswell

Joe Morgan

Eddie Collins

Pete Rose

Rod Carew

Rogers Hornsby

Charlie Gehringer

Jackie Robinson

Ryne Sandberg

Nap Lajoie

Craig Biggio

Tony Lazzeri

Roberto Alomar

Other (please specify)

 

Who do you rather have in your team at the prime of their careers?

[Special K]

Ryne Sandberg, hands down

[AJB34]

hornsby, manos abajo :notworthy

[Hugg]

You asked 2 different questions.

 

Best 2B of all time?

Probably Hornsby.

 

Who would I take in their prime?

Alfonso Soriano.

 

None of those other 2B have touched the seasons he's put up the last 2 years.

[Wild Card]

It wouldn't be fair to say Rose, considering he played just about everywhere.

 

Because I'm fairly young, I'll go with Alomar and Soriano.

[FreshFish]

It wouldn't be fair to say Rose, considering he played just about everywhere.

 

Because I'm fairly young, I'll go with Alomar and Soriano.

good point on Rose.

 

Soriano may be too young to be considered one of the best of all time.

[catchoftheday]

RYNO !!!

[SorianoFanHFW]

Hornsby (OPS+)

 

Will Soriano be it? Well, he's 28, but if he improves his on base and without that scary yankee stadium power gap, he can do amazing things...unbelievable things.

 

However, he's stuck at 1 homer now...but so is sheffield.