May 6, 200422 yr I think Encarnacion was even shocked to see it called an out, the play wasnt even close sometimes if its a trap and the umpire calls it an out I can deal with it but today was pretty far fetched. He pulled a "Conine". Just as Conine refused to try and pull that ball out from under the fence what convinced the umps was Enc just laying there. Had he gotten up and thrown to the cutoff man that would indicated he didn't make the play. It was a great piece of acting. Acting? What do you mean? Do you mean he was acting like he actually caught it? Hmmm... I thought it was called cheating. I thought it was weak move by Juan. The blown call by the ump is just baseball. It happens. But the move by Juan was not; that's called cheating. :thumbdown cheating? ... cheating? .... dude he's trying to win thats all. there is no need to blame Juan or any other player for that matter, its not their fault, they are only doing their job. either way a big NO~NO to RE'plays It's not the players job to pretend they had the ball all along. I just can't agree with that, but I would bet that most share your view. The umpire made the wrong call. That's the real issue here, and that was not Juan's fualt. But what Juan did was not acting, it was cheating. He knew the ball hit the ground; he tried to pretend the ball was in his glove. It's cheating. No big deal. I am not saying he is to be considered a "cheat" for the rest of his career. I am just saying that he was cheating in that one instance. I will say this, though: most right fielders wouldn't even have gotten close enough to that ball to pretend anything[i/]. Let's not make this a big debate. I feel that when a players knows he dropped the ball, and then picks it up and pretends he had it all along, it's cheating. Does the pitcher love him for it? Yes. Do his teammates love him for it? Yes. Do his fans love him for it? Yes. Do the opposing players like it? Absolutely not. Should he be suspended? Hell no. Does it make him a cheater for that one play? Yes. Still, Juan may be the best right field glove in all of baseball (note I said "glove", not arm, although his arm isn't to shabby either). Ichiro is better defensively ... and has a more accurate arm. plus he's bada** :notworthy
May 6, 200422 yr They showed the replay of Encarnacion dropping the ball in slow motion at least 5 times up on the jumbotron when all 4 umps were discussing it. Would it have been that hard for them to look up at it and just see it? But either way, at least umps don't blow calls like this every night like NBA refs do. The NBA has the worst officials in professional sports. If I were to rank officials in pro sports, I would probably go with the NHL, NFL, MLB, stick every sport on earth in this spot, then finally the NBA.
May 6, 200422 yr Well, at least they showed that replay. They never ever show replays at JRS. It pisses me off. And I would have to say MLB has better umps than NFL has refs. The only officials better than the MLB is the NHL's. You have to remember, every play is based on an official's judgement in baseball. They do their job well.
May 6, 200422 yr Umpires should have that instant camera that they have on Football. That would be awesome and no bad calls!
May 6, 200422 yr It's not the players job to pretend they had the ball all along. I just can't agree with that, but I would bet that most share your view. The umpire made the wrong call. That's the real issue here, and that was not Juan's fualt. But what Juan did was not acting, it was cheating. He knew the ball hit the ground; he tried to pretend the ball was in his glove. It's cheating. No big deal. I am not saying he is to be considered a "cheat" for the rest of his career. I am just saying that he was cheating in that one instance. I will say this, though: most right fielders wouldn't even have gotten close enough to that ball to pretend anything[i/]. Let's not make this a big debate. I feel that when a players knows he dropped the ball, and then picks it up and pretends he had it all along, it's cheating. Does the pitcher love him for it? Yes. Do his teammates love him for it? Yes. Do his fans love him for it? Yes. Do the opposing players like it? Absolutely not. Should he be suspended? Hell no. Does it make him a cheater for that one play? Yes. Still, Juan may be the best right field glove in all of baseball (note I said "glove", not arm, although his arm isn't to shabby either). *umps have meeting and descide it was a catch* *encarnacion suspiciously sprints towards the crew chief* encarnacion, "sorry, it wasnt a catch. it hit the ground. im so ashamed i didnt mention this earlier" *sprints back into right field*
May 7, 200422 yr The MLB is behind other sports. It's time they started using some technology in their game-deciding calls.
May 7, 200422 yr It's not the players job to pretend they had the ball all along. I just can't agree with that, but I would bet that most share your view. The umpire made the wrong call. That's the real issue here, and that was not Juan's fualt. But what Juan did was not acting, it was cheating. He knew the ball hit the ground; he tried to pretend the ball was in his glove. It's cheating. No big deal. I am not saying he is to be considered a "cheat" for the rest of his career. I am just saying that he was cheating in that one instance. I will say this, though: most right fielders wouldn't even have gotten close enough to that ball to pretend anything[i/]. Let's not make this a big debate. I feel that when a players knows he dropped the ball, and then picks it up and pretends he had it all along, it's cheating. Does the pitcher love him for it? Yes. Do his teammates love him for it? Yes. Do his fans love him for it? Yes. Do the opposing players like it? Absolutely not. Should he be suspended? Hell no. Does it make him a cheater for that one play? Yes. Still, Juan may be the best right field glove in all of baseball (note I said "glove", not arm, although his arm isn't to shabby either). *umps have meeting and descide it was a catch* *encarnacion suspiciously sprints towards the crew chief* encarnacion, "sorry, it wasnt a catch. it hit the ground. im so ashamed i didnt mention this earlier" *sprints back into right field* Or of course, he could just pick up the ball the moment he dropped it and toss it back in... Didn't think of that one, huh? :blink: :blink:
May 7, 200422 yr Or of course, he could just pick up the ball the moment he dropped it and toss it back in... Didn't think of that one, huh? :blink: :blink: that changes absolutely NOTHING, isnt he supposed to throw it in anyways? or is the ball supposed to stay in his hand for the rest of the game :whistle
May 7, 200422 yr Jesus Christ... let's drop it. I eluded from the very beginning that I was simply breaking down a single play. It is my opinion that when you do something like Juan did, you cheat. It would have been different if he trapped the ball and wasn't sure he did. That was not the case. :banghead Goddamn... let it go. That was 3 days ago! You are trying to change my mind, but your arguments are horrible. He hid the ball in his right hand trying to fool the umps into thinking it was an out. That is not heads-up baseball. That is cheating. Just because you do something that helps your team, does not excuse it from being considered cheating. Ok? Enough? Let's talk Padres... (And comparing this to what Conine did in Philly is missing the point. Conine was abiding by the rules of the game. He had an option to go after it, but instead he did what he was supposed to do to notify the umps that the ball was stuck under the fence by throwing his hands up. That is NOT cheating, even if the Philly fans thinks it was.)
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.