Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins buzz from the Herald-

Featured Replies

If anything, if it was based upon career production and comparable salaries, he'd be making less than $9M. Good player, he may be, but his career does not suggest he's a $9 million pitcher especially when one looks at the salaries of players of similar service time.

 

But that's not how it really works.

 

Arbitration cases hear arguments relating to that season. One need only read the reports of former consultants such as Bill James to know that. The decision is determinated based upon the validity of arguments for the team and players' requested amounts, with consideration to how he is paid relative to comparable players with similar service time. Thus, a player such as Dontrelle that is already well compensated relative to his peers, will not earn a substantial raise from this season, especially one with such questionable performance.

General practice is for teams to offer raises, however small, to promising players without regard their posting of a terrible season. However, that in no way, would harm the team's case unless the request in out of line with the salaries of comparable players. Willis' peers garner salaries close to $6.45M and it's impossible to argue that Dontrelle's season should earn him a substantial raise.

There more in the article than what I quoted. It's a good one.

http://www.bizofbaseball.com/index.php?opt...0&Itemid=41

 

In a player's first time through the arbitration process, his career is weighted almost as heavily as his platform year, with his platform year defined as the most recent season. However, in each subsequent time through arbitration the platform season is considered almost exclusively. In addition, few things matter more than playing time. If a player is sent to the minors, traded, or lands on the disabled list, those situations are generally marks against the player. The other key to keep in mind is that the arbitration process is governed by what front offices call "comps", or comparable players. Each side, team and agent, is trying to find the most favorable comps that they can use to their advantage. Finally, the comps generally do not go back further than four to five years. Arbiters want to be able to use comparisons from the same time period, as there are different elements that comprise each era of the game. As such, you will not see Barry Bonds used as a comp for Miguel Cabrera or see Mike Piazza used as a comp for Joe Mauer. As valid as those comparisons may be in the real world, they matter little in the arbitration room. For a more detailed description of the ins and outs of the process, see Tom Gorman's piece over at BP (subscription required)

 

And according to Baseball-Reference, the "comps" playing right now for Dontrelle are Beckett, Prior, Webb and Peavy.

 

Sosnik needs only look at the first five professional pay-days for Beckett and Prior (two pitchers whom Dontrelle outperformed through their five year time) and see career earnings in excess of $13 million to Dontrelle's $7 and *blammo* here we are, pay raise.

 

Furthermore, Beckett and Prior both have gone to arbitration, another consideration relative to players, like Webb, who got bought out.

Actually neither went to arbitration. They signed before the decisions. And Beckett and Prior didn't earn over $13 million because of their MLB careers, which Dontrelle may or may not had a comparable career to, but because of what Beckett and Prior did as amateurs. Arbitration isn't socialism. Arbitration is a weakened form of their reserve clause that allows the transitioning MLB player to argue for their requested salary.

Prior opted out of the pro contract he signed as an amateur and challenged the Cubs to the point of arbitration before compromising on a contract. One can only assume that the Cubs considered his career accomplishments along with his future promise.

Beckett settled before arbitration each time and the Marlins (2005) and Red Sox (2006) made their decisions for what we can only assume were the same reasons the Cubs and most teams do: as a reward for their career accomplishments, previous season's performance and future promise. In 2005 and the first time he was able to argue the salary of his contract as a MLB player, Beckett received a $900K raise.

Forget the FA route. Go get Salty.

Better chance at a Laird/Teagarden combo

 

I also kinda doubt Texas will be willing to trade Salty. But I'm being a homer on this one. That's my choice, any other I will learn to live with.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.