December 30, 200718 yr :banghead Jeez, we support Musharraf's overthrow of a democratically elected government, Except we didn't and that isn't what he overthrew anyhow. send him 10 billion dollars, After he signed on to help in Afghanistan then we get mad that he intends on staying a dictator so we pressure him to let Bhutto (who herself is no angel) out of exhile and allow elections, We weren't mad, and the only reason we pushed for the power-sharing deal was to increase the Pakistani government's popularity she gets killed (likely by Pakistani ISI) and now there's talk that there will be "spillover" into Afghanistan, jeopardizing our fight against terrorism. The person may have been an ISI agent turned to work for AQ, but security operatives do no carry out martyrdom attacks.
December 30, 200718 yr :banghead Jeez, we support Musharraf's overthrow of a democratically elected government, Except we didn't and that isn't what he overthrew anyhow. send him 10 billion dollars, After he signed on to help in Afghanistan then we get mad that he intends on staying a dictator so we pressure him to let Bhutto (who herself is no angel) out of exhile and allow elections, We weren't mad, and the only reason we pushed for the power-sharing deal was to increase the Pakistani government's popularity she gets killed (likely by Pakistani ISI) and now there's talk that there will be "spillover" into Afghanistan, jeopardizing our fight against terrorism. The person may have been an ISI agent turned to work for AQ, but security operatives do no carry out martyrdom attacks. Eric, I fdid some research and I concede that I was wrong about a few things, though you glossed over a few details yourself. Here's what I found out. Jeez, we support Musharraf's overthrow of a democratically elected government, Except we didn't and that isn't what he overthrew anyhow. Indeed, the U.S. placed sanctions on Pakistan that (before 911) were only supposed to be removed when Pakistan returned to democracy (Source: CNN, 6/21/2001 http://archives.cnn.com/2001/WORLD/asiapcf...stan.pres.reax/). However, some circles credit U.S. pressure on Sharif to withdraw his forces from Jammu and Kashmir and the move to punish Pakistan for its nuclear tests (thereby bolstering India) to contributing to Musharaff's rise to power. (http://www.fas.org/news/pakistan/1999/wwwh9o14.htm) So, you indeed had reason to correct me and I would not say that the U.S.'s actions at the time were unjustifiable, but as we can see, such interventionism in the long run has created unforseen problems. We weren't mad, and the only reason we pushed for the power-sharing deal was to increase the Pakistani government's popularity Why is that any of our business? The person may have been an ISI agent turned to work for AQ, but security operatives do no carry out martyrdom attacks. With the ISI's money laundering ties to September 11th (General Ahmad sent 100 grand to Muhammad Atta, http://www.rediff.com/us/2001/dec/24ny9.htm) and similar ties with the 7/7 bombings (http://www.cfr.org/publication/11644/), I would not hold them much higher than an organized crime ring with government sanction, meaning that as in the past it should not surprise us in the future when people play for both sides. The CFR, a mainstream organization that most of the people running for President belong to, assess that the ISI "is hardly monolithic," meaning it is not like a regular government agency. Granted this is a very negative picture of Pakistan and the ISI painted by their detractors, but most experts agree that the ISI is not totally controllable (though it is not a rogue organization). Personally, the whole place is an unstable mess and I fail to see how our tinkering starting before the 1999 coup all the way up to now has improved anything. I would not mind reading a case supporting the opposite from you.
January 4, 200818 yr I dont know who said it earlier, but I find it absolutely ironic that someone who had so much scandal and improperties tied to her former time as prime minister is now seen as a martyr. I also fully believe if the government wasnt behind it, they at the very least knew about it. The whole circus of how she died after was a total joke and does a lot to support this theory.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.