April 24, 200719 yr Here is something that Ron Paul had to say that I found very interesting and accurate. The senseless and horrific killings last week on the campus of Virginia Tech University reinforced an uneasy feeling many Americans experienced after September 11th: namely, that government cannot protect us. No matter how many laws we pass, no matter how many police or federal agents we put on the streets, a determined individual or group still can cause great harm. Perhaps the only good that can come from these terrible killings is a reinforced understanding that we as individuals are responsible for our safety and the safety of our families. Although Virginia does allow individuals to carry concealed weapons if they first obtain a permit, college campuses within the state are specifically exempted. Virginia Tech, like all Virginia colleges, is therefore a gun-free zone, at least for private individuals. And as we witnessed, it didn't matter how many guns the police had. Only private individuals on the scene could have prevented or lessened this tragedy. Prohibiting guns on campus made the Virginia Tech students less safe, not more. The Virginia Tech tragedy may not lead directly to more gun control, but I fear it will lead to more people control. Thanks to our media and many government officials, Americans have become conditioned to view the state as our protector and the solution to every problem. Whenever something terrible happens, especially when it becomes a national news story, people reflexively demand that government do something. This impulse almost always leads to bad laws and the loss of liberty. It is completely at odds with the best American traditions of self-reliance and rugged individualism. Do we really want to live in a world of police checkpoints, surveillance cameras, and metal detectors? Do we really believe government can provide total security? Do we want to involuntarily commit every disaffected, disturbed, or alienated person who fantasizes about violence? Or can we accept that liberty is more important than the illusion of state-provided security? I fear that Congress will use this terrible event to push for more government mandated mental health programs. The therapeutic nanny state only encourages individuals to view themselves as victims, and reject personal responsibility for their actions. Certainly there are legitimate organic mental illnesses, but it is the role of doctors and families, not the government, to diagnose and treat such illnesses. Freedom is not defined by safety. Freedom is defined by the ability of citizens to live without government interference. Government cannot create a world without risks, nor would we really wish to live in such a fictional place. Only a totalitarian society would even claim absolute safety as a worthy ideal, because it would require total state control over its citizens' lives. Liberty has meaning only if we still believe in it when terrible things happen and a false government security blanket beckons.
April 24, 200719 yr There's no causality with your DC example. If anything, tougher gun restrictions means crime and murder are already out of control and, hence, the city enacted tougher restrictions. In other words, you could argue that the restrictions came out too late to keep the murder rate about the same. In addition, how do you know the murder rate wouldn't have gone up quicker if they had not enacted tougher restrictions? You don't. Gun control laws don't do anything. How many violent criminals will not feel guilty about murdering someone, but will feel guilty for obtaining a gun illegally? Most likely, zero. Citizens need a means to defend themselves from those criminals. Knowing that citizens can carry guns acts as a deterrent. It works in Texas and murder rates tend to be pretty low in places with fewer restrictions on where people can legally carry guns. I'm not saying gun control in general because then that would include places where it is easy for anyone to get a gun legally. Sorry if my thoughts seem choppy, I am distracted by the game right now. hehe. You're missing the point. The question is how many murders are the result of passion, heat of the moment type of situations? Furthermore, how many of those murders involved the use of a firearm? So an important question is this: how many violent crimes that would have been committed with a gun/shotgun/firearm that are now instead committed with fists and knives will result in injury rather than death? In other words, would using a fist, bat, or knife result in a lower death rate among those violent crimes? Put even more simply, how much does the weapon used impact the result (no injury, injury, serious injury, and death)?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.