Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

So Let's Rant and Rave About the Good Things

Featured Replies

This thread hurts my head.

Probably neither. VORP or EQA are excellent because they take the entirety of a player's production and put them into one number. And they are park adjusted, so Hanley actually comes out even better with those because he plays in a pitcher's park.

Thanks dude. I've never been a huge stat guy that was helpful.

 

You can find them on Baseballprospectus.com (along with tons of other useful stats, as well as the standard AVG/OBP/SLG stats).

I use Baseball-Reference.com as my homepage. I was thinking about getting a subscription to Prospectus. Any good books I should check out besides http://www.sportech.info/amazon/0879463112...dbook_2007.html ?

 

I would recommend Baseball Prospectus' Baseball Between The Numbers if you want to get right into the numbers behind the stats. I reccomend it as it's a good read, and informative, but I'm not going to lie and say it's easy to understand. there's some high level math going on there.

 

I also highly recommend Bill James' Historical Baseball Abstract as the starting place for really getting into statistical analysis. He really dumbs it down and makes it understandable. A great writer, as well.

 

And Moneyball.

 

The Handbook is interesting, and I've picked it up a few times at the bookstore and flipped through it, but I've never felt compelled to buy it. Their projections are pretty spot on, though.

 

A subscription to BP is well worth the money, and if I had the money, I would most definitely get one. They had a free weeklong trial not too long ago, and I spent a lot of time there. Those are some knowledgable guys.

 

The Numbers Game by Alan Schwarz is a nice little book on the history of statistics and statistical analysis in baseball. I think Heckeroo or Hotcorner recommended it to me a couple years ago and I've read it a few times since then.

  • Author

I don't know what you expect us to say. Cabrera and Ramirez are all-stars. The bullpen is much better than it was last year. Uggla still shows good power. Kim was good compensation for Julio. Amezaga is a decent proxy CF.

 

It's all been done before.

 

I think threads like these are good especially in the midst of a bad season. It's nice to have a player like Hanley along with Cabrera put up great seasons even if the overall team result isn't where you want it. I know when the Sox hada rough season last year it was nice to have Ortiz go for the club HR record. It made those last few weeks of watching much more enjoyable then they would have been.

Bingo, that was my whole point. Thanks Fox. In this season of major downers I was just trying to praise one of our best players and add some optimism for the future. It's bad enough the attitude around these parts is horrible 75% of the time. I'm not trying to get all "Cant everyone just get along" on you guys but my Marlins mood has been pretty meh lately and Hanley always cheers me up.

 

Besides, what does Uggla, Kim, Julio and Amezaga have to do with anything?

This thread hurts my head.

 

Enemies of good grammar and well thought out opinions beware. :o

When Hanley learns to walk a little bit more he's going to be just otherworldly.

 

I'm glad he's not our centerfielder ;) .

This thread hurts my head.

Then don't read it dude. Jesus H.

fyi, the "H" stands for Hanley

My main problem with OPS is that it makes OBP and SLG% equal.

 

In Moneyball, Paul DePodesta made a study of the value of OBP v. SLG. In the end, he concluded one point of OBP is 3 times more valuable that a point of SLG%.

 

Exactly. OPS puts OBP and SLG at a one to one ratio. This is slightly flawed because one stat can be more valuable than another. Or, they can be computed using different base values. In the case of OPS, it's both. OBP is a true percentage. If you get on base 40% of the time, you have an OBP of .400. On the other hand, slugging percentage is a misnomer because it's a rate (total bases per AB) which is based out of 4. If you were the ultimate hitter and hit a homerun every time you got up to bat, you'd have a slugging percentage of 4.00. That's why the 1:1 comparison isn't as accurate as it can be (it still works to give you a good idea, but there's more accurate stats out there). For instance, a player can increase their slugging percentage by .050 much faster than that same hitter can increase their on-base percentage by .050. That shouldn't happen for two stats at a 1:1 ratio.

 

Bill James even says it's possible for OBP to be 4-5 times more valuable. I'll try to see if I can work on something later today to see what rate I come up with.

 

Also, for good stats, check out VORP and EqA (like bobbob recommended), which are freely available from Baseball Prospectus. I have a membership to the site and it's great. Mind you, I do some statistical analysis for an organization at my university, so it's really useful for me to have access to certain features like the export function and sortable statistics. However, if you only want a place to check out a stat or two when your interest is piqued, you'll be fine with just the information they have up for free.

Yeah, I like VORP a lot. It disregards defense, and while I don't think that it's right to say defense should be ignored, it's damn near impossible to quantify defense (at least when discussing good v very good).

 

My eyes tell me Alfredo Amezaga's an average centerfielder who makes everything look a lot harder than it needs to, Rich and Tommy (whose eyes earn their paychecks) think his defense has earned him a bronze statue.

 

And even the advanced defensive quantification take into account silly factors like sheer volume of balls hit to the defender, which has nothing to do with the player but the pitcher and batter.

Wow, I was just joking, Jon...take it easy. Like you, I'm not a big fan of the whole looking at stats and stuff like that, though I do respect it. I also think Hanley will be a special player but isn't it amazing that Miggy has been so consistent and good for the last three years that we seem to take it for granted?

 

Hanley looks like he will turn out to be a perennial all-star but Miggy looks like a guy who could be mentioned in the same breath as Hank Aaron, Willie Mays, and the like. I really hope he's a Marlin for life because he's someone you only get to watch once a lifetime.

Wow, I was just joking, Jon...take it easy. Like you, I'm not a big fan of the whole looking at stats and stuff like that, though I do respect it. I also think Hanley will be a special player but isn't it amazing that Miggy has been so consistent and good for the last three years that we seem to take it for granted?

 

Hanley looks like he will turn out to be a perennial all-star but Miggy looks like a guy who could be mentioned in the same breath as Hank Aaron, Willie Mays, and the like. I really hope he's a Marlin for life because he's someone you only get to watch once a lifetime.

 

Honestly, both of these guys are once in a lifetime.

 

To just use your logic on you, isn't amazing that Miggy's so good that we take .330 and 20+ homeruns for granted?

 

Either of these guys would be the franchise player for about 26 other teams.

Wow, I was just joking, Jon...take it easy. Like you, I'm not a big fan of the whole looking at stats and stuff like that, though I do respect it. I also think Hanley will be a special player but isn't it amazing that Miggy has been so consistent and good for the last three years that we seem to take it for granted?

 

Hanley looks like he will turn out to be a perennial all-star but Miggy looks like a guy who could be mentioned in the same breath as Hank Aaron, Willie Mays, and the like. I really hope he's a Marlin for life because he's someone you only get to watch once a lifetime.

 

Honestly, both of these guys are once in a lifetime.

 

To just use your logic on you, isn't amazing that Miggy's so good that we take .330 and 20+ homeruns for granted?

 

Either of these guys would be the franchise player for about 26 other teams.

 

True, I just wish Hanley would get more walks but as long as he's hitting the ball at a high rate and develops more power, it doesn't seem to be a priority right now.

Hanley is the greatest thing to happen to the human race since Jesus, true story.

 

 

But know what is even more awesome than Hanley?

 

Nothing.

I don't know what you expect us to say. Cabrera and Ramirez are all-stars. The bullpen is much better than it was last year. Uggla still shows good power. Kim was good compensation for Julio. Amezaga is a decent proxy CF.

 

It's all been done before.

 

 

Anyways, not as if my words mean much around these parts (as they shouldn't) but I'm really happy to see Hanley develop in to such a great player rather quickly for you guys. I remember when he started in the Sox organization a long time ago he got in to some disiciplinary problems which shouldn't be that surprising considering how young he was but he matured almost as quickly as he has developed at the major league level and became almost a cliche 'model' teammate. I hope you guys can retain him for a long time.

 

I think threads like these are good especially in the midst of a bad season. It's nice to have a player like Hanley along with Cabrera put up great seasons even if the overall team result isn't where you want it. I know when the Sox hada rough season last year it was nice to have Ortiz go for the club HR record. It made those last few weeks of watching much more enjoyable then they would have been.

 

 

 

 

One of your best posts ever Fox. Humor and intellect.

 

 

I seriously laughed.

  • Author

This thread hurts my head.

Then don't read it dude. Jesus H.

fyi, the "H" stands for Hanley

:lol

 

Not sure how I missed this one. At this point besides Cab's it's what gets me excited every night for Fish games.

BTW what happened to shadeznation.com ?

there's still a nation, under Hanley, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all

 

aka :mischief

:lol :lol

 

Since you guys completely dissected and trashed my favorite stat, OPS.

 

Use one of Baseball Prospectus' stat equations. They look pretty useful.

Did they call him Renteria that whole time? :lol

 

Here is a fun little anecdote (if anyone takes this as a diss you're a fool) about Hanley, I think he may have had one of the worst first ABs I've seen a player have (Jacoby Ellsbury's this year was almost equally lolish). In his first AB he took 3 pitches right down the pipe all for strikes and struck out. I don't know if it was nerves or what but there was no way he was swinging....literally no intention of it. In retrospect it is one of the msot awesome/odd things about him.

Did they call him Renteria that whole time? :lol

 

Here is a fun little anecdote (if anyone takes this as a diss you're a fool) about Hanley, I think he may have had one of the worst first ABs I've seen a player have (Jacoby Ellsbury's this year was almost equally lolish). In his first AB he took 3 pitches right down the pipe all for strikes and struck out. I don't know if it was nerves or what but there was no way he was swinging....literally no intention of it. In retrospect it is one of the msot awesome/odd things about him.

 

That reminds of that Youk story. He said something about how in a minor league game, he struck out on three different pitches in a row looking and he was so upset till his coach told him there was nothing to be upset about since he saw every pitch the pitcher had and he could use that in his next at-bat. And thus he became Kevin Youkilis, The Greek God of Walks.

 

 

Back on topic, does anyone besides me think De Aza could be a good ballplayer? I mean, I know he played like one week, but it was a good week.

  • Author

Did they call him Renteria that whole time? :lol

 

Here is a fun little anecdote (if anyone takes this as a diss you're a fool) about Hanley, I think he may have had one of the worst first ABs I've seen a player have (Jacoby Ellsbury's this year was almost equally lolish). In his first AB he took 3 pitches right down the pipe all for strikes and struck out. I don't know if it was nerves or what but there was no way he was swinging....literally no intention of it. In retrospect it is one of the msot awesome/odd things about him.

Yeah that's the only thing that sucks about that video.

With the way the team has been playing lately one thing that always puts a smile on my face is Hanley Ramirez. I'm not the oldest person on this board but I've been a fan of the game for a very long time. Never has there been a player that has gotten me so excited to watch a game than Hanley Ramirez. The kid just makes you smile when you watch him play. The kid dislocates his shoulder and still puts up better numbers than guys who are 100%. He is a freak, bottomline. Last 30 days...

 

 

 

So when is the National League Player of the Month announced?

 

I had to start a thread on this, we all speak daily on how good this kid is, I figured I would give him his own thread.

 

Just add your love for Hanley to this thread!

 

absolutely incredible. great job.

Preliminary findings on the best OBP / SLG ratio for OPS:

 

In the interest of time and convenience, I relied solely on team runs scored, OBP, and SLG for this season, which makes small sample size alarms go off everywhere. I'll try to get a more in-depth analysis done soon where I look at those team stats for each season since the strike 1994-2007. I think it's probably the best period to use in terms of defining a particular era and having a big enough sample size.

 

That said, I ran a multiple regression on where I use a computer to figure out the optimal values of A, B, and C for the equation: A*OBP + B*SLG + C = Runs Scored. The important thing is the values for A and B because B/A ought to give you the optimal ratio of OBP:SLG.

 

Surprisingly, I got a rate of 1.342 OBP : 1 SLG as the best fit for the existing data. Additionally, my R-Squared value (which tells you how high the correlation is) was 0.89 (Perfect correlation = 1.0). Since I was kind of surprised that the coefficient for OBP wasn't higher, I decided to test the new formula against other variations of the OPS formula with different coefficients for OBP. The results are in the included graph. As you can see, the difference isn't all that significant although 1.342 remains the optimal coefficient. I'm going to see if I get the same thing once I include a wider sample size probably tomorrow.

What was your value for C? Where does it come into play for the equation?

 

Wouldn't it need to be some sort of constant? (math isn't my forte)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.