Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins buzz from the Herald-

Featured Replies

What seems to be collective amnesia on the part of the local sports media is that Cabrera and Willis already collectively earn $14 million and even if Miggy goes to $11 million, (speculation was it was $10 million last week) I find it hard to believe Willis earns an almost 50% increase even in these inflated days after his performance this season.

 

 

I agree. Who would he use for comparables when asking for $10 million? I don't think there are any pitchers with his service time and with ERAs in the 5.00 range making $10 million. I think he'll end up between $6 million and $7 million.

What seems to be collective amnesia on the part of the local sports media is that Cabrera and Willis already collectively earn $14 million and even if Miggy goes to $11 million, (speculation was it was $10 million last week) I find it hard to believe Willis earns an almost 50% increase even in these inflated days after his performance this season.

 

 

I agree. Who would he use for comparables when asking for $10 million? I don't think there are any pitchers with his service time and with ERAs in the 5.00 range making $10 million. I think he'll end up between $6 million and $7 million.

His crew will use comparables for his career and that's scary

 

Similar Pitchers

 

1. Jake Peavy (962)

2. Carmen Hill (954)

3. Charlie Lea (947)

4. Josh Beckett (946)

5. Dickey Kerr (944)

6. Ferdie Schupp (942)

7. Mark Prior (941)

8. Brandon Webb (939)

9. Paul Dean (938)

10. Wally Bunker (938)

 

Similar Pitchers through Age 24

 

1. Steve Avery (982)

2. Bob Moose (966)

3. Ross Grimsley (966)

4. Wally Bunker (965)

5. Ramon Martinez (960)

6. Mark Buehrle (958)

7. Admin Christenson (958)

8. Dave McNally (957)

9. Britt Burns (957)

10. Lefty Gomez (956) *

Ramp.. but how much were these "comparables" making when they had his service time? That's the relevant issue.

 

Also, the first time you go to arbitration the career numbers take precedence over the previous season's numbers but in the subsequent arbitration years the previous season's numbers take precedence over the career numbers.

Ramp.. but how much were these "comparables" making when they had his service time? That's the relevant issue.

 

Also, the first time you go to arbitration the career numbers take precedence over the previous season's numbers but in the subsequent arbitration years the previous season's numbers take precedence over the career numbers.

well unfortunately, other teams were smart and bought out players like Brandon Webb and Jake Peavy

 

I still expect Willis to get a nice payraise of about $3mil

Your analysis ignores passed balls. The only catcher who allowed more passed balls per inning than Barret is Olivo and it was barely at that.. Olivo allowed one passed ball every 62 innings while Barret allowed one every 64 innings. I think I'll pass on the .281 OBP guy who can't catch the ball and who can't throw anyone out and who is a**hole to boot. I don't mind a**holes who can play but it's retarded to add an a**hole who can't play and more so when the a**hole is a catcher and the team has a young pitching staff.

This is fabulous. I laugh at bringing up passed balls in general, as we're resorting to that versus far superior statistics, but please address the argument, not the problems of these obvious imperfect options. SO what catcher do you want. If you want to use passed balls to qualify this, be my guest. I don't care what you use as long as it's a tangible thought.

 

Passed Ball Barret

Jason "Not as good as Barret, but still draws walks" Kendall

Ramon Castro

or one of the other FA catchers (that really get easily tossed from the whole debate based off higher salary/similar ceiling issues, or not as good as the other guys)

 

Don't get me wrong. I would love to pass on ALL of these dudes, trade for Jeff Clement, Salty, or Shoppach, or even Montero, but the article says FA catchers, these are the guys. Who ya got? Michael Barret, and his apparent past ballsness, is still the best option to me of this group versus hoping Kendall hits that .350 OBP or hoping Castro is not a 2007 sample size fluke (plus would even come here since we ran him out of town once). Answer the question based on the choices from the article and what's on FA. You gotta it in you. I know it.

Ramp.. but how much were these "comparables" making when they had his service time? That's the relevant issue.

 

Also, the first time you go to arbitration the career numbers take precedence over the previous season's numbers but in the subsequent arbitration years the previous season's numbers take precedence over the career numbers.

well unfortunately, other teams were smart and bought out players like Brandon Webb and Jake Peavy

 

I still expect Willis to get a nice payraise of about $3mil

Gotta disagree. I'm going 8ish, which represents a $1.5ish raise. The Marlins are going to have an awesome whiptastic argument based of his 2006-2007 seasons. Dontrelle's agent is cool though and gets it. I don't suspect the parties will go to arbitration, and they'll both come to a number where they are each happy.

 

Cabrera though. BLING BLANG!!!!!!!!!!

Your analysis ignores passed balls. The only catcher who allowed more passed balls per inning than Barret is Olivo and it was barely at that.. Olivo allowed one passed ball every 62 innings while Barret allowed one every 64 innings. I think I'll pass on the .281 OBP guy who can't catch the ball and who can't throw anyone out and who is a**hole to boot. I don't mind a**holes who can play but it's retarded to add an a**hole who can't play and more so when the a**hole is a catcher and the team has a young pitching staff.

This is fabulous. I laugh at bringing up passed balls in general, as we're resorting to that versus far superior statistics, but please address the argument, not the problems of these obvious imperfect options. SO what catcher do you want. If you want to use passed balls to qualify this, be my guest. I don't care what you use as long as it's a tangible thought.

 

Passed Ball Barret

Jason "Not as good as Barret, but still draws walks" Kendall

Ramon Castro

or one of the other FA catchers (that really get easily tossed from the whole debate based off higher salary/similar ceiling issues, or not as good as the other guys)

 

Don't get me wrong. I would love to pass on ALL of these dudes, trade for Jeff Clement, Salty, or Shoppach, or even Montero, but the article says FA catchers, these are the guys. Who ya got? Michael Barret, and his apparent past ballsness, is still the best option to me of this group versus hoping Kendall hits that .350 OBP or hoping Castro is not a 2007 sample size fluke (plus would even come here since we ran him out of town once). Answer the question based on the choices from the article and what's on FA. You gotta it in you. I know it.

The two major strikes agaists Olivo are his poor OBP and that he can't catch the ball. In '07 Barret was just barely above Olivo in both OBP and catching pitches (passed balls). Your original comment that Barret would be excellent is ridiculous unless you add about 983 qualifiers which is what you've done after I replied. Had you added the qualifiers from the get go I would have never replied.

The two major strikes agaists Olivo are his poor OBP and that he can't catch the ball. In '07 Barret was just barely above Olivo in both OBP and catching pitches (passed balls). Your original comment that Barret would be excellent is ridiculous unless you add about 983 qualifiers which is what you've done after I replied. Had you added the qualifiers from the get go I would have never replied.

So, who do you want on the marlins among Olivo, Barret, Kendall, Castro, Lo Duca, Torrelaba, and I'll add Javier Valentien who wasnt mentioned.

 

What. Catcher. Do. You. Want. The. Marlins. To. Sign. If. They. Go. The. Free. Agent. Route. As. Per. The. Article.

 

Production, Salary, everything is in play.

cabrera for Martin, Laroche and Kemp seems like a return that most folks wouldnt flip too much over. I personally would rather keep miggy though.

 

Or willis for Clement and a prospect perhaps wouldnt be too bad.

The two major strikes agaists Olivo are his poor OBP and that he can't catch the ball. In '07 Barret was just barely above Olivo in both OBP and catching pitches (passed balls). Your original comment that Barret would be excellent is ridiculous unless you add about 983 qualifiers which is what you've done after I replied. Had you added the qualifiers from the get go I would have never replied.

So, who do you want on the marlins among Olivo, Barret, Kendall, Castro, Lo Duca, Torrelaba, and I'll add Javier Valentien who wasnt mentioned.

 

What. Catcher. Do. You. Want. The. Marlins. To. Sign. If. They. Go. The. Free. Agent. Route. As. Per. The. Article.

 

Production, Salary, everything is in play.

I would prefer Lo Duca, Torrealba or Valentin over Barret and not so much because I like them but because I don't like Barret.

Why do we have to choose these guys mentioned in the article. I have a name that is free this offseason.

 

How about Jose Molina? He's defensive minded and with our offense, we really don't have to go out of our way for a good hitting catcher. Personally, I think Molina is a good choice. Also, I would watch the situation with Brian Schneider with the Nats to see if he were somehow available.

Why do we have to choose these guys mentioned in the article. I have a name that is free this offseason.

 

How about Jose Molina? He's defensive minded and with our offense, we really don't have to go out of our way for a good hitting catcher. Personally, I think Molina is a good choice. Also, I would watch the situation with Brian Schneider with the Nats to see if he were somehow available.

 

No. No no no no no no no no.

Forget the FA route. Go get Salty.

Better chance at a Laird/Teagarden combo

cabrera for Martin, Laroche and Kemp seems like a return that most folks wouldnt flip too much over. I personally would rather keep miggy though.

 

Or willis for Clement and a prospect perhaps wouldnt be too bad.

 

 

I don't think they give up Martin in a package, even for Cabs. But yes, I would jump on that. Martin is the best catcher in the National League, IMO. Substitute Martin for Kershaw and Billingsley, and maybe.

Ramp.. but how much were these "comparables" making when they had his service time? That's the relevant issue.

 

Also, the first time you go to arbitration the career numbers take precedence over the previous season's numbers but in the subsequent arbitration years the previous season's numbers take precedence over the career numbers.

well unfortunately, other teams were smart and bought out players like Brandon Webb and Jake Peavy

 

I still expect Willis to get a nice payraise of about $3mil

To actually answer your question, among the players comparable to Willis who went through arbitration are Josh Beckett and Mark Prior, and earned raises of $2M following less than impressive years. But those two had smaller bases than Willis due to the restraints of their first contracts and were able to argue the value they brought to the club during the years of those first contracts. If those two tell us anything, it's that Willis shouldn't expect a big raise if any raise at all.

Actually, RFerry, it's quite easy to argue for a pay-raise for Dontrelle. When you compare his career accomplishments to others through similar age and see his career earnings to be less than half of others like Beckett and Prior and you see Matt Sosnik has the case made for him. Pay scale in arbitration isn't a what have you done for me lately, it's here's what I've done and why I deserve it. Sosnik could argue for a $9 million or so pay-day based on his career production and service time and easily get it.

Actually, RFerry, it's quite easy to argue for a pay-raise for Dontrelle. When you compare his career accomplishments to others through similar age and see his career earnings to be less than half of others like Beckett and Prior and you see Matt Sosnik has the case made for him. Pay scale in arbitration isn't a what have you done for me lately, it's here's what I've done and why I deserve it. Sosnik could argue for a $9 million or so pay-day based on his career production and service time and easily get it.

One of the most ridiculous post I've read.

 

Arbitration is about comparable players in service time and not about comparable players in age and as this is 3rd arbitration year his latest season (5.17 ERA) takes precedence over his career numbers.

 

I wish we could bet on what he'll get... easy money.

Actually, RFerry, it's quite easy to argue for a pay-raise for Dontrelle. When you compare his career accomplishments to others through similar age and see his career earnings to be less than half of others like Beckett and Prior and you see Matt Sosnik has the case made for him. Pay scale in arbitration isn't a what have you done for me lately, it's here's what I've done and why I deserve it. Sosnik could argue for a $9 million or so pay-day based on his career production and service time and easily get it.

One of the most ridiculous post I've read.

 

Arbitration is about comparable players in service time and not about comparable players in age and as this is 3rd arbitration year his latest season (5.17 ERA) takes precedence over his career numbers.

 

I wish we could bet on what he'll get... easy money.

 

I'm willing to take ANY bet that says he gets a pay-raise. It's all about career production, service time, and compensation for that production. It's not only about your past season.

There more in the article than what I quoted. It's a good one.

http://www.bizofbaseball.com/index.php?opt...0&Itemid=41

 

In a player's first time through the arbitration process, his career is weighted almost as heavily as his platform year, with his platform year defined as the most recent season. However, in each subsequent time through arbitration the platform season is considered almost exclusively. In addition, few things matter more than playing time. If a player is sent to the minors, traded, or lands on the disabled list, those situations are generally marks against the player. The other key to keep in mind is that the arbitration process is governed by what front offices call "comps", or comparable players. Each side, team and agent, is trying to find the most favorable comps that they can use to their advantage. Finally, the comps generally do not go back further than four to five years. Arbiters want to be able to use comparisons from the same time period, as there are different elements that comprise each era of the game. As such, you will not see Barry Bonds used as a comp for Miguel Cabrera or see Mike Piazza used as a comp for Joe Mauer. As valid as those comparisons may be in the real world, they matter little in the arbitration room. For a more detailed description of the ins and outs of the process, see Tom Gorman's piece over at BP (subscription required)

There more in the article than what I quoted. It's a good one.

http://www.bizofbaseball.com/index.php?opt...0&Itemid=41

 

In a player's first time through the arbitration process, his career is weighted almost as heavily as his platform year, with his platform year defined as the most recent season. However, in each subsequent time through arbitration the platform season is considered almost exclusively. In addition, few things matter more than playing time. If a player is sent to the minors, traded, or lands on the disabled list, those situations are generally marks against the player. The other key to keep in mind is that the arbitration process is governed by what front offices call "comps", or comparable players. Each side, team and agent, is trying to find the most favorable comps that they can use to their advantage. Finally, the comps generally do not go back further than four to five years. Arbiters want to be able to use comparisons from the same time period, as there are different elements that comprise each era of the game. As such, you will not see Barry Bonds used as a comp for Miguel Cabrera or see Mike Piazza used as a comp for Joe Mauer. As valid as those comparisons may be in the real world, they matter little in the arbitration room. For a more detailed description of the ins and outs of the process, see Tom Gorman's piece over at BP (subscription required)

 

And according to Baseball-Reference, the "comps" playing right now for Dontrelle are Beckett, Prior, Webb and Peavy.

 

Sosnik needs only look at the first five professional pay-days for Beckett and Prior (two pitchers whom Dontrelle outperformed through their five year time) and see career earnings in excess of $13 million to Dontrelle's $7 and *blammo* here we are, pay raise.

 

Furthermore, Beckett and Prior both have gone to arbitration, another consideration relative to players, like Webb, who got bought out.

I would think the arbiter would determine who the "comps" are based on the guidelines set be the CBA and not based on what baseball-reference says.

I would think the arbiter would determine who the "comps" are based on the guidelines set be the CBA and not based on what baseball-reference says.

No kidding.

 

Just for the overly rudimentary study we're doing, you've yet to cite anything suggesting Dontrelle deserves a cut.

 

Still, if you ever feel like making a bet, you know I'm more than down.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.