September 18, 200521 yr Sort of an offshoot from the drug legality thread: Often times people on this board will refer to themselves as libertarian in one form or another. Some have argued that the libertarian party's biggest error is to prioritize drug legalization over economic liberty. My question is, what exactly does one who advocates greater liberty, ie a libertarian, advocate? In my mind, social liberties are the most vital thing to defend. That government cannot encroach on our basic right to do and act as we wish as long as those individual actions do not encroach on others(ie your rights end on my door). This, however, also has to be reconciled with the idea of the social contract and the existence of a unified political body to carry out communal goals. (ie the idea that government builds our roads). Hence I also believe that taxes, even though they encroach on our ability to keep our money to ourselves, are necessary for the existence of a nation or state or city. I dont think any libertarian would argue that all taxes should be abolished(or would they?). So my argument has always been that government spending tax revenue on social programs, open for debate in effectiveness, has not encroached on our liberties or our ability to do or act as we wish. This is the case because we have already told government they can take our money. The encroachment has happened and was allowed. But the way they spend it cannot be a violation. So with that in mind, am I a libertarian? At least by my view. What do others think liberty and hence libertarianism is about?
September 18, 200521 yr Liberty is when you've got time off after a long day humping a ruck 20 miles in the field and you can go out with your buddies. oh wait, you didn't mean that kind of liberty :mischief .
September 19, 200521 yr Sort of an offshoot from the drug legality thread: Often times people on this board will refer to themselves as libertarian in one form or another. Some have argued that the libertarian party's biggest error is to prioritize drug legalization over economic liberty. My question is, what exactly does one who advocates greater liberty, ie a libertarian, advocate? In my mind, social liberties are the most vital thing to defend. That government cannot encroach on our basic right to do and act as we wish as long as those individual actions do not encroach on others(ie your rights end on my door). This, however, also has to be reconciled with the idea of the social contract and the existence of a unified political body to carry out communal goals. (ie the idea that government builds our roads). Hence I also believe that taxes, even though they encroach on our ability to keep our money to ourselves, are necessary for the existence of a nation or state or city. I dont think any libertarian would argue that all taxes should be abolished(or would they?). So my argument has always been that government spending tax revenue on social programs, open for debate in effectiveness, has not encroached on our liberties or our ability to do or act as we wish. This is the case because we have already told government they can take our money. The encroachment has happened and was allowed. But the way they spend it cannot be a violation. So with that in mind, am I a libertarian? At least by my view. What do others think liberty and hence libertarianism is about? 951835[/snapback] A libertarian would say yes, there should be public roads, but individuals shouldn't be taxed to pay for them. The roads, should pay for themselves and be on a toll system. You pay the toll, you use the road. Therefore, unused, or useless roads fall into ruin and get reclaimed by nature or some farmer, whoever. While roads for the greatest amount of utility (greatest good for the greatest number) function alive and well in a society. It's all about personal freedom and to do whatever you want (within reason, short of hurting anyone else). You have that part down. However, the thing with libertarians is, don't come in and say you have to do this or you have to do that. If the government says, "Okay, we're going to come in and tax a little more out of you, to go towards Hurricane relief." A libertarian is going to say, "No. You're not. I'll either give or not give. But it's my choice, not yours." Taxing with libertarians is a VERY tricky issue and there's a schism between the nuts who say no taxes (which, of course I don't believe in) and that individuals should be willing to pay for their government out of their own pocket when they FEEL like it (crazy, huh?). That, if government is necessary and serves a purpose, like the aforementioned road, then someone will pay for it's use. However, I fall in line with the libertarians who say minimal taxing. It's necessary for establishing a small military, militia, police force, legislative body, whatever. Whatever it takes to keep the peace. You need firemen, you need cops. So, yes, they should be paid in advance out of tax dollars, etc. Libertarian statement: "You have the freedom to swing your fist as violently as you want, in whatever manner you want, wherever you want, short of hitting the end of someone elses nose." So, personal freedom to you and yours, on your land. Just don't expect that same freedom on someone elses plot. I could go into more detail about utility and whatnot and even tell you some more CRAZY libertarian/utilitarian stuff that might drive you bonkers, but I'll wait for a reaction/reply. Or even see if there's interest in this kind of thing. I might be teaching a course on John Mill (Libertarian/Utilitarian and THE man) in the future, so... I'M interested.
September 20, 200521 yr I agree with buckeye but i want to touch on the social v economic scope of libertarianism. The problem is it is inconsistent and perhaps illogical to say that govt needs to stay out of your 'social' life but its ok for them to stay in your 'financial' life. To simplify buckeyes quote even further is the traditional saying "My rights end where yours begin" The only role if the federal govt is to protect those rights, which are life, liberty, and property. A, as buckeye says, more extreme libertarian would even argue that our defense should be primarily based on militia and that the national army should merely be a congregation of the state militias to be used as needed. As far as taxes go, i believe that the real problem is federal taxation, b/c that is increasing the power of the feds too much, the idea being that a good federal govt should not have so much money at its disposal for fears that it becomes too powerful. Welfare and those sorts of things as a realist, i think should be made efficient. In other words more bang for your buck. Fix problems so that the programs can run effectively but attempt to save money in the process. A typical democrat plan of action has been that if a program doesnt work it should be assumed that it needs more funding to work. Clinton (and congress) changed this thinking partially in attempts to reform such programs. The problem is that many of these programs need to reformed at a state level. Then we reach a philosophical disagreement in which a libertarian believes in the individual and that with the cards hes dealt it is his ultimate job to do what he must. Wealth or success are results of hard work and determination not solely on luck. (oversimplified) Finally, my argument against the party's legalization issue, is that although i agree with legalization, it is not a politically sound argument. Most people dont want legalizaton, because they have a preconceived notion that it will bring negative results. However, if the party focuses more on individual liberty (social and economic), smaller govt (which includes dimishing power of executive branch which bush has arguably enhanced), then the party wil be able to gain steam
September 21, 200521 yr I believe that this country is on the verge of revolt against our waning ?inalienable? rights. I find it almost unfathomable that so many of these changes have gone unchallenged. The Patriot Act is the most embarrassingly unconstitutional piece of legislation to escape the Supreme Court?s judgment since prohibition. Our individual rights are being taken away at an almost exponential rate these days. For me, the straw that broke the camel?s back was the Supreme Court?s decision on eminent domain. For all you need to know on the subject, here?s an excerpt from Sandra Day O?Connor?s dissenting paper: Any property may now be taken for the benefit of another private party, but the fallout from this decision will not be random. The beneficiaries are likely to be those citizens with disproportionate influence and power in the political process, including large corporations and development firms. That is insane! Let my Town just TRY to take my land so they can build a Wal-Mart. I will go vigilante so quick, the Town Board wouldn?t know what smacked them upside their greedy little heads! I think it is little wonder that ?Libertarians? are starting to come out of the woodwork. Our government has grown too large to be effective thanks to a military with no budget, social programs that overburden our system, and a moral/religious agenda that has no place in our culture. You can only take so much away before the American people wake up and take a stand.
September 21, 200521 yr Actually whats interesting about the eminent domain ruling is that it invloved matters of stautory interpretation not constitutional matters. This means that state legislatures can make statutes that make that ruling irrelevant in the forum state. By the way what provisions of the patriot act are you referring to? B/c alot of the patriot act is a reiteration of FISA, which has been around for a while. I'm not disagreeing with you im just curious.
September 22, 200521 yr I think, quite simply, that libertarianism is just a return to classical liberalism, the ideals of Smith and Locke. If you look at what a libertarian stands for, they line almost exactly with classical liberal ideals. Take someone like me, on a rather hot button issue. I'm against abortion, for religious beliefs. I was born and raised Roman Catholic and in my growing maturity have decided that this religion fits my beliefs the best. I don't believe that life should be terminated in anything except capital punishment (get back to me on that one later), therefore my opinion. However, I'm pro-choice. Why? Well, murder is wrong. But have we proved that what's inside a woman's body is a life? No. And as long as it's not legally a life, it is the woman's responsibility to do with it as she wishes since it is her body. Plus, I might not believe in abortion, but it's not my place in the world to force my beliefs on someone else. This is a case where you would just allow the government to step away and allow people to make personal decisions based on their established biases. I guess I'll get into more issues if necessary, but that sums up alot if you just branch it out to everything else. I believe buckeye's mention of the highways is another great example. If you use something, you pay for it. If you don't, you don't get billed. Simple as that. I'm also of the belief that most current Republicans under 30 (and maybe even some Democrats) are truly Libertarians at heart.
September 22, 200521 yr I think, quite simply, that libertarianism is just a return to classical liberalism, the ideals of Smith and Locke. If you look at what a libertarian stands for, they line almost exactly with classical liberal ideals. Take someone like me, on a rather hot button issue. I'm against abortion, for religious beliefs. I was born and raised Roman Catholic and in my growing maturity have decided that this religion fits my beliefs the best. I don't believe that life should be terminated in anything except capital punishment (get back to me on that one later), therefore my opinion. However, I'm pro-choice. Why? Well, murder is wrong. But have we proved that what's inside a woman's body is a life? No. And as long as it's not legally a life, it is the woman's responsibility to do with it as she wishes since it is her body. Plus, I might not believe in abortion, but it's not my place in the world to force my beliefs on someone else. This is a case where you would just allow the government to step away and allow people to make personal decisions based on their established biases. I guess I'll get into more issues if necessary, but that sums up alot if you just branch it out to everything else. I believe buckeye's mention of the highways is another great example. If you use something, you pay for it. If you don't, you don't get billed. Simple as that. I'm also of the belief that most current Republicans under 30 (and maybe even some Democrats) are truly Libertarians at heart. 957540[/snapback] Also, and this is an interesting conundrums, if a TRUE libertarian is walking next to a small pond and see's a baby drowning then he can keep walking and NOT save the baby. That means, true libertarians are willing to bite that bullet, and allow for that guy NOT to be punished as a result of leaving the baby. You are NOT obligates to help others and vice versa.
September 22, 200521 yr I think, quite simply, that libertarianism is just a return to classical liberalism, the ideals of Smith and Locke. If you look at what a libertarian stands for, they line almost exactly with classical liberal ideals. Take someone like me, on a rather hot button issue. I'm against abortion, for religious beliefs. I was born and raised Roman Catholic and in my growing maturity have decided that this religion fits my beliefs the best. I don't believe that life should be terminated in anything except capital punishment (get back to me on that one later), therefore my opinion. However, I'm pro-choice. Why? Well, murder is wrong. But have we proved that what's inside a woman's body is a life? No. And as long as it's not legally a life, it is the woman's responsibility to do with it as she wishes since it is her body. Plus, I might not believe in abortion, but it's not my place in the world to force my beliefs on someone else. This is a case where you would just allow the government to step away and allow people to make personal decisions based on their established biases. I guess I'll get into more issues if necessary, but that sums up alot if you just branch it out to everything else. I believe buckeye's mention of the highways is another great example. If you use something, you pay for it. If you don't, you don't get billed. Simple as that. I'm also of the belief that most current Republicans under 30 (and maybe even some Democrats) are truly Libertarians at heart. Also, and this is an interesting conundrums, if a TRUE libertarian is walking next to a small pond and see's a baby drowning then he can keep walking and NOT save the baby. That means, true libertarians are willing to bite that bullet, and allow for that guy NOT to be punished as a result of leaving the baby. You are NOT obligates to help others and vice versa.I agree, in a true classical liberal / libertarian state, you don't have to do anything except pay the minimal taxes necessary to run the state that does exist. However, it is also the system's belief (and my own) that you don't have to force people to be good, the majority of them will do it anyways becomes in the end being good is more beneficial than being bad. Not doing something isn't a crime, it's only when you do something that you should be held accountable.
September 22, 200521 yr I'm also of the belief that most current Republicans under 30 (and maybe even some Democrats) are truly Libertarians at heart. 957540[/snapback] I'd agree with that statement for the most part. A lot of Libertarians that I know were raised by Republicans and believe the republican principles on economics. Most young people also tend to be socially liberal. Of the conservatives I know, most have told me that they considered themselves moderate republicans during their college years and shortly after just because at the time their stance on social issues conflicted with the republican ideology. Most of them now, claim to be full fledge conservatives. So that leads me to assume the following that could be flat out wrong but whatever, The LP party survives on participation of college students and other young people who for the most part eventually transform into Republicans. As I look at The LP's vote totals, outside of a strong year in 80(the only time they got at least 1% of the vote), the LP party has maintained a steady vote count, usually anywhere from .3 to .5. Yet, I still run into many LP members who are young people. Yet, with this influx of new blood they still maintain for the most part the same results in Elections. That just leads me to believe, many eventually leave the party as they grow. I may be dead wrong but that's just what I see.
September 22, 200521 yr I'm thinking many are like me. They keep themselves aligned with the Republican party, thinking they can maybe make some changes to it in the future. However since there isn't a significant movement to dethrone one of the bigger parties as of yet, they stick to being Republicans so that the complete opposite of what they believe in (in their opinion) doesn't make it into power. If, for some reason, the youth holds on to their current alignments into the future, we could see a major battle between libertarianism and socialism. Which would be alot of fun.
September 22, 200521 yr I'm thinking many are like me. They keep themselves alighned with the Republican party, thinking they can maybe make some changes to it in the future. However since there isn't a significant movement to dethrone one of the bigger parties as of yet, they stick to being Republicans so that the complete opposite of what they believe in (in their opinion) doesn't make it into power. If, for some reason, the youth holds on to their current alignments into the future, we could see a major battle between libertarianism and socialism. Which would be alot of fun. 957645[/snapback] I don't really see Libertarianism ever become a major threat of a party but it's not out of the question that they become a consistent king maker in elections. Although, I disagree with The LP's platform a great deal(Socially Conservative, an economic liberal), I don't really mind them just because I believe they do a good service in pointing out government waste. A small dream of mine, would be them used as consultants from both parties to point on staunch government waste that often gets overlooked due to the sheer size of it(e.g. the infamous 50 million dollar bridge in Alaska for an island of 50) and help cut out the extreme waste. Only a pipe dream, but I believe it could do a world of good, in diverting funds to neccesary programs without raising taxes.
September 22, 200521 yr (Socially Conservative, an economic liberal) Err, sure you're talking about the right party there cap'n?
September 22, 200521 yr Author (Socially Conservative, an economic liberal) Err, sure you're talking about the right party there cap'n? 957794[/snapback] I think he is. I think he means in the modern concepts of conservative and liberal. Rune sounds to me like a New Deal democrat. One who believes in the economic principles of FDR but not the overreaching elements of the 60s social liberals.
September 22, 200521 yr Yeah, but if he's describing libertarians he has it backwards - they are fiscally conservative and socially liberal.
September 22, 200521 yr Author Yeah, but if he's describing libertarians he has it backwards - they are fiscally conservative and socially liberal. 957909[/snapback] No I think he was describing his views as socially conservative and fiscally liberal and thats why he disagrees with the LP platform so much.
September 22, 200521 yr Also, and this is an interesting conundrums, if a TRUE libertarian is walking next to a small pond and see's a baby drowning then he can keep walking and NOT save the baby. That means, true libertarians are willing to bite that bullet, and allow for that guy NOT to be punished as a result of leaving the baby. You are NOT obligates to help others and vice versa. That's not true at all. Libertarianism is, as the name implies, the belief in liberty. Libertarians believe that each person owns his own life and property, and has the right to make his own choices as to how he lives his life - as long as he simply respects the same right of others to do the same. This does not prevent a Libertarian from helping his neighbor, it simply means that the government should not be able to force him to. The irony in this whole thing is that there is usually a very strong sense of community in a Libertarian and they tend to be draw towards voluntary service in the military, fire service, and ambulance service. Again, however, the key here is that this service is VOLUNTARY. This may see counterintuitive until you really think about it. You would think that a Libertarian would have no interest in volunteering for their local fire department, for example. However, a Libertarian would WANT to volunteer because it gives him an opportunity to guarantee the protection of his family and property by his own involvement and connections in the fire services. This is in sharp contrast to a socialist perspective where a person would feel no obligation to volunteer because this is a service that should be provided for them.
September 22, 200521 yr Also, and this is an interesting conundrums, if a TRUE libertarian is walking next to a small pond and see's a baby drowning then he can keep walking and NOT save the baby. That means, true libertarians are willing to bite that bullet, and allow for that guy NOT to be punished as a result of leaving the baby. You are NOT obligates to help others and vice versa. That's not true at all. Libertarianism is, as the name implies, the belief in liberty. Libertarians believe that each person owns his own life and property, and has the right to make his own choices as to how he lives his life - as long as he simply respects the same right of others to do the same. This does not prevent a Libertarian from helping his neighbor, it simply means that the government should not be able to force him to. The irony in this whole thing is that there is usually a very strong sense of community in a Libertarian and they tend to be draw towards voluntary service in the military, fire service, and ambulance service. Again, however, the key here is that this service is VOLUNTARY. This may see counterintuitive until you really think about it. You would think that a Libertarian would have no interest in volunteering for their local fire department, for example. However, a Libertarian would WANT to volunteer because it gives him an opportunity to guarantee the protection of his family and property by his own involvement and connections in the fire services. This is in sharp contrast to a socialist perspective where a person would feel no obligation to volunteer because this is a service that should be provided for them. Exactly making my point right. It's VOLUNTARY. You don't HAVE to help the baby. You're not punished for not doing so. Obviously, in the case I mentioned, we like babies, so we'd help the kid out. But, if you don't, you can say, "Oh, man, he's callous! He's a jerk, he's an a**hole," whatever. But what you CANNOT say, if you're a libertarian is, "What you did was WRONG." It's a small and philosophical distinction, but VERY important. The baby was only used because babies give people a certain reaction. Which is where I think you might be coming from.
September 23, 200521 yr You may be right. I guess my initial point was "Screw my neighbor as long as I'm okay" is certainly not part of the Libertarian philosophy. For some reason, that's what I took away from your previous post. The larger point was that I found it interesting how few individuals with proclivities towards socialism take part in volunteer community organizations in comparison to individuals who have more libertarian views. It seems almost paradoxical.
September 24, 200521 yr Thats bc socialism doesnt have any type of philosophical basis on helping people personally. The idea is to make the rich through the power of the state pay for others. It focuses on an overall or common good rather than liberatrianism that focuses on the rights of individuals. As individuals we can chose to help other individuals. Reliance on the state takes away from doing stuff on your own.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.