Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Randolph for MOTY?

Featured Replies

  • Author

Apparently you only read the bolded portions. If you actually read the article:

 

Randolph is in a weaker league this season, you bet. But his team has also lost two corner outfielders. His team has lost Pedro Martinez for huge chunks of time and Duaner Sanchez, the team's top setup man, and had the rotation change dramatically when Victor Zambrano was lost for the season and maybe for good. Then Brian Bannister was lost. He puts John Maine out there and now Dave Williams and shuffles his bullpen and keeps going, on what could turn out to be one of the best regular seasons in the history of the team.

 

Furthermore, these are not nothing players the Marlins are winning with -- they are top notch prospects for the most part that many expected to do well. IMO, Girardi wins it if the marlins win the wild card, but let's not undermind what Randolph is doing. The Mets have have plenty of talented teams in the past, but they played like sh*t thanks to poor management and a bad clubhouse ('92 and '01-last season). The fact he was able to get these stars to bond so well and play like a team shouldn't be overlooked.

 

He already killed his arguement then second he started off with that. Also look at the corner outfield spots and tell me with a streight face that their offence was in danger because of these 2 areas. Flloyd is getting old and he was bound to choke on a season at one point and while Nady could hit for good power, he could not hit for average and he came off as a utility player so he never really had a definate position which makes him average their defensively.

 

Because the offence was so good, players like Steve Trachsel could win games easily and the depth of your pen saved any of the "Test-A-Pitcher"s like Lima or Soler. Also, how does a rotation "dramatically change" when Victor Zambrano is taken out of it? :lol

Also you can contribute some of the club chemistry to Loduca to being a guy that does what's best for the team and Carlos for already knowing some of the Mets. It also helps when a majority of your club are latin and can talk to each other in spanish.

He already killed his arguement then second he started off with that.

 

Doesn't that ring true for Girardi (or an other NL manager for that matter) as well? At least Randolph is leading his team to an over .500 record in a mediocre league

 

 

Also look at the corner outfield spots and tell me with a streight face that their offence was in danger because of these 2 areas.

 

Losing your two starting corner outfielders hurts no matter how good your offense is.

 

 

Flloyd is getting old and he was bound to choke on a season at one point

Choke on a season? Spreken ze English?

 

and while Nady could hit for good power, he could not hit for average and he came off as a utility player so he never really had a definate position which makes him average their defensively.

 

Nady played strong defense and was better offensively than Chavez or Milledge. I'd much rather have him out there than either of the two.

 

 

Because the offence was so good, players like Steve Trachsel could win games easily and the depth of your pen saved any of the "Test-A-Pitcher"s like Lima or Soler.

 

If the team wasn't tied for the 2nd lowest ERA in the national league and 3rd lowet in baseball, your arguement might have merit

 

 

Also, how does a rotation "dramatically change" when Victor Zambrano is taken out of it?

 

Becasue we had no one to replace him at the time. Eh, I really don't see the point of this argument either.

 

 

Also you can contribute some of the club chemistry to Loduca to being a guy that does what's best for the team and Carlos for already knowing some of the Mets. It also helps when a majority of your club are latin and can talk to each other in spanish.

 

 

And half your club doesn't. Very easily could be a split there. The fact is Willie kept these guys very grounded and helped them keep focused during a few mini-slides. It's very easy to allow a clubhouse to turn into a country club, see the Franco and Leiter Mets. Willie has done a superb job stopping that from happening.

BS,

 

By your standards, Delgado should win the manager of the year. His presence has elevated Beltran and Wright and by extension Reyes.

 

Willie doesn't provide the lineup protection, and that's the biggest difference from this year to last. Well, that and the fact that the Mets were the only NL East team to not suck horrifically for the the first two months.

That's pretty much the exact opposite of what I said. If anything, I said that Delgao's bat is less repsonsible for their success than most believed. How does Delgado's bat account for the way Willie handled the rotation after they lost their two best pitchers? Or the way he reshuffled the pen when Sanchez got hurt? Or the way turned Valentin into a starting 2nd baseman again? Yeah, pretty much the exact opposite.

  • Author
Doesn't that ring true for Girardi (or an other NL manager for that matter) as well? At least Randolph is leading his team to an over .500 record in a mediocre league

 

*Looks at Met's Payroll, Looks at Marlins Payroll*

*Looks at Mets Veterans, Looks at Marlins Veterans*

 

Nope. Despite how weak the NL is, the fact that we were expected to lose over 120 games has already been proven wrong and the Mets were expected to be as successful as they have been because of the spending spree and major trades they made this offseason.

 

 

Losing your two starting corner outfielders hurts no matter how good your offense is.

 

Not if it's not affecting how good the team still plays.

 

 

Choke on a season? Spreken ze English?

I meant in a season which didn't exactly come out how I wanted. He is getting old, not exactly one of those players that can play till their 40. Did his numbers not dramatically decrease?

 

Nady played strong defense and was better offensively than Chavez or Milledge. I'd much rather have him out there than either of the two.

He was pretty clutch but it was the choice of the FO to trade him due to an injury to Duaner, the team was light years ahead of the division already so like I said before, those moves didn't hurt the Mets, otherwise they wouldn't still be gaining ground and going on those winning streaks.

 

 

If the team wasn't tied for the 2nd lowest ERA in the national league and 3rd lowet in baseball, your arguement might have merit

 

The success of the pen masks a lot of the damage starting pitchers have done.

 

Becasue we had no one to replace him at the time. Eh, I really don't see the point of this argument either.

You can't replace a man that constantly puts himself in trouble on the mound with his walks? You guies seem to have done it already.

 

 

 

And half your club doesn't. Very easily could be a split there. The fact is Willie kept these guys very grounded and helped them keep focused during a few mini-slides. It's very easy to allow a clubhouse to turn into a country club, see the Franco and Leiter Mets. Willie has done a superb job stopping that from happening.

 

Can you sneak into the club house and tape him actually stopping something like this from occuring, please prove this one to me because it's pretty much a completly diffrent Met team from back then.

 

I am not attacking Willie, I think he has done a pretty good job with the team but nothing special that has wowed baseball. He basically did his job, he was expected to take this team to the playoffs with all the talent minaya got, did he? Yes! To add things like complaining about injured players is ridiculous because EVERY team has injured players. If anything I am makign a joke of the writer because a lot of the things he mentioned could support a lot of other Managers the same way, he didn't support his reasons well and because of it, the article looks like a joke.

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.