Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

An idea to save the Marlins

Featured Replies

I have an idea that is a compromise. Since it's a compromise it's, by definition, not the best solution for each of the parties involved but it solves everyone's problems. Here's the idea:

 

The Orange Bowl gets destroyed and a new dual purpose dome is built in its place.

 

It's a fixed dome that is designed to be comfortable for both sports. It can be done. The dual use stadiums of the past were ugly and uniform but sightlines were not an issue. One could be designed one that is more aesthetically pleasing than previous ones.

 

A fixed dome would cost much less than a retractable one. The stadium could be designed with glass walls below the dome to allow natural light to enter during the daytime and have less of a feeling of being enclosed. It would be climate controlled perfect weather for every game.

 

The turf would have to be artificial, but they have made big advancements in turf and it's a much better than it used to be. Also converting from baseball to football would be much easier and the football team wouldn't have to worry about playing in dirt.

 

Between the Marlins and the Hurricanes there will be 87 guaranteed dates per year. The MIAMI Marlins stay in town, Hurricanes fans and alumni are happy.

 

Ok let the dissecting and complaints begin...

Not the worst idea to be posted here but a couple of things to consider - if the stadium is not owned/managed/controlled by the Marlins there goes all the concession and advertising and naming rights $$$, so you're right back where you started.

 

Also a fixed dome would require an artificial surface which I suspect neither team would find acceptable.

:banghead

 

how many times have we heard samson and company say THEY DONT WANT TO SHARE A STADIUM

 

also that neighborhood sucks, id rather not hear any shootings during my baseball game.

 

and the hurricanes wouldnt share a place with us....

 

so good try

  • Author

The ballpark proposal that was on the table before, the one that was going to be next to the OB, included terms that the City would own the ballpark. The team would derive the ancillary revenues associated with ownership but would not, in fact, own it. They'd be paying rent. In fact that's where the majority of the $200 million the team offered would be coming from. Rent payments.

 

As far as sharing goes, I don't agree that that is the problem. The problem is not sharing in the revenue. Sharing 6 dates per year isn't an issue it's making sure that you get the revenue for your 81 dates. As far as actually sharing the playing surface, the Dolphins were the ones that were suffering because of the dirt infield.

 

I addressed the turf issue. In college football artificial turf is pretty common. And the Nike Field turf they use these days is much better than old stuff that was like a carpet. None of the newer ballparks use turf but there are certainly a few that still use it. Skydome, Metrodome, The one in Tampa, etc. Again it's not the ideal but it solves a huge problem.

how many times have we heard samson and company say THEY DONT WANT TO SHARE A STADIUM

 

I haven't. Have you? The problem with the dual purpose and adjoined stadium proposals are that they ask to the Marlins to sign a lease that, like their abusive one presently signed with Huizenga, they would receive reduced revenue shares of sky box sales, parking and concessions.

how many times have we heard samson and company say THEY DONT WANT TO SHARE A STADIUM

 

I haven't. Have you? The problem with the dual purpose and adjoined stadium proposals are that they ask to the Marlins to sign a lease that, like their abusive one presently signed with Huizenga, they would receive reduced revenue shares of sky box sales, parking and concessions.

 

 

um and you kidding? theyve said this at least 100 times within 3 years here.

Maybe in the context of reduced revenue, but never in my memory of a blatant refusal to share its facility. Heck, the Orange Bowl proposal that came the closest to being realized rested on the premise that it was going to be used for community events, concerts and conventions during the season and offseason.

Maybe in the context of reduced revenue, but never in my memory of a blatant refusal to share its facility. Heck, the Orange Bowl proposal that came the closest to being realized rested on the premise that it was going to be used for community events, concerts and conventions during the season and offseason.

 

The Marlins FO has been cristal clear on that they want a baseball only facility. Could it be use for other events like concerts, etc.? Sure why not.

 

But the seating location, design, athmosphere, etc would all be with baseball in mind

  • Author

81 dates per year vs. 6 and the proportional revenue would be "main tenant" territory in my book.

I have an idea that is a compromise. Since it's a compromise it's, by definition, not the best solution for each of the parties involved but it solves everyone's problems. Here's the idea:

 

The Orange Bowl gets destroyed and a new dual purpose dome is built in its place.

 

It's a fixed dome that is designed to be comfortable for both sports. It can be done. The dual use stadiums of the past were ugly and uniform but sightlines were not an issue. One could be designed one that is more aesthetically pleasing than previous ones.

 

A fixed dome would cost much less than a retractable one. The stadium could be designed with glass walls below the dome to allow natural light to enter during the daytime and have less of a feeling of being enclosed. It would be climate controlled perfect weather for every game.

 

The turf would have to be artificial, but they have made big advancements in turf and it's a much better than it used to be. Also converting from baseball to football would be much easier and the football team wouldn't have to worry about playing in dirt.

 

Between the Marlins and the Hurricanes there will be 87 guaranteed dates per year. The MIAMI Marlins stay in town, Hurricanes fans and alumni are happy.

 

Ok let the dissecting and complaints begin...

 

 

Some people just don't get it.

  • Author

OK genius, what's your plan?

 

Insert jeopardy theme song here.

 

I work in the creative field. When you have an assigment, a deadline, you begin to brainstorm. Not every idea is feasible or great but sometimes better ideas are born as variations of so so ideas. In a brainstorm it's not very productive to shoot an idea down flat because it may just be the best idea available. It's easy to sit behind a terminal and say: "That won't work!"

 

So we have a huge problem. We're all fans and none of us want the Marlins to leave town. In order to achieve our ends we may have to give up on some of our requirements like "The stadium should be next door to my house."

 

And it's not so easy for a franchise to leave town. The Marlins may have to accept a deal that's less than what they'd like, whether it's here or elsewhere. So just because they say soemthing is unacceptable doesn't mean that they won't negotiate it away. And this is all about negotiation.

I mean its not really all that difficult. Baseball is done in Miami. The orange bowl and such is done by the city of Miami. The Marlins are done with Miami. As in, no more talk with them at all. zero

 

Domes are crap, anyone will tell you that. There will never be another domed stadium built in this nation that is actually useful. Period.

 

Artifical turf is pretty much crap, although there have been major strides in this stuff.

 

Bottom line is that someone is going to have to step up to keep the Marlins in south Florida. Its up to the cities, counties, etc to give the marlins a call and make a realistic offer.

 

You had better believe other cities will be doing the same. I think the organization has said many times they fully want to stay in South Florida, but sometimes things are out of your control.

81 dates per year vs. 6 and the proportional revenue would be "main tenant" territory in my book.

 

Not necessarily true, as witnessed by the lease the Oakland Athletics have or the city proposed the Marlins for the adjoined Orange Bowl stadium. The Baltimore Orioles and Colts used to go back and forth between being the one with the more favorable lease.

"also that neighborhood sucks, id rather not hear any shootings during my baseball game"

 

Are you serious?!? Have you been to that area of town? It's a bunch of old cubans, it is not dangerous. It's not the prettiest part of town, nor the wealthiest...but dangerous?!? You've got to be kidding... The only gunshots you're likely to hear there is of the INS boys going in to grab Elian..lol

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.