Hideki Matsui and Capuano for Adam Dunn

 

Would you do this trade, either side, give your opinion, PLEASE?

Which side is yours?

I would recieve Adam Dunn, this hasnt been offered to me and I havent offered it yet, me and the other guy are talking trade and that is something I thought of. What do you think?

chris capuano isnt really a fantasy stud and doesnt hold much value

 

 

 

I'm honestly a huge mastui fan... he's a very underrated fantasy player. Dunn will get you HR's and thats all

it all depends on your standing is this a rotiseire league, or head to head basically it is trading Matsui for Dunn, CApuano isnt a real fantasy player, Dunn can swipe some bags and hit HRs thats about it. Matsui is overall a well rounded fantasy player. Will put up a decent avg. rack up the runs, rbis and homers behind that monsterous Yankee offense. I would do it for matsui

JJ hit it off mostly. It also depends upon your positions and if you need to worry about Dunn's Ks as he has alot of them. If it is a head to head league with few catagories that is one thing. But if it is deep and keeps track of alot of things then I wouldnt. If you need to free space for a pick up or someone on the DL, I would then. The one thing to remember is the Yankees always score alot.

 

Still, as you said you were gonna offer it up. Cant hurt to try, just to mix up things if you need a change.

I'd do it, but you almost have to have a huge average guy (like Ichiro) to offset Dunn's all or nothing fantasy presence. Dunn can kill a lot of your categories in a deep league (I have him on two of my teams) if he has an off week.

If this were my league, I'd say no frickin way because we count OPS.

 

I still don't think I'd do it. Matsui has been bad since the first 4 days of the season and Capuano is nothing to count on.