August 16, 200620 yr What about cases of self-defense, alchohol impairment, of because of social circumstance (think of any instance where someone has to literally kill to survive)? That's not first degree murder, and therefore not eligible for the death penalty.
August 16, 200620 yr What about cases of self-defense, alchohol impairment, of because of social circumstance (think of any instance where someone has to literally kill to survive)? That's not first degree murder, and therefore not eligible for the death penalty. That's hypocrisy. Killing is killing. If I shoot someone with a gun, I'm going to use "accident" as an offense and claim the problem of induction. Same thing. You get drunk and kill someone in a car, you're a murderer. I'm not saying I agree with giving them the death penalty, but it's still true.
August 16, 200620 yr That's why we put people away on evidence, not on whether or not the killer said it was an accident. According to our legal system, you are not a murderer if you kill someone by hitting them with a car unless there was clear intent. That's why it's called manslaughter and not murder. And furthermore, by your own words: All killers are not equal. Killers are separate from one another. Natural implication is that the value of their acts against society differ, based on circumstance.
August 16, 200620 yr That's why we put people away on evidence, not on whether or not the killer said it was an accident. According to our legal system, you are not a murderer if you kill someone by hitting them with a car unless there was clear intent. That's why it's called manslaughter and not murder. And furthermore, by your own words: All killers are not equal. Killers are separate from one another. Natural implication is that the value of their acts against society differ, based on circumstance. :wub:
August 16, 200620 yr What about cases of self-defense, alchohol impairment, of because of social circumstance (think of any instance where someone has to literally kill to survive)? That's not first degree murder, and therefore not eligible for the death penalty. That's hypocrisy. Killing is killing. If I shoot someone with a gun, I'm going to use "accident" as an offense and claim the problem of induction. Same thing. You get drunk and kill someone in a car, you're a murderer. I'm not saying I agree with giving them the death penalty, but it's still true. You are aware that there are different degrees of murder arent you? Because from what I can gather from this post, you have no freakin clue.
August 16, 200620 yr What about cases of self-defense, alchohol impairment, of because of social circumstance (think of any instance where someone has to literally kill to survive)? That's not first degree murder, and therefore not eligible for the death penalty. That's hypocrisy. Killing is killing. If I shoot someone with a gun, I'm going to use "accident" as an offense and claim the problem of induction. Same thing. You get drunk and kill someone in a car, you're a murderer. I'm not saying I agree with giving them the death penalty, but it's still true. You are aware that there are different degrees of murder arent you? Because from what I can gather from this post, you have no freakin clue. Legally, but not morally. Well, not morally in my opinion. I sometimes mistake our laws for being moral, but that's a bad assumption. Thanks for being on the ball and reading Juanky's post first, JEAN-E-YUS.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.