July 25, 200422 yr I appreciate GiantsFan's polls, but I think we should have a more inclusive topic on this, because I find predicting who will be a HoF and who won't be a fascinating discussion. My picks based on the moment, active players (excluding McGwire, Gwynn, Ripken, Boggs, and Rickey!): Clemens Johnson Pedro Maddux Glavine Bonds Manny Bagwell Thomas Alomar Griffey Piazza Pudge A-Rod Jeter Sosa Palmeiro Rivera Near shoo-ins based on age: Pujols Vlad Rolen On the cusp: Larkin Williams Biggio Thome Schilling No dice: Sheff Smoltz McGriff Brown Edgar Giambi Need a couple of more seasons to make sure: Chipper Nomar Helton
July 25, 200422 yr Players eligible who should be in the hall: -Ryne Sandberg -Ron Santo -Andre Dawson -Jim Rice -Goose Gossage -Bruce Sutter
July 25, 200422 yr Clemens Johnson Pedro Maddux Glavine Bonds Bagwell Alomar Griffey Piazza Pudge A-Rod Jeter Sosa Palmeiro Rivera
July 25, 200422 yr My list of top 10 active players: 1. Barry Bonds 2. Roger Clemens 3. Randy Johnson 4. Greg Maddux/Tom Glavine 5. Curt Schilling 6. Rafael Palmeiro 7. Sammy Sosa 8. Mariano Rivera 9. Pudge Rodriguez 10. Fred McGriff
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.