Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins2003

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Marlins2003

  1. All the boxscores are on the league website and I followedthem almost everyday. My sense is he didn't miss more than a couple of games, playing everyday at shortstop and hitting better against lefties than righties. He was definitely not held out because of LHP.
  2. I want to apologize to everyone for being happy that Dontrelle and the Marlins avoided arbitration. Forgive me father I have sinned. It has come to that hasn't it Don.
  3. My sense of Murphy, who I admit to have never seen play (a disclosure I would encourage others here to make when they make these wide-ranging and often ugly pronouncements villifying players) but just looking at him through the eyes ofsites like minorleaguesplits.com, milb.com, various blogs and messageboards, leaves me with three impressions: 1. There's no evidence he can hit at the major league level. He had a nice second half in the minors but frankly alot of players can say that. So far, he looks to have a very limited offensive upside. 2. He is of little value (other than in a trade) to his parent club. That may be a good thing. We all know Hanley's famous quote about when he thought he factored into the Red Sox'plans. 3. He's about to become yesterday's news as younger players work their way through the system. I'm not going to say the guy can't be a late-bloomer, we have a team in part comprised of them and their maturity and determination brings something to the table you won't find in some 20 year old phenom who has been told his whole life he "deserves" to be the bigs,but he needs to put together a good year somewhere, probably Pawtucket, before he's worth making a major investment in. Right now he's worth an equivalent prospect, from where he's frequently ranked, I guess a 10-12th ranked player. A couple of things are working against him too. One is Ellsbury who certainly will be taking an MLB roster spot ahead of Murphy and Red Sox death struggle against their foes, the Yankess, almost guarantees (at least to me) there will probably never be a spot for Murphy as anything other than a spare part unless he absolutely sets the world on fire. It's kind of unfair but we were just discussing Upton's plight (and no Lou, I'm not equating their talent, just their circumstance, sorry you won't be able to twist that around as you do so often) and they are sort of in similar situations where the parent clubs appear to be looking elsewhere. Alot of these kids deserve better. Maybe the Marlins are an answer but I suspect unless the price is incredibly low, it won't be.
  4. There's an enormous difference between the value of, and more importantly the market for, young starting pitching, both at the major league level and in the high minors, and that of a deficient infielder regardless of age who it is hoped can find a job as the fourth outfielder on the worst team in baseball. Yes that was cold, and perhaps unfair, but don't worry, in my own way, I'll undo that comment later in this post. Any day the Marlins want to entertain offers for their fifth starter or their top ten minor league pitching prospects the line will form around the block with GMs making legitimate offers for every one of them. Beinfest, if he chose, could trade them all in a day (figuratively) and collect a king's ransom in the process while the GM-less Devil Rays (and that is their problem, the new ownership has a guy with zero major league experience making player personnel decisions who believes the title GM is beneath him and has said so) are tied in knots helpless to find anyone who is willing to pay their asking price for players who deserve better. Upton will rot on the vine until he's 25 or 26 at this rate. It is isn't fair to the players being held hostage nor to the fans. Just look at Rocco Baldelli and for a minute take the Marlins out of the equation. How many teams have been linked to serious talks with TB regarding Baldelli? And yet no one could even get close because of the way player personnel works there. Beinfest is the exact opposite and some complain he gets rid of players too quickly. The Sean Wests and the Chris Volstads and the Harvey Garcias don't have to worry about getting their shot at the bigs, they know it will come if not with the Marlins with someone else, and with the history of this franchise of elevating players from the AA level, they know it will happen sooner rather than later. The Marlins are a team where player turnover is as sure as the sun coming up in the morning. Upton's value, regardless of hype or talent declines everyday there is no place for him to play and worse, no plan to showcase his talents. It isn't his fault, and it isn't as I said above, about his talent. The Devil Rays could probably get any top five team major league ready pitching prospect (maybe even with another top fifteen) for Upton tomorrow, but they greedily want more. Like it or not, agree or not, no one will ever know unless TB relents on his value or Baldelli's and sets one of them free (I don't want that misinterpreted as they should give either away) so they both can flourish. Very seldom do I remark that a ballplayer "deserves" to play, in fact one would be hard-pressed to find in three years+ years here me saying as much, but the pro-Upton camp has convinced *me*, if perhaps not of his *overwhelming* value, at least that he deserves his day in the sun *and he's not getting that in Tampa*. (* duplicate paragraphs removed*) * * = edit
  5. And it just dawned on me...the Philly website's source for the Alfonseca signing is the Miami Herald. Again, not saying it isn't true but I missed that in the first reading :mischief2
  6. I haven't seen Sanchez play very much, but I think it is possible that his defense is borderline Reggie bad (if not worse). and I believe he has a weak arm as well unless the steroids he got busted for helped his arm strength 200 fold, his arm is weaker than Juan Pierre's. I really don't believe the comment about his arm being weaker than Juan Pierre's is true. I believe his problem is bad routes, losing balls in sky, etc., and while he may not have a cannon, it's acceptable. If I'm wrong, feel free to correct me. What are you all bitching about? Beinfest is doing the best he can with what he has. He signed a centerfielder with a career batting average of .296 to a minor-league contract and you're complaining? Not to mention he's made some damn good pick-ups for the bullpen from the minor-league contract bin that have all had good success before and could easily do it again. PLUS, Gregg, Owens, and Lindstrom are all talented and I think will have success. I really don't understand what you guys are complaining about. I'm happy with what Beinfest has been able to do while barely spending a dollar. If you're gonna bitch, bitch at Loria. Wild, absolutely. We're complaining because Beinfest signed the guy to a minor league contract...sheesh. What do people expect Beinfest to say? "Yeah we signed him but psst he doesn't have a snowball's chance in hell of making the team, he's the insurance policy for the insurance policy..."
  7. Actually, his value was diminished (even below what it was when he was traded) when he broke his ankle/foot early on in the year.
  8. We're in a unique situation right now where the organization is sitting on a tremendous opportunity (read, talent pool) and if we're prudent, and wait to see how things work themselves out in spring training (we all want to believe no one will be injured, everyone stays healthy and productive but the real world doesn't usually work out that way), we'll be rewarded. It's been a slow off-season and it's hard not to be frustrated or anxious about a making a "big" trade to fill an obvious shortcoming. But that doesn't mean we should be making trades for the sake of making trades. Beinfest is right to wait and not rush to give away prospects just to make the rotisserie leaguers happy. Not when you see what desperate teams are willing to pay for pitching, and how much moreso as opening day approaches. Whether it's toward the end of spring training, or the trade deadline, or even next off-season (which is only nine months away) allowing our staff to mature (with some insurance waiting in the wings) and our prospects to as well, makes good business sense. None of the above is meant to mean if the RIGHT deal comes along for the right player, you don't pull the trigger on a trade. I have enough confidence in Beinfest that he and his staff will know when the time is right and the professional talent evaluators will make the right choices. Two and a half months from now, the Marlins will be playing baseball for real. Regardless of who plays centerfield the first half of the season it's virtually a guarantee they will be more productive than Abercrombie was. And if Hermida stays healthy and even comes close to what was expected from him among the national media and baseball mavens from virtually every reputable source/site, this will be a better, more productive club even if some guys fall short of last year's numbers. I also think there's another issue to consider, one that may be a behind the scenes motivating force. One of the biggest objections to state assistance in stadium financing, no matter how ridiculous the argument is regarding the tax rebate - you're rebating only a portion of taxes collected that would only be collected if a stadium is built - is the notion that this a sport with multi-millionaire owners paying millions to ballplayers like it was monopoly money. I think one of the reasons you've seen the Marlins take such a low profile in recent months is to not throw fuel on that fire and may be one of the reasons the team continues to offer Willis and especially Cabrera one year contracts. Committing to pay Miggy $150-200 million over X years makes the average person question whether this is a franchise in need of their help. You don't want to give the naysayers or your enemies any ammunition to use against you. I believe what DuPuy said some months ago about really pulling together a world class team of professionals who worked through the problems in Washington DC to get that accomplished, and I would guess those are the same people driving this deal as well. That isn't an anti-Loria/Samson comment but rather a tip of the hat to DuPuy and his troops. So in my mind it isn't as simplistic as some would proffer, there any number of complex issues of talent value on both sides of the trading equation as well as issues related to the wellbeing of the franchise itself. At the very least we can afford to give Beinfest and company some time to sort it all out. Tomorrow the legislature reconvenes, we'll know the disposition of Tallahassee before the season opens, and if it turns our way, alot of other pieces may fall into place as well.
  9. Looks like Barry got it right after all... Phils agree with Madson, Alfonseca Right-handed relievers get one-year deals from Philadelphia By Ken Mandel / MLB.com PHILADELPHIA -- Ryan Madson avoided arbitration on Sunday by agreeing to a one-year, $1.1 million deal with the Phillies, leaving the club with four arbitration-eligible players. Madson wasn't the only reliever to agree to a contract, as veteran reliever Antonio Alfonseca also accepted a one-year deal that could be worth up to $1.1 million, according to The Miami Herald. The newspaper cited Alfonseca's agent, Juan Iglesias, who said his client selected the Phillies over the Marlins. Alfonseca was limited to 52 games over the past two seasons with the Rangers and Marlins. He was shut down in 2006 because of a sore right elbow. He compiled a 2.57 ERA in 79 games with Atlanta in 2004, his last full season. Madson, 26, went 11-9 with two saves and a 5.69 ERA in 50 games, including 17 starts, in 2006. He finished second on the team in wins, third in innings pitched (134 1/3) and fourth in strikeouts (99), establishing career highs in all of those categories. As a reliever, Madson went 3-4 with a 4.50 ERA. After shuttling between the bullpen and rotation last season, the right-hander is expected to exclusively be used as a reliever in 2007, and should serve in a late-inning role. Originally selected by the Phillies in the ninth round of the 1998 First-Year Player Draft, Madson has spent his entire career with the Phillies, going 26-17 with three saves and a 4.35 ERA in 181 games. The remaining four arbitration-eligible players are Geoff Geary, Brett Myers, Aaron Rowand and Chase Utley. Of that group, the team is considering a long-term deal with Utley that would essentially buy out his three arbitration years -- thus eliminating the yearly filing -- and perhaps delay his filing for free agency by a year or two.
  10. Alex Sanchez has two shortcomings, neither of which have anything to do with Reggie's biggest problem...hitting a baseball. If the entire game was about puttting the ball in play Sanchez would certainly better be held in higher regard. Unfortunately there's more to the game, namely defense and demeanor. Sanchez has had lapses of judgement or concentration in the field and he's had issues with teammates from time to time. How much of both are now behind him no one here knows, we'll have to wait and see what happens in spring training. His time in SF, Skully could probably elaborate.
  11. What continues to be interesting (at least to me) as the day goes on is a) no one else is confirming or even reporting Alfonseca's Philly agreement (which one would think would have to include a physical all things considered) and b) his agent who is quoted by Jackson has neither confirmed or denied it. I am curious what to make of it. And I am curious if the Marlins in fact have an offer on the table...
  12. Not saying Jackson doesn't have it right, but no other news source - news.Google, Roto, ESPN, SI, Fox Sports, the Phillies MLB website - has reported as of 9:00am this morning Antonio Alfonseca signing anywhere, nevermind Philadelphia. And based on Borowski's incentive-laded 2006 contract the two as described by BJ don't seem that much different. I'm not sure what to think about this. I would think Florida would be the better choice for AA for a number of reasons - Philly fans, the weather and his body, familiarity - but if the story is true the offers most have been structured significantly differently. Usually Jackson is reasonably on the mark but this column reads more like messageboard chatter and a quick run through Rotoworld than anything new and ground-breaking. It will be interesting to see whether the AA thing proves true or not. (edit) Jacobs does have a point there. No doubt several Marlins could take avantage of having a lefthanded BP guy. There's any number of semi-pro guys around Miami who would be glad to do it for peanuts. It's probably more getting the front office to think outside the box and get behind the idea than anything else.
  13. It's an interesting question. Maybe someone else will do better research than me but a quick run through Marlins transactions as listed on their website indicates no compensatory player so I have to assume they took the cash option (which was listed as part of the deal, player or cash). He now appears to be part of the Washington Nationals organization.
  14. Interesting that Nook Logan is getting a starting job over the guys we should be interested in. And the majority of you laughed at me when I mentioned his name last year when he got waived. and we'll still be laughing at you. Nook Logan is terrible, and Manny Acta is looking like an idiot so far(he wants to have Christian "only one OBP over .311 in his career" Guzman batting second) I don't get the Nook Logan thing either :blink:
  15. Of course it's the Mexican Winter League and it's not the majors but I happened upon something that caught my eye and thought I'd pass it along. As we all know Amezaga's achille's heel last season was hitting lefties, batting .091. Personally, since he hit almost .300 against righties I always thought he should abandon switch-hitting and face all pitchers from the left side, but I digress. I happen to come across his splits in Mexico and guess what, he's hitting .303 against lefties vs. .296 against righties this winter. I wonder what he's doing different? If anyone fluent in spanish wants to check through the team's website I'd be interested to know if he continues to switch hit or anything that might indicate why he's showing so much improvement (besides the league not being = to MLB). BTW, for anyone out there fearful I'm suggesting Amezaga start in CF in 2007, he hasn't played so much as an inning there as far as I can see, playing exclusively at shortstop (which kinda makes you wonder about you know who *wink wink*). I'm just curious why the big turnaround in his LHP stat. link to his team's website - www.ligadelpacifico.com.mx oh, and BTW here's his stats - http://www.minorleaguebaseball.com/app/mil...&pid=407792
  16. (note to Mods) We have two threads on pretty much the same thing that both quote the same Rosenthal and Roto blurbs.) None of this is vaguely new, or news, but it will make the rounds as one place after another repeats it. Maybe someone else has, but I have yet to find one really positive (read authoratative, vs some blog or messageboard post) article on Gutierrez. I read the "good ballplayer but strikes out too much" stuff all the time but nothing that really would indicate to me he's an answer here. Now if Beinfest or his guys see something different and he works out, that's great neither he nor Murphy really have shown they can play at the major league level as opposed to other equivalent options out there not on the Tampa Bay roster. Speaking of Tampa Bay, it's going to be interesting to watch who does and who doesn't get A team play time and who doesn't, and how Dukes and to a lesser degree Upton will handle themselves if they don't. I'm kinda thinking Tampa is going to relent (not necessarily as it relates to the Marlins) and pull off at least a couple of trades before spring training starts if for no other reason than to clear the air and get people settled into their positions. But one never knows with TB.
  17. Actually, if they're both proven to be healthy enough I'd want to sign both Benitez and Alfonseca. They provide a number of things not the least of which are options around the two major trading deadlines depending on the club's standings and chances down the stretch that could be invaluable. Ditto Rodriguez and Gregg.
  18. You're just going to keep lieing and lieing and lieing and lieing. A leopard doesn't change its spots. But that's the only way you can justify your roto league trades and your video game mentality.
  19. F-Rod>El Pulpo Er, no. Right now, based on AA's winter league numbers you'd have to go with him although in fairness to both it really depends on their individual health. Given a choice between the best of AA and the best of FR, I'd still take AA.
  20. Thanks Lou for the lecture. Wrong again as usual, but predictable as hell. And can you possibly post with putting words in my mouth? Let me rephrase, because I'm not really asking a question, even rhetorically. Stop putting words in my mouth and creating false arguments. :thumbdown
  21. Phew...that's a relief. If nothing else Albuquerque is going to be an interesting team this season.
  22. Not being in the same region, therefore not hearing as much news... can i actually get my hopes up? uh huh :thumbup
  23. Is this Comcast inserting the content at the :25 and :55 slots on CNN Headline News or is it WPLG? It's a Comcast produced local show. What if anything WPLG has to do with it I don't know.
  24. You forgot to paste the first part of the story, how well AA is doing in Mexico. Amezaga thriving in Mexican League Utilityman hitting .296 with one homer through six games By Chip Haunss / Special to MLB.com Infielder Alfredo Amezaga continued his fine stint with the Yaquis de Obregon in the Mexican Pacific League playoffs. The 28-year-old utilityman is batting .296 (8-for-27) with one home run, four RBIs and three runs scored in six games for the Yaquis, who are 3-3 in the playoffs. Amezaga, who was signed by the Marlins in November 2005, completed the regular [Mexican League] season with a .297 batting average, three homers, 24 runs scored, 15 RBIs and 14 stolen bases in 39 games. [ ]
  25. (note to mods - this brief program will only be on a few times today, I think alot of people may want to see it - feel free to move or delete this tomorrow) Comcast broadcasts on the CNN Headline News channel (29 here) a local program featuring Spiro whatshisface. Today's guest is ex-asst county manager and now City of Miami Manager Pete Hernandez (whose job it was to get the stench out of city hall once Joe Arriola departed) and the subject is the new ballpark downtown. I'll let you hear it for yourself (unless someone knows how to find an online feed and can post it here) he is very very upbeat and talking like this is a done deal. They've been using the footprints of existing modern stadiums (Camden Yards was one mentioned, I forget the others) and he says triumphantly "they all fit". I don't know the broadcast schedule (but it usually interrupts Glenn Beck around 7:25 - 7:35pm). Those interested might want to look out for it.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.