August 13, 200323 yr I know its late and over and thankfully none of it really mattered in the end thanks to Ramon Castro. Nothing makes me angrier then an old sweat drenched pig on an authority trip. I feel the reasoning for such horrible umpire work recently in the majors is due to the MLB Umpire Union which if you dont know is one of the strongest unions in the country. This means umpires basically can not be fired for poor performance, bad judgement, or even diminished skills. In my opinion its really bad for the game knowing that a game in rookie league is probably called more fairly by younger better umpires then it is in the greatest baseball league in the world.
August 13, 200323 yr Pudge's ejection last night was a genuine rip-off. First of all, Pudge got the player, I don't remember which one, and second, he shouldn't have been ejected for throwing his mask off. Ugh. :thumbdown Stupid umps. :angry
August 13, 200323 yr This means umpires basically can not be fired for poor performance, bad judgement, or even diminished skills. Talk about job security. So pretty much, no one gets fired...they just retire.
August 13, 200323 yr Pudge's ejection last night was a genuine rip-off. First of all, Pudge got the player, I don't remember which one, and second, he shouldn't have been ejected for throwing his mask off. Ugh. :thumbdown Stupid umps. :angry Hey don't worry everything happens for a good reason,pudge was out(ejected) then came red,and then came ray and what happened he hit a homer and we won,so maybe we can all notice that things happen for a reason. :thumbup
August 13, 200323 yr Pudge's ejection last night was a genuine rip-off. First of all, Pudge got the player, I don't remember which one, and second, he shouldn't have been ejected for throwing his mask off. Ugh. :thumbdown Stupid umps. :angry Hey don't worry everything happens for a good reason,pudge was out(ejected) then came red,and then came ray and what happened he hit a homer and we won,so maybe we can all notice that things happen for a reason. :thumbup Yes, except if you remember, the run that the Dodgers scored on the ejection play gave them their fourth run, which forced us into extra innings later. If they hadn't scored, we would have most likely won the game 4-3 in 9 innings. :thumbup
August 13, 200323 yr but whats the fun in that futuregm? Plus, we all wanted to see Castro get some ABs....it wouldnt have happened if Pudge hadnt gotten tossed. I mean, winning 4-3 is cool...but winning 5-4 in extras on a walkoff hr by a board-favorite 3rd string catcher is just d*mn cool!
August 13, 200323 yr I didn't say it really mattered, but I was concerned that we would lose the game in extras. Fortunately, we didn't.
August 13, 200323 yr I'm not too knowledgable on the whole umpire situation. Is there no "governing body" that rates umpires according to their calls? I know I've heard of some professional sport doing that, but I don't know which one it is right now. Damn bronchitis medication!
August 13, 200323 yr The play at the Plate with Pudge was safe, the runner never touched home pudge was blocking it.....
August 13, 200323 yr I'm not too knowledgable on the whole umpire situation. Is there no "governing body" that rates umpires according to their calls? I know I've heard of some professional sport doing that, but I don't know which one it is right now. Damn bronchitis medication! the Union is too powerful in baseball, it would never be allowed. Questec sort of does the job, but if anyone read the article in the Dontrelle ESPN Mag about Questec you all know what a crock it is.
August 13, 200323 yr The play at the Plate with Pudge was safe, the runner never touched home pudge was blocking it..... Wouldn't that make it out then?
August 13, 200323 yr he was definitely out. Gammons on BBTN was funny...he started talkin about something else (I think the fact that Pudge got ejected), and talked like it was fact that he was out, and that it was a bad call. Kinda funny.
August 13, 200323 yr Umps hate us.....always have.....always will I bet EVERY team's fans say that, too.
August 13, 200323 yr i guess because there are sooooo many close calls every single game... i mean, in one at bat, there could be 2 close ball/strike calls, one call if the batter checked his swing, one call if the batter beat the throw from the SS t o 1st base it might get out of control
August 13, 200323 yr If they ever went to any kind of replay system, they'd have to have a challenge system, where the manager has 1 or 2 challenges per game. They're already concerned the game is too long as it is and instant replay can add a lot of time (as we've seen in the NFL).
August 13, 200323 yr Well then they should establish something like the NFL in which there is a penalty, in their case it's losing a time out, for second-guessing a call.
August 13, 200323 yr Which only brings up the arguement for instant replay in close calls such as that. What is the matter with baseball that it is so entrenched in tradition that it can't take advantage of technology? If I were the commish, that's the first thing I would do- institute instant replay on challenged calls. OK, let me start off by saying I'm not a big fan of instant replay. I remember it being used in a Marlins game a while back and while it helped the umps make the right call I think the umps have enough siteline to see the plays. It isn't like the NFL where there are 22 players on the field to watch. In baseball the four umpires combined can see all angles of the field at once. Most of the time 2 or more umps can view a play perfectly. That is why one ump can overrule another. Here is why baseball will not use the instant replay system unless an ump directly calls for it in a game (as was the case in a Marlins game a couple years back). In football a team risks a timeout. Whats the risk in baseball? Because if there is no risk every other call will be challenged and umps will lose their objectivity.
August 13, 200323 yr and then they would need to establish what can or cannot be challenged... i like it better without it...(even though it costs us sometimes)
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.