April 13, 200917 yr I'm pretty skeptical of all fielding metrics. I like what +/- tries to do but I am not sure it fully accomplishes it. Defense is definitely the hardest thing to quantify, but that's no revelation. I guess thats why all these metrics keep getting published with teams looking for the next best thing. IMO, you pretty much have to watch a guy play to get a true sense of how good at D he is.
April 13, 200917 yr Author I'm pretty skeptical of all fielding metrics. I like what +/- tries to do but I am not sure it fully accomplishes it. Defense is definitely the hardest thing to quantify, but that's no revelation. I guess thats why all these metrics keep getting published with teams looking for the next best thing. IMO, you pretty much have to watch a guy play to get a true sense of how good at D he is. I agree that it's not definitive, and that you need a mixture of both numbers and scouting to rightfully define how a good a player is. I put a lot more stock in the numbers because I'm not a scout nor can I rightfully judge defense with my eye, but I have no problem defaulting to what scouts say and normally put it about 50/50 in each. But the numbers are almost always in-line with what the scouts say. Derek Jeter getting the gold gloves was based off managers, scouts knew he had taken steps back. Scouts always knew Adam Everett was an elite defensive SS, plus/minus better shows just how elite he is compared to the field. It just better helps quantify just how good a defensive player is, plus just how much of an impact it has on the game.
April 13, 200917 yr +/- fails to associate defensive ability with wins. What it does is tell you how many "good plays" a guy has made over the average fielder. All that determines is who is a good fielder and who isn't, which is fine and dandy, but fielding runs tells you how valuable the player was defensively. I actually like both of them, but I prefer FR for that very reason
April 13, 200917 yr Author One tells you how many runs a player saved. The other tells you how many runs a player saved. What am I missing....?
April 13, 200917 yr +/- fails to associate defensive ability with wins. What it does is tell you how many "good plays" a guy has made over the average fielder. All that determines is who is a good fielder and who isn't, which is fine and dandy, but fielding runs tells you how valuable the player was defensively. I actually like both of them, but I prefer FR for that very reason When it comes to Metrics, I say "the less audacious the better" It does not bother me for a stat-rat to tell me who is better, or who has better defensive production It would bother me if he tried to claim that he knew exactly how many games (or runs) that defense will cost his team.
April 13, 200917 yr +/- fails to associate defensive ability with wins. What it does is tell you how many "good plays" a guy has made over the average fielder. All that determines is who is a good fielder and who isn't, which is fine and dandy, but fielding runs tells you how valuable the player was defensively. I actually like both of them, but I prefer FR for that very reason +/- has obvious flaws but there's valid thinking behind it so it has merit. What is the fielding run formula? How is it calculated?
April 13, 200917 yr One tells you how many runs a player saved. The other tells you how many runs a player saved. What am I missing....? As far as I know, +/- has absolutely nothing to do with runs. It tells you how many times a player made a play that another player at that same position missed. Am I wrong? From the Fielding Bible website: A player gets credit (a "plus" number) if he makes a play that at least one other player at his position missed during the season, and he loses credit (a "minus" number) if he misses a play that at least one player made.
April 13, 200917 yr Author It can then be converted into runs, which Dewan covers in the second book that just came out.
April 13, 200917 yr Actually, the Baseball Prospectus stat I am thinking of is not Fielding Runs, it is called "Defense".
April 13, 200917 yr It can then be converted into runs, which Dewan covers in the second book that just came out. Didn't know that. How do you convert it? Is it based on the 10 runs=1 win?
April 14, 200917 yr Author well, everything, not just all defensive stats but I mean everything, is based off of 10 runs = 1 win. Mutiply first base by 0.73, 2nd/3rd/ss by 0.76, LF and CF by 0.56, and RF by 0.58 to convert plus/minus to runs saved.
April 14, 200917 yr Author Guess I never did post this stuff here Now for how they converted it to runs prevented....i'll get to my thoughts on it in the next post. First, they take the Run Matrix, aka the expected amount of runs to score based on the situation. That being attached. How come it's 0 outs, aka plural, but it isn't plural, it's nothing. I mean, I realize it isn't singular, so it couldn't be 0 out, but it also sure as hell isn't multiple...it's the opposite of multiple. At this point I"m just going to copy the book The key way that we use this chart is to look at it before and after a play. Let's say there's a man on first with one out. The expected runs at this point is .528. The next play is a groundball to the shortstop. He boots it for an error and we now have men on first and second with one out. The expected runs went from .528 to .919. That's an increase of .391 (.919 minus .528) runs. The play itself, the error, cost the team. 391 runs. We dont' have to follow it through and coutn the rest of the inning. We know what the value of the ending state is and can use it. The term that we are using in this book for this is Defensive Runs. Since the error cost the team runs, it becomes a negative when stated as Defensive Runs. The value of the error is -0.391 defensive runs. The plus/minus system is the most important method that we use to evaluate defense. By going through each play in our database and using the run matrix table, we have converted plus/minus into plus/minus runs saved. When we are all done, we came up with a value of runs saved per plus/minus point by position. HEre are the values we use throughout this book. Pitcher: .75 First Base: .73 Second Base: .76 Third Base: .76 Shortstop: .76 Left Field: .56 Center Field: .56 Right Field: .58 For example, if a pitcher has a +4 plus/minus rating, it translate into three runs saved (.75 * 4) (Now for the math) Let's start with this example: Nobody on and no outs, and the batter hits a hard groundball to Stephen Drew at shortstop, specifically to Vector 197 (Slightly to the a normal shortstop's right). Before the groundball, the run expectancy was .521. If Drew gets the out, there is now one out and still nobody on base, a run expectancy of .279, a drop of .242. If he doesn't make the play, the runner reaches first with nobody out, which has a run expectancy of .900, a .379 run increase. The Plus/Minus System gives us the percentage of the time that a hard groundball to Vector 197 was succesffully converted to an out by the shortstop last year: 85.6%. The shortstop will make the play most of the time, but not always. We determine that average shorstop will contribute (.856) * (.242) + (1 - .856) * (-.379) = .153 runs on the play. If Drew converts the out, this play was worth .242-.153 = .091 runs above the average shortstop. Obviously, this can get complicated. FOr outfielders, for instance, a fliner or flyball that falls in safely could easily become a single, double, or a triple depending on a number of things, including the runner. Also , baserunners don't always behave predictably. Some take extra bases, some don't. As a result, we average all of these outcomes togeather based on the freequency of each. After repeating this procedure for every play, we found that there was still plenty of "noise" in the run values that had nothing to do with a fielder's defensive ability. FOr example, converting a difficult play with two outs and the bases loaded could be worht two full runs, but the same play with two outs and nobody on was worht a tenth of that, at no fault of the fielder. This is a situational bias that the fielder has little control over. To adjust for this bias, we took a look at how many runs each plus/minus was worth. How many runs was Chase Utley's +46 plays worth? At second base, it turned out that the avreage plus/minus point was worth .76 runs. That's 35 plus/minus runs saved for Utley in 2008
April 14, 200917 yr Author Also interesting: Also one of the things brought up is about positioning. It doesn't adjust for positioning. So a player that better posititions himself is going to save more bases than one who doesn't. For example, physically, Utley is not the best defensive 2b. The thing is though is that he positions himself better than all other 2Bs. In the end of the day he was still the best defensive 2b last year because he saved the most runs, and in the end it's the end result that matters. But if gave one of the better athletes like Brandon Phillips Utley's positioning, he'd then be better than Utley. What's interesting is that it shows that the largest shifters do the best at 1b, 2b, and SS. The combined Plus/Minus 12 largest 1B shifters: +19 11 Average 1B shifters: +4 12 smallest shifters: -35 2B shifters: +87 average shiftes: +8 Small shifters: -57 SS shifters: +52 average shifters: +29 small shifters: -36 but oppsite for 3b 3B shifters: -41 average: +40 smallest: +34 So I think this goes to show that coaches/teams/whatever needs to do a better job of positioning their IF.
April 14, 200917 yr Author However, it should also be noted that shifting normally has to do with a poor defensive player next to them. Chase Utley plays a big shift because Howard is such a bad defensive 1b. Ergo he gets to more balls than a normal 2b would. However, if Howard was a good fielding 1b, Utley would then not position so drastically, ergo not get to so many balls. That's basically one of the fundamental things of plus/minus v.s. UZR, as I brought up earlier. plus/minus rewards players for making good plays and bad players not making plays a lot more than UZR does. Just staying with the Utley example, he was at +20.6 runs in UZR but +35 in plus/minus. The way the amount of plays is then converted to runs is the same, they look at the same run expectancy and such, it's just a matter of how much credit do you give to a guy making a play somebody at his position doesn't normally make. I can kinda understand the two points defining each.
April 14, 200917 yr I'm sorry, but measuring how many runs someone saved versus how many extra out's someone caused or didn't cause is a negative. Might as well be measuring RBI.
April 14, 200917 yr Author I'm sorry, but measuring how many runs someone saved versus how many extra out's someone caused or didn't cause is a negative. Might as well be measuring RBI. lol, that was basically my rseponse to it, morecopypasta I really don't know about this and want to call bulls***. I mean, it's completely juding things out of the fielders hands. Are we going to start counting RBIs again? I mean, do the same for offense. If a player hit a single with no one on, that's worth less runs than a player doing the same exact thing with a runner on third. Are we going to fault a guy putting up a .300/.400/.500 line on San Francisco's team compared to a guy putting up a .300/.400/.500 line on NYY's team because the other hitters in the line up suck? I realize that we are then talking about averaging the entire thing all togeather, to try and take that out. But it's still applying things out of the fielders control. If a ball is hit to a shortstop and he converts an out with nobody on base, but does the SAME exact thing with a runner on second, why should the second one be worth more runs? Having a misplay also be woth in the mid-.70's is also just obscene. I mean, seriously? I'm probably going to keep with the .5 metric. Although I could also understand using .375 (Average up all the "man on first" run expectancies, so that it completely takes out things outside of the fielders control (and, by making a misplay, we are talking about generally putting a guy on first that shouldn't be there). (.900+.528+.227)/3=.376. Honestly I'm actually leaning a lot more towards .375 at this point. I'll probably use .375-.5 and say "somewhere around this" lol.
April 14, 200917 yr Too much work. I'll just go with the quick-and-easy Baseball Prospectus method and let them figure out all the complicated stuff
April 14, 200917 yr Author Atleast go with UZR then I mean, BP had Uggla as saving 8 runs last year. I think that alone should show it's problematic lol
April 14, 200917 yr Atleast go with UZR then I mean, BP had Uggla as saving 8 runs last year. I think that alone should show it's problematic lol They actually have Uggla costing 8 runs, not saving.
April 14, 200917 yr My Baseball Prospectus 2009 book has him at -8 :shrugs The stat I am talking about ("Defense") is not listed on that link. I guess the only way to see it is if you have the book or a subscription with BP
April 14, 200917 yr Actually, nevermind. Try this link. Look under the column titled "Defense". They have him at -8 for last year.
April 14, 200917 yr Author Whatever it is, it has minor league defensive stats, so I'm real curious to know how it's calculated to know if it's legit since nothing else covers the minors.
April 15, 200917 yr The way they calculate it is similar to the +/- . They use an in-depth play-by-play data system in which they compare the results of every play to the average expected result and assign values to it, and then they convert it to runs using a liner weights type of system. It's really complicated, but it seems to be legit. And yeah, the fact that they have MiLB is really incredible.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.