Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins buzz from the Herald-

Featured Replies

Marlins offseason chatter:

 

? The Marlins, who are very open to making a major trade, have made pitching their clear-cut No. 1 priority but also will try to sign a veteran free agent catcher who works well with a young staff.

Unless payroll rises much beyond $30 million -- nothing's set but the Marlins have given no reason to expect that -- it will be difficult to keep both Dontrelle Willis and Miguel Cabrera, instead of one -- and upgrade elsewhere. They figure to combine for nearly $20 million in arbitration, with Cabrera projected for $11 million.

With the Marlins planning to keep payroll low until a proposed new stadium opens, both likely will be gone by free agency in November '09. Ballpark talks, incidentally, keep taking one step forward, one step back.

So if one of the two is dealt, who's more likely? Depends on the offers.

 

? There's sentiment internally toward pursuing a reunion with Mets free agent catcher Paul Lo Duca. But Marlins owner Jeffrey Loria would need to authorize that kind of expenditure. The Marlins -- who want to drop Miguel Olivo but keep Matt Treanor -- also are expected to explore free agents Yorvit Torrealba (Colorado) and Michael Barrett (San Diego), with the Cubs' Jason Kendall and Mets backup and ex-Marlin Ramon Castro among other options.

 

? If the Marlins don't trade for starting pitching, they'll seek an established starter whose price is driven down by injury or other factors. One example: Baltimore free agent Kris Benson, who missed '07 after shoulder surgery.

The Marlins will listen to offers for Scott Olsen but would keep him if nothing enticing surfaces. The hope is that two or so rotation spots will be filled by Ricky Nolasco, Anibal Sanchez (the Marlins don't want to rush him off shoulder surgery), Rick VandenHurk or Sergio Mitre. The Marlins think top prospect Chris Volstad (4-2 with a 3.16 ERA at Double A Carolina) is close, but Double A prospect Gaby Hernandez (9-11, 4.22 ERA) needs more seasoning.

 

? If Cabrera isn't traded, he'll stay at third base for now, barring something unexpected. (A Mike Jacobs trade could change that.) But one person in close contact with the Marlins says the thought internally is he must lose more weight to stay there long-term.

 

? Moving Hanley Ramirez to center field was discussed, but is unlikely.

 

? Unless the Marlins trade for a center fielder, or sign a cheap player to platoon with Cody Ross, they'll go to spring with Ross and Alejandro DeAza, who finished in an 11-for-71 slump, and unproven Brett Carroll.

 

? The Marlins, who must pay $4 million of Carlos Delgado's Mets salary in '08, want to re-sign 1B/3B Aaron Boone.

What seems to be collective amnesia on the part of the local sports media is that Cabrera and Willis already collectively earn $14 million and even if Miggy goes to $11 million, (speculation was it was $10 million last week) I find it hard to believe Willis earns an almost 50% increase even in these inflated days after his performance this season.

 

But even if I'm wrong and Miggy gets $11 and Willis $9, that only a $6 million increase for both. Hardly unmanageable.

 

BTW, here's a little newsblast regarding Barry Jackson. He's was a bit pissy last week having been shut of the QAM/790 story and made to wait for the details like everyone else, letting it be known he deserved better. So for what it's worth take Barry's comments with a grain of salt for a few weeks until the FO makes nice with him again.

We could get keith foulke to solidify our BP as well. He's planning on returning next year, after taking a year off due to having a bone spur removed in his elbow

We could get keith foulke to solidify our BP as well. He's planning on returning next year, after taking a year off due to having a bone spur removed in his elbow

Why? :blink:

 

Gregg, Lindstrom, Tank, Pinto, J. Miller, Kensing, and L. Gardner. DL Owens, AAA C. Martinez, Zarate, H. Garcia. Left over SP (Carvajal, Barone, Seddon, whoever doesn't win rotation spots). AA - Marceaux, Tucker. We don't need anything here.

 

---

 

Michael Barret would be excellent.

BTW if they really want to sign a veteran starter who's price is down Mark Prior is likely to be non-tendered by the Cubbies. I personally think they'll be ok in the pitching department if they stand pat.

Kris Benson is intriguing if he wants to come here for a year to prove he's got stuff left. He'd be more effective in the NL anyway I think. You sign him to a one year deal, and worst case he becomes a nice all-star break trading piece to pick up a couple prospects. I'm also in favor of resigning Kim just for the fact he will be abe to protect our young arms later on in the season.

It's a bit annoying that he makes that stadium comment in passing without a hint of an explanation.

I'm told Barrett can't call a game/sucks on defense.

Did you watch him in the playoffs. Whoever told you is right. Its more fun to watch and judge for yourself, makes your opinions yours not someone elses.

I would love to see Kris Benson on the Marlins. It is a great fit, think he could have a Carl Pavano type season with us. Lo Duca returning would be intriguing, obviously he isn't the best fit, but it is a significant upgrade.

Michael Barret would be excellent.

If you're talking about the Barret of the .281 OBP who can't throw anyone out and who defensively flat out blows then he would be horrible... is there another Michael Barret?

 

I guess he would be "better" than Jason Kendall but that's not saying much.

We could get keith foulke to solidify our BP as well. He's planning on returning next year, after taking a year off due to having a bone spur removed in his elbow

Why? :blink:

 

Gregg, Lindstrom, Tank, Pinto, J. Miller, Kensing, and L. Gardner. DL Owens, AAA C. Martinez, Zarate, H. Garcia. Left over SP (Carvajal, Barone, Seddon, whoever doesn't win rotation spots). AA - Marceaux, Tucker. We don't need anything here.

 

---

 

Michael Barret would be excellent.

He's going to come cheap, and he's a veteran.

Lo Duca makes way too much money. I wouldn't mind seeing Barrett or Kendall

Keith Foulke is going to be cheap because he can't get batter out anymore. The club did a pretty good job avoiding the veteran bullpen model (see 2004-2006 teams) and went with young fireballers and it worked out well. I do not expect things to change.

I'm told Barrett can't call a game/sucks on defense.

Did you watch him in the playoffs. Whoever told you is right. Its more fun to watch and judge for yourself, makes your opinions yours not someone elses.

 

OK...thanks for the lesson. I'm gonna go hunt down some game tapes so I can form my own opinion.

Bring back Mike Piazza...

 

Maybe an incentive-laden deal for catching so many games.

Treanor can catch every couple days if Piazza's health doesn't hold up.

 

As for a starting pitcher, I think we re-sign BK and go after Matt Clement.

I'm told Barrett can't call a game/sucks on defense.

Did you watch him in the playoffs. Whoever told you is right. Its more fun to watch and judge for yourself, makes your opinions yours not someone elses.

 

OK...thanks for the lesson. I'm gonna go hunt down some game tapes so I can form my own opinion.

You're welcome. Did someone tell you to get the tapes, or did you think of that all by yourself, which is a start. Keep at it, I support you 100%.

Michael Barret would be excellent.

If you're talking about the Barret of the .281 OBP who can't throw anyone out and who defensively flat out blows then he would be horrible... is there another Michael Barret?

 

I guess he would be "better" than Jason Kendall but that's not saying much.

Hey what have you done for me lately dude. Maybe you missed how Barret has been really banged up for about a full calender year now, and had a .850ish cumulative OPS 2004-2006. Check the home/away, it wasn't wrigley either. Oh, and here's some fun facts for you to chew on. This is a cumulative list of the FA options per the article. Argue me which player to take based on PERFORMANCE versus SALARY.

 

2007 CS% numbers for all catchers mentioned

Olivo .329

Barret .163

Kendall .153

Lo Duca .234

Yorvit .197

Castro .100

 

So Olivo is OK, and everyone else sucks. No one here is outrageously better or worse than anyone else defensively where there is going to be a lasting impact onto a team's run production. Let's not make an intangible argument of "calling games" here either, although I'm sure you will puntolize this argument to the best of your ability.

 

2007 OPS / Career OPS

Olivo .667 / .680

Barret .653 / .747

Kendall .610 / .758

Lo Duca .689 / .752

Yorvit .699 / .705

Castro .887 / .723

 

Olivo and Yorvit offer you nothing. Kendall and Lo Duca are older now, so their career isn't as applicable. They are the middle hitters here, with LoDuca relying completely on contact rates and Kendall on his ability to draw walks. Either would probably be effective in a High .600/Low .700 kind of way, but absolutely offers you no CEILING potential. Which leaves us, Castro who overachieved in spare time in 2007, or Barret who underachieved greatly in 2007. Both of these are in the prime years of their career and have shown they can hit baseballs.

 

So a quick recap. Olivo can throw out runners, no one is a defensive wizard, and Barret and Castro are the only ones that offer any sort of realistic hitting potential of the group.

 

Expected 2008 commitment

Lo Duca $10-12 million, 2 years

Everyone else, way less money, probably a one year + option commitment, and would love the opportunity to be a # 1 catcher

 

So where does this leave us. First, LoDuca is out. He displays no advantages over anyone (please no intangiscale. please god!), and is literally twice as expensive. Yorvit and Olivo are out, because who cares. They are just w/e. So we have Kendall, Barret, and Castro. Since you've already detailed Kendall < Barret, Do you want Michael Barret, or Ramon Castro. There is nothing else. My answer is, I'll take the guy who has started before, has been injured, and has shown he can play, not the guy who has already been run out of this organization once, will probably have a larger market in FA because of a "breakthrough" year, and has never started in his life.

 

So coming full circle and qualifying this further so you get it, among the options presented, Michael Barret would be excellent. He is the best combination of performance and salary of this group.

Don't forget my man, Mike P.

 

2006 CS % = .118

 

2007 OPS = .727

Career OPS = .922

 

2007 Salary = $8.5 mil

Don't forget my man, Mike P.

 

2006 CS % = .118

 

2007 OPS = .727

Career OPS = .922

 

2007 Salary = $8.5 mil

Does he have knees anymore?

I think Kendall would be an exellent hitter, a catalyst with the marlins + he provides leadership, something that Barrett would fail to provide

I think Kendall would be an exellent hitter, a catalyst with the marlins + he provides leadership, something that Barrett would fail to provide

He also would donate his free time to local animal shelters and organize beach clean ups in the tri-county area. He's such a philanthropist.

Kris Benson is intriguing if he wants to come here for a year to prove he's got stuff left. He'd be more effective in the NL anyway I think. You sign him to a one year deal, and worst case he becomes a nice all-star break trading piece to pick up a couple prospects. I'm also in favor of resigning Kim just for the fact he will be abe to protect our young arms later on in the season.

 

I'd only take Kris if Anna comes along too....this clubhouse needs it.

Michael Barret would be excellent.

If you're talking about the Barret of the .281 OBP who can't throw anyone out and who defensively flat out blows then he would be horrible... is there another Michael Barret?

 

I guess he would be "better" than Jason Kendall but that's not saying much.

Hey what have you done for me lately dude. Maybe you missed how Barret has been really banged up for about a full calender year now, and had a .850ish cumulative OPS 2004-2006. Check the home/away, it wasn't wrigley either. Oh, and here's some fun facts for you to chew on. This is a cumulative list of the FA options per the article. Argue me which player to take based on PERFORMANCE versus SALARY.

 

2007 CS% numbers for all catchers mentioned

Olivo .329

Barret .163

Kendall .153

Lo Duca .234

Yorvit .197

Castro .100

 

So Olivo is OK, and everyone else sucks. No one here is outrageously better or worse than anyone else defensively where there is going to be a lasting impact onto a team's run production. Let's not make an intangible argument of "calling games" here either, although I'm sure you will puntolize this argument to the best of your ability.

 

2007 OPS / Career OPS

Olivo .667 / .680

Barret .653 / .747

Kendall .610 / .758

Lo Duca .689 / .752

Yorvit .699 / .705

Castro .887 / .723

 

Olivo and Yorvit offer you nothing. Kendall and Lo Duca are older now, so their career isn't as applicable. They are the middle hitters here, with LoDuca relying completely on contact rates and Kendall on his ability to draw walks. Either would probably be effective in a High .600/Low .700 kind of way, but absolutely offers you no CEILING potential. Which leaves us, Castro who overachieved in spare time in 2007, or Barret who underachieved greatly in 2007. Both of these are in the prime years of their career and have shown they can hit baseballs.

 

So a quick recap. Olivo can throw out runners, no one is a defensive wizard, and Barret and Castro are the only ones that offer any sort of realistic hitting potential of the group.

 

Expected 2008 commitment

Lo Duca $10-12 million, 2 years

Everyone else, way less money, probably a one year + option commitment, and would love the opportunity to be a # 1 catcher

 

So where does this leave us. First, LoDuca is out. He displays no advantages over anyone (please no intangiscale. please god!), and is literally twice as expensive. Yorvit and Olivo are out, because who cares. They are just w/e. So we have Kendall, Barret, and Castro. Since you've already detailed Kendall < Barret, Do you want Michael Barret, or Ramon Castro. There is nothing else. My answer is, I'll take the guy who has started before, has been injured, and has shown he can play, not the guy who has already been run out of this organization once, will probably have a larger market in FA because of a "breakthrough" year, and has never started in his life.

 

So coming full circle and qualifying this further so you get it, among the options presented, Michael Barret would be excellent. He is the best combination of performance and salary of this group.

Your analysis ignores passed balls. The only catcher who allowed more passed balls per inning than Barret is Olivo and it was barely at that.. Olivo allowed one passed ball every 62 innings while Barret allowed one every 64 innings. I think I'll pass on the .281 OBP guy who can't catch the ball and who can't throw anyone out and who is a**hole to boot. I don't mind a**holes who can play but it's retarded to add an a**hole who can't play and more so when the a**hole is a catcher and the team has a young pitching staff.

I think Kendall would be an exellent hitter, a catalyst with the marlins + he provides leadership, something that Barrett would fail to provide

Kendall hasn't really hit well the past 3 or so years and he allowed about 120 SB this year.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.