Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins/White Sox Post game thoughts....

Featured Replies

First of all, Boone's error (although JJ got charged) was of far greater consequence. That was the literal wheels come crashing off moment.

 

Pile on Hermida all you foolishly want, but at the end of the day, he only made an out twice, actually forced the pitchers to work and was literally ROBBED of a sure RBI double by Dye. THAT was the turning point...if Hermida's hit drops, Miguel scores easily. If Dye misses the dive, Hermida's probably got himself an inside the parker and no doubt a triple.

 

But, you can pick and choose all you want. Ignore that JJ was seemingly in a 3 ball count to every batter, that we have no one on the roster capable of playing 1st base decently, that Olivo, despite picking off two runners, still struggles keeping balls controlled and will swing at the rosin bag.

 

 

 

Ok Swifty, you and I have to put the gloves on for this one.......

 

 

How is it that in your eyes Aaron Boone is somehow tied into every Marlins error?

 

Please stop indirectly comparing him to DLee. He is not, and never will be DLee. But that doesnt mean that just because he doesnt make a play that DLee would have made, he should be charged with an error.

 

I have heard enough of this "Boone made the error but *insert player* was charged with the error.

 

Im suprised you havent tied Boone to Hermida's gaffe in RF last night. Surely Aaron was to blame on that one (maybe Hermida got distracted because Boone sneezed while the ball was slapping the top of his mitt).

 

Clearly we did not lose the game last nite because of Hermida and he will have a long, fruitful career but lets call a spade a spade.

 

HIS DEFENSE SUCKS RIGHT NOW.

First of all, Boone's error (although JJ got charged) was of far greater consequence. That was the literal wheels come crashing off moment.

 

Pile on Hermida all you foolishly want, but at the end of the day, he only made an out twice, actually forced the pitchers to work and was literally ROBBED of a sure RBI double by Dye. THAT was the turning point...if Hermida's hit drops, Miguel scores easily. If Dye misses the dive, Hermida's probably got himself an inside the parker and no doubt a triple.

 

But, you can pick and choose all you want. Ignore that JJ was seemingly in a 3 ball count to every batter, that we have no one on the roster capable of playing 1st base decently, that Olivo, despite picking off two runners, still struggles keeping balls controlled and will swing at the rosin bag.

 

 

 

Ok Swifty, you and I have to put the gloves on for this one.......

 

 

How is it that in your eyes Aaron Boone is somehow tied into every Marlins error?

 

Please stop indirectly comparing him to DLee. He is not, and never will be DLee. But that doesnt mean that just because he doesnt make a play that DLee would have made, he should be charged with an error.

 

I have heard enough of this "Boone made the error but *insert player* was charged with the error.

 

Im suprised you havent tied Boone to Hermida's gaffe in RF last night. Surely Aaron was to blame on that one (maybe Hermida got distracted because Boone sneezed while the ball was slapping the top of his mitt).

 

Clearly we did not lose the game last nite because of Hermida and he will have a long, fruitful career but lets call a spade a spade.

 

HIS DEFENSE SUCKS RIGHT NOW.

 

Did you watch the game? Or the game last week at home (I think Friday)?

 

AARON BOONE CANNOT PICK A GODDAMN THING. If it's in the dirt, the runner's safe. PERIOD

 

JJ made a low throw to first, but certainly a catchabe, if not containable throw. Instead, it ends up down the baseline and flood-gates are open.

 

As for my comments, I guess you fail to understand how official scoring works. Any throw down low, by the rules, is charged to the thrower, not the recipient. Essentially, fielders are unfairly held accountable for a bad 1st baseman. A 1st baseman is almost unable to have an error charged to him unless he is fielding or throwing the ball, other than that, the burden is on the fielders and that's not fair.

 

I love Boone, I have nothing to complain about Boone at the plate, for what it's worth I still believe he's a better defensive player than Jacobs, but to even suggest that either player is average defensively is foolish. What's more, to even insinuate that I pile on Boone the way others pile on Hermida here is retarded. My criticisms are of antiquated scoring decisions that unfairly reward/punish players on technicalities.

First of all, Boone's error (although JJ got charged) was of far greater consequence. That was the literal wheels come crashing off moment.

 

Pile on Hermida all you foolishly want, but at the end of the day, he only made an out twice, actually forced the pitchers to work and was literally ROBBED of a sure RBI double by Dye. THAT was the turning point...if Hermida's hit drops, Miguel scores easily. If Dye misses the dive, Hermida's probably got himself an inside the parker and no doubt a triple.

 

But, you can pick and choose all you want. Ignore that JJ was seemingly in a 3 ball count to every batter, that we have no one on the roster capable of playing 1st base decently, that Olivo, despite picking off two runners, still struggles keeping balls controlled and will swing at the rosin bag.

 

 

 

Ok Swifty, you and I have to put the gloves on for this one.......

 

 

How is it that in your eyes Aaron Boone is somehow tied into every Marlins error?

 

Please stop indirectly comparing him to DLee. He is not, and never will be DLee. But that doesnt mean that just because he doesnt make a play that DLee would have made, he should be charged with an error.

 

I have heard enough of this "Boone made the error but *insert player* was charged with the error.

 

Im suprised you havent tied Boone to Hermida's gaffe in RF last night. Surely Aaron was to blame on that one (maybe Hermida got distracted because Boone sneezed while the ball was slapping the top of his mitt).

 

Clearly we did not lose the game last nite because of Hermida and he will have a long, fruitful career but lets call a spade a spade.

 

HIS DEFENSE SUCKS RIGHT NOW.

 

Did you watch the game? Or the game last week at home (I think Friday)?

 

AARON BOONE CANNOT PICK A GODDAMN THING. If it's in the dirt, the runner's safe. PERIOD

 

JJ made a low throw to first, but certainly a catchabe, if not containable throw. Instead, it ends up down the baseline and flood-gates are open.

 

As for my comments, I guess you fail to understand how official scoring works. Any throw down low, by the rules, is charged to the thrower, not the recipient. Essentially, fielders are unfairly held accountable for a bad 1st baseman. A 1st baseman is almost unable to have an error charged to him unless he is fielding or throwing the ball, other than that, the burden is on the fielders and that's not fair.

 

I love Boone, I have nothing to complain about Boone at the plate, for what it's worth I still believe he's a better defensive player than Jacobs, but to even suggest that either player is average defensively is foolish. What's more, to even insinuate that I pile on Boone the way others pile on Hermida here is retarded. My criticisms are of antiquated scoring decisions that unfairly reward/punish players on technicalities.

Have to disagree with you Swifty. That was just a flat-out bad throw by JJ. Low and moving away with sink. It landed about 8 feet from first. Can't blame that one on Boone. I don't think even DLee gets that throw, and if he does, he's off the base with no time to get back. I'm no fan of Boone's defense. He's not good, or even average, but he was not at fault on that play. I do agree with your thought that a decent first baseman would improve the rest of the team's defense. That's one step we need to take sometime to improve the defense.

First of all, Boone's error (although JJ got charged) was of far greater consequence. That was the literal wheels come crashing off moment.

 

Pile on Hermida all you foolishly want, but at the end of the day, he only made an out twice, actually forced the pitchers to work and was literally ROBBED of a sure RBI double by Dye. THAT was the turning point...if Hermida's hit drops, Miguel scores easily. If Dye misses the dive, Hermida's probably got himself an inside the parker and no doubt a triple.

 

But, you can pick and choose all you want. Ignore that JJ was seemingly in a 3 ball count to every batter, that we have no one on the roster capable of playing 1st base decently, that Olivo, despite picking off two runners, still struggles keeping balls controlled and will swing at the rosin bag.

 

 

 

Ok Swifty, you and I have to put the gloves on for this one.......

 

 

How is it that in your eyes Aaron Boone is somehow tied into every Marlins error?

 

Please stop indirectly comparing him to DLee. He is not, and never will be DLee. But that doesnt mean that just because he doesnt make a play that DLee would have made, he should be charged with an error.

 

I have heard enough of this "Boone made the error but *insert player* was charged with the error.

 

Im suprised you havent tied Boone to Hermida's gaffe in RF last night. Surely Aaron was to blame on that one (maybe Hermida got distracted because Boone sneezed while the ball was slapping the top of his mitt).

 

Clearly we did not lose the game last nite because of Hermida and he will have a long, fruitful career but lets call a spade a spade.

 

HIS DEFENSE SUCKS RIGHT NOW.

 

Did you watch the game? Or the game last week at home (I think Friday)?

 

AARON BOONE CANNOT PICK A GODDAMN THING. If it's in the dirt, the runner's safe. PERIOD

 

JJ made a low throw to first, but certainly a catchabe, if not containable throw. Instead, it ends up down the baseline and flood-gates are open.

 

As for my comments, I guess you fail to understand how official scoring works. Any throw down low, by the rules, is charged to the thrower, not the recipient. Essentially, fielders are unfairly held accountable for a bad 1st baseman. A 1st baseman is almost unable to have an error charged to him unless he is fielding or throwing the ball, other than that, the burden is on the fielders and that's not fair.

 

I love Boone, I have nothing to complain about Boone at the plate, for what it's worth I still believe he's a better defensive player than Jacobs, but to even suggest that either player is average defensively is foolish. What's more, to even insinuate that I pile on Boone the way others pile on Hermida here is retarded. My criticisms are of antiquated scoring decisions that unfairly reward/punish players on technicalities.

Have to disagree with you Swifty. That was just a flat-out bad throw by JJ. Low and moving away with sink. It landed about 8 feet from first. Can't blame that one on Boone. I don't think even DLee gets that throw, and if he does, he's off the base with no time to get back. I'm no fan of Boone's defense. He's not good, or even average, but he was not at fault on that play. I do agree with your thought that a decent first baseman would improve the rest of the team's defense. That's one step we need to take sometime to improve the defense.

 

It hit off of Boone's f***ing glove.

 

I'm not saying you have to get the out, but as a firstbaseman, you ABSOLUTELY HAVE TO KEEP THAT BALL IN FRONT OF YOU.

First of all, Boone's error (although JJ got charged) was of far greater consequence. That was the literal wheels come crashing off moment.

 

Pile on Hermida all you foolishly want, but at the end of the day, he only made an out twice, actually forced the pitchers to work and was literally ROBBED of a sure RBI double by Dye. THAT was the turning point...if Hermida's hit drops, Miguel scores easily. If Dye misses the dive, Hermida's probably got himself an inside the parker and no doubt a triple.

 

But, you can pick and choose all you want. Ignore that JJ was seemingly in a 3 ball count to every batter, that we have no one on the roster capable of playing 1st base decently, that Olivo, despite picking off two runners, still struggles keeping balls controlled and will swing at the rosin bag.

 

 

 

Ok Swifty, you and I have to put the gloves on for this one.......

 

 

How is it that in your eyes Aaron Boone is somehow tied into every Marlins error?

 

Please stop indirectly comparing him to DLee. He is not, and never will be DLee. But that doesnt mean that just because he doesnt make a play that DLee would have made, he should be charged with an error.

 

I have heard enough of this "Boone made the error but *insert player* was charged with the error.

 

Im suprised you havent tied Boone to Hermida's gaffe in RF last night. Surely Aaron was to blame on that one (maybe Hermida got distracted because Boone sneezed while the ball was slapping the top of his mitt).

 

Clearly we did not lose the game last nite because of Hermida and he will have a long, fruitful career but lets call a spade a spade.

 

HIS DEFENSE SUCKS RIGHT NOW.

 

Did you watch the game? Or the game last week at home (I think Friday)?

 

AARON BOONE CANNOT PICK A GODDAMN THING. If it's in the dirt, the runner's safe. PERIOD

 

JJ made a low throw to first, but certainly a catchabe, if not containable throw. Instead, it ends up down the baseline and flood-gates are open.

 

As for my comments, I guess you fail to understand how official scoring works. Any throw down low, by the rules, is charged to the thrower, not the recipient. Essentially, fielders are unfairly held accountable for a bad 1st baseman. A 1st baseman is almost unable to have an error charged to him unless he is fielding or throwing the ball, other than that, the burden is on the fielders and that's not fair.

 

I love Boone, I have nothing to complain about Boone at the plate, for what it's worth I still believe he's a better defensive player than Jacobs, but to even suggest that either player is average defensively is foolish. What's more, to even insinuate that I pile on Boone the way others pile on Hermida here is retarded. My criticisms are of antiquated scoring decisions that unfairly reward/punish players on technicalities.

Have to disagree with you Swifty. That was just a flat-out bad throw by JJ. Low and moving away with sink. It landed about 8 feet from first. Can't blame that one on Boone. I don't think even DLee gets that throw, and if he does, he's off the base with no time to get back. I'm no fan of Boone's defense. He's not good, or even average, but he was not at fault on that play. I do agree with your thought that a decent first baseman would improve the rest of the team's defense. That's one step we need to take sometime to improve the defense.

 

It hit off of Boone's f***ing glove.

 

I'm not saying you have to get the out, but as a firstbaseman, you ABSOLUTELY HAVE TO KEEP THAT BALL IN FRONT OF YOU.

That's true, but it was JJ's error. Boone should have kept the ball out of the outfield. Then there would have been runners on 1st and 2nd instead of 1st and 3rd when Thome hit his HR.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.