January 10, 200521 yr Dwayne's good in all aspects of the game, whereas Cabrera is not. 651992[/snapback] Cabrera's also playing out of position, that's not a fair evaluation. 651996[/snapback] Wade also played out of his position during his entire rookie season, so it is a fair evaluation. 652034[/snapback] The playing out of position thing for these two guys is fundamentally different. Moving Wade to PG from SG is like moving Cabrera from 3rd base to shortstop... Moving Cabrera from 3rd base to OF is like moving Wade from guard to forward. So, no, it's not the same.
January 10, 200521 yr It is so difficult to compare. It is much easier to dominate in basketball. Dwayne has the upper hand right now, but Miguel will probably become the bigger superstar.
January 10, 200521 yr Dwayne's good in all aspects of the game, whereas Cabrera is not. 651992[/snapback] Cabrera's also playing out of position, that's not a fair evaluation. 651996[/snapback] Wade also played out of his position during his entire rookie season, so it is a fair evaluation. 652034[/snapback] Fine, so Cabrera's rookie season was better than Wade's. Cabrera plugged himself right into a playoff contender, came up huge in the playoffs and didn't hurt the team while bouncing around in the outfield. He also elevated his game when his team needed him most: see, Game 7 NLCS and Game 4 of the World Series. 652038[/snapback] wade single handedly won that hornets series 652040[/snapback] Basketball's a different type of game. If we could, Cabrera would be our go to guy, but because we have to get through the lineup, it's a little difficult. Without Cabrera, I have a hard time believing we win Game 7 of the NLCS because he squashed the "invincibility" of Wood by homering off him in the first inning...same can be said for Clemens in Game 4, and let's not forget what he did in the 8th inning in Game 6 of the NLCS.
January 10, 200521 yr They are both going to the Hall of Fame one day. They both have the talent to be the best in the game, bar none. However, right this very second, D Wade is better. His team is #1 in their conference, he's top 5 in the NBA right now and one could argue he is the best guard in the game at the moment, and he still has plenty of improving to do. Miguelito isn't top 5 just yet, and he hasn't done quite everything Wade has, but they both have a flair for the dramatic in big spots and I wouldn't be surprised if they were both MVPs in the same season at least once if not a couple times.
January 10, 200521 yr Defense is still part of the game and while he may be out of position in RF, that is where he is. However, Wade is a superior defender in basketball. They are both already proving their offensive gifts, however, I have to say Wade is more special. He is arguably the best at his position in the entire NBA. However, the same can not be said for Cabrera yet.
January 10, 200521 yr Whats the Shaq effect on Wade? I know he performs well when Shaq isnt there but the other two guards who had the Shaq effect did also. Kobe and Penny were amazing too with Shaq but Penny was never the same post Shaq and Kobe is starting to show the same. Im not saying Wade is as bad as Penny or will end up like Kobe. But how much of the fg% increase is Shaq? In that sense its harder to guage on Wade since in basketball, youre affected by your teammates but not in baseball. Ill give Wade credit though. He is awesome.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.