Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

NL East midterm grades

Featured Replies

I'm not complaining about the optimism, I think it's great and is warranted. But when everyone starts citing a rating given in an article on the official site I get a little weary, Especially on this board, which is filled with contempt for the baseball press in general.

 

All I'm saying is that you can't have it both ways. When someone (either local or national) writes a negative article or says something negative on TV they are branded here as subjective, negative, out to get the Marlins, etc...

 

But when a positive story comes out on the MLB site it's the word of God.

Hey, it is a rating, the Braves and Phillies didn't do as well. The Expos got an A for overacheiving. It is realistic at the minimum. At least we have a source that isn't negative till the end of the world on this team. Their articles have lots of facts, which I like. They are not really opinions but facts. Facts have no preference.

The Braves, with the best record in baseball, and the Phils, who are leading the WC race, didn't get ratings as high as the Marlins?

 

Yeah, that sounds realistic. Sounds like opinions to me, not fact.

This year's Braves were supposed to be in a tight race with the Phils. The Braves pitching has not been good and they did not start the season well. The Phillies have underperformed alot.

 

Braves got a B considering they were supposed to have good pitching, and the Phils got a C because they are not performing well, what's the Problem?

  • Author

The Braves, with the best record in baseball, and the Phils, who are leading the WC race, didn't get ratings as high as the Marlins?

 

Yeah, that sounds realistic. Sounds like opinions to me, not fact.

Fish, this wasnt written by a Marlins writer

This year's Braves were supposed to be in a tight race with the Phils. The Braves pitching has not been good and they did not start the season well. The Phillies have underperformed alot.

 

If that's the case I want the Marlins' pitching to not be good, for them to have started the season well and to underperform themsleves right into the playoffs.

Fillet, the braves were supposed to be blowing away everyone. Yet they are losing the season series to the Marlins, Expos, and Phillies. They do well outside the division, but not inside of it. It is a divisional review.

The Marlins and Expos have performed above all expectations. The Braves and Phillies have not. They have actually underachieved considering how they were touted.

 

We deserve the grade we got. Same as everyone else.

  • Author

Braves have NOT underachieved

 

maybe their pitching has

 

but they werent supposed to win the East

 

not only are the winning it..... they are running away with it

Braves have NOT underachieved

 

maybe their pitching has

 

but they werent supposed to win the East

 

not only are the winning it..... they are running away with it

TY Ramp. I guess the best record in baseball isn't enough to deserve a grade as good as the Fish. Maybe to get an A the Braves had to be sooo good that teams in their division would forfeit. Would that do it?

Braves were supposed to win the NL East. They have underperformed in the division. Look at their report card and see why he gave it to them. Not very difficult.

  • Author

Braves were supposed to win the NL East. They have underperformed in the division. Look at their report card and see why he gave it to them. Not very difficult.

um no they werent

 

this was supposed to be the year the dynasty ended

BRAVES (61-32)

 

A decade-plus of pitching-dictated success supposedly began to bore Atlanta fans. Tomahawk-choppers: This is your wake-up call. Zoned Javy Lopez needed all of 54 games to reach 23 homers, Gary Sheffield and Andruw Jones are also in the 20s, and Chipper Jones is just warming up.

 

Greg Maddux / P

Height: 6'0"

Weight: 185

Bats/Throws: R/R

 

More info:

Player page

Stats

Splits

Braves site

 

 

 

Worst-case scenario: Three of the new starters (Shane Reynolds, Paul Byrd, Hampton) will have a combined total of nine wins entering the All-Star break; the lone incumbent (Maddux) will have more losses than in all of 2002 with double the ERA. It's happening, and the Braves still have the Majors' best record and the NL's biggest division lead.

 

It's official: If Schuerholz were rear-ended while driving to work, it would be by Tyra Banks.

 

Grade: B-plus; slouched much of the term, but aced the test by pulling some all-nighters.

 

Award candidate(s): Horacio Ramirez, Rookie of the Year; Kid Stopper hasn't lost in three months, bringing some sanity to a crazy rotation.

 

Remote control: Clone John Smoltz and stick one of them in the rotation. On days he pitches, bat Hampton No. 8 and Vinny Castilla No. 9. Give back Ted Turner his seats.

 

Predicted finish: Second place in NL East.

This guys is a Braves hater then, wow what a bad thing. We still have half a season and the Braves come back to play in the division alot this half. They do not play well in the division.

The Braves have a losing record within the division anyway! They should be better than what they are now. EVEN BETTER. But they aren't. The Phillies have drasticaly under achieved offensively, and maybe over achieved pitching wise, but ultimately have under achieved. The Marlins and Expos have easily over achieved. No one expected us or them to be as good as we are. And we are only getting better.

The dynasty could ahve ended this year, bu we still have half a season left.

They have it on lay away...

I think its great that we got a "B".......thats pretty good, but hopefully by the end of the

year we can push our grade up to an "A" and make the playoffs.

I think its great that we got a "B".......thats pretty good, but hopefully by the end of the

year we can push our grade up to an "A" and make the playoffs.

We don't want an A. Apparently the better you perform the worse grade you get.

 

And who cares about how well the Braves perform in their division? I'd hope and pray the Marlins lost every single game to everyone in their division if it meant they had the best record in baseball.

 

The Bravo's have had a 1423 game lead since April, and chances are they won't be playing anyone in the division in the PO's anyway.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.