Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

No Pokey

Featured Replies

The Marlins would be best served by having Willingham play the vast majority of his games out in left field. Let him work in the Winter Leagues as a catcher. Maybe in a few years he'll be a valuable defensively as he potentially looks to be offensively. The Marlins young pitching staff needs someone with more major league experience handling pitchers. The 8 or 9 young pitchers working on their pitching skills likely mean more to the Marlins future than the 1 player working on his catching skills.

 

 

Someone on another thread suggested we could try to acquire Alex Cintron from the D-backs to fill the Pokey slot. Too late. Arizona traded him to the White Sox...

 

http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/news/story?id=2359426

I don't care what you think about Willingham. What I'm telling you that is when it comes to measuring a catcher's tangible performance, the difference is minimal. In every advanced metric of evaluating defense, the best and worse catcher are seperated by a much smaller difference than that of any other position (even RFers). Let me make this more simple for you. Let's assume Willingham is on par with the worse 2005 starting catcher across the board (am I giving him too much credit, Spike?) What is the exact difference between the most terrible and best? 8 errors, 5 passed balls, 90 steals (a very high figure, over the three previous years it was never over 60, but whatever) and less than 5 misplayed bunts or pop-ups. That's an approximate 100 bases given at the expense of 10 outs. Now let's compare that to corner outfielders. The disparity was 9 errors, 30 misplayed balls in their zone (estimated using the following formula: chances x (2 - zone rating) - chances). That's 75 bases at the expense of 39 outs. Now remember that outs are way more important than an advanced base! And that's not even including the effect that an outfielder's arm can have, which some suggest is up to 11 runs. Just for reference, the advanced metrics note the difference between the best and worst catchers between 15 and 20 runs.

For the sake of the OF Willingham needs to play LF. That will keep him fresh and allow the better defensive catcher- Olivo to play and nurse the young pitchers. There is nobody else for the OF unless a vet. is acquired or something. All the national mags are saying Willingham in LF

  • Author

I don't care what you think about Willingham. What I'm telling you that is when it comes to measuring a catcher's tangible performance, the difference is minimal. In every advanced metric of evaluating defense, the best and worse catcher are seperated by a much smaller difference than that of any other position (even RFers). Let me make this more simple for you. Let's assume Willingham is on par with the worse 2005 starting catcher across the board (am I giving him too much credit, Spike?) What is the exact difference between the most terrible and best? 8 errors, 5 passed balls, 90 steals (a very high figure, over the three previous years it was never over 60, but whatever) and less than 5 misplayed bunts or pop-ups. That's an approximate 100 bases given at the expense of 10 outs. Now let's compare that to corner outfielders. The disparity was 9 errors, 30 misplayed balls in their zone (estimated using the following formula: chances x (2 - zone rating) - chances). That's 75 bases at the expense of 39 outs. Now remember that outs are way more important than an advanced base! And that's not even including the effect that an outfielder's arm can have, which some suggest is up to 11 runs. Just for reference, the advanced metrics note the difference between the best and worst catchers between 15 and 20 runs.

 

:thumbup

 

It's silly. We could have an .800+ OPS catcher, or a normal LF. This argument is stupid. Let's play Stokes over Jacobs because he is much better defensively. That's what this Willingham/Olivo argument is saying. If Willingham can catch, I'd rather magically put Jacobs in LF - because at 1B he will cost more runs then Willingham behind the plate - and play Stokes at 1B everyday. I know this can't happen in reality, but this Olivo thing is just mind boggling stupid. And we want Dan Uggla to start at 2B.

 

Unlike Uggla/Amezaga - where neither players will hit big league pitching, you take the defensive player in that situation. When it's Abercrombie/Reed for CF, you take the defense with Reed. When it's a potentially large offensive threat like Willingham or Jacobs, you work with the defense at the expense of their bat. Their offensive output overcomes whatever defensive downgrade they have.

 

We should all be praying Willingham isn't atrocious defensively so we can play him back there. And regardless of that, if he is atrocious and the team determines he can't catch, left field is still wide open because this organization has only 1 pure outfielder with starting potential.

I guess it doesn't matter that Jacobs has a reconstructed (torn) labrum and it could be argued making all those throws from left field over a 162 season is nothing less than a prescription for disaster.

 

With less than ten games under the team's belt, it's a bit premature to be determining who should be playing where. Just like it's premature to be stating as fact that this player or that will not be able to hit ML pitching.

I guess it doesn't matter that Jacobs has a reconstructed (torn) labrum and it could be argued making all those throws from left field over a 162 season is nothing less than a prescription for disaster.

 

With less than ten games under the team's belt, it's a bit premature to be determining who should be playing where. Just like it's premature to be stating as fact that this player or that will not be able to hit ML pitching.

 

You're right 03. Projecting out how these players will perform at the Major League level with the ridiculously low amount of playing time is ludicrous. Trying to project out stats is an exercise in futility. I'd like to see how Willingham, Hermidia, Jacobs, HanRam, Olivo, and all the young arms....perform over the next 2-3 years, both offensively and defensively. I was just going on the broad supposition that our young pitchers would be better served with a catcher with some major league experience. Someone who knows the hitters. Who knows how to help his pitcher with the calling of the pitch, framing strikes, calming him down, talking to the ump. All the intangibles. Keeping LoDuca and Castillo for another year would have been optimally best for the team's future as a whole.

It seems rather arrogant to say that Olivo has the better intangibles (sic? how can intangibles even be compared?) because he's the better catch-and-throw guy.

Olivo's had just 24 more games in the NL, most of them in late season divisional competition, and has less than a month's experience with our pitchers. What makes you think he will handle them any better than a guy who has caught many of them over the past few years in the majors, minors, spring training, and watched our NL and NL East competition from behind the plate and on the bench for longer than Olivo's even been in the NL?

It seems rather arrogant to say that Olivo has the better intangibles (sic? how can intangibles even be compared?) because he's the better catch-and-throw guy.

Olivo's had just 24 more games in the NL, most of them in late season divisional competition, and has less than a month's experience with our pitchers. What makes you think he will handle them any better than a guy who has caught many of them over the past few years in the majors, minors, spring training, and watched our NL and NL East competition from behind the plate and on the bench for longer than Olivo's even been in the NL?

 

Who said anything about Olivo having better intangibles. I didn't. Some other poster said they felt he was a better defensive catcher and could better nurse the pitchers(an intangible?). Who knows. Willy has a handful of games behind the plate in the majors. Olivo has 10 handfuls. They're both way too small a sample size. I say let's see how they look after 2-3 years. For this year, I'd prefer some other catcher with a lot more MLB experience getting most of the starts and handling the young arms.

Problem with that is that Olivo likely won't be here in 2 years, and if Willingham does move it's going to be a permanent position. Learning catcher is hard enough once, let alone relearning it after 300+ MLB games across the diamond. This is Willingham's last chance at catching, unless something happens mid-way through the year. You don't give up the chance of having that type of bat at catcher simply to give his competitors more time and your pitchers a little less rough time.

 

BTW, the defense will improve this year, there's simply no place but up (okay, well there's 28th, 29th and 30th), and the pitchers will benefit in some way. Although they're still going to have their rough times.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.