Everything posted by chuck carr
-
July 31 - Cardinals vs Marlins
No W for Cashner but certainly helped win that game. Even Rea helped even the series. And these two wins were huge. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
July 31 - Cardinals vs Marlins
Wrong again. Very new to site. And probably not for long. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
July 31 - Cardinals vs Marlins
I'm sure I'm next to be banned anyway because I don't always agree. But this belief is just astonishing to me. He was not thrown in for cash. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
July 31 - Cardinals vs Marlins
Correct that was his mindset. The no walks today kept him out of trouble. This philosophy stars from the SABR staff and then Hill passes it to Mattingly and Nieves. There's an algorithm showing Cash is more effective sacrificing Ks for less walks. This isn't true for everyone. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
July 31 - Cardinals vs Marlins
A throw in? I know this is sarcasm, but nobody called him a throw in. Cashner was the reason we made the move for the playoff push. Then the deal expanded to have another starter/controllable asset. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
July 31 - Cardinals vs Marlins
Not sure what Miami announcers were saying because I was on Cardinals feed, but even though Cashner didn't have his best stuff today, he was told to not go for strikeouts until needed and to pitch to contact. Kind of like how they handle Jose. He's going to be good for us. Such a shame about Rea. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
AJ Ramos
How about Barraclough trade? Signing McGehee from Japan and then trading him for Castillo and Flores? Drafting Lomo and dealing him for Capps? Drafting and converting JT from infielder to catcher? Drafting Jose, Yelich, Stanton, Ozuna, Ramos, etc? The Prado/Phelps deal? The Dee trade? Ichiro signing? It's amazing how much hate there is for a front office who has a manager who won't spend money like most teams and yet has built a really nice team. Of course people will play the results of Rea's injury regarding the trade, but Miami saw some approach/pitch selection/pitch location flaws which they thought with simple tweaks could really help Rea. The 3 innings was too short of a sample size to know, but he clearly has/had stuff to be a cog in our rotation for next 5 years. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
Rea
For better or worse, Chen will be back for us soon. He will take back Rea's spot (probably 10 days from now depending on strength). Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
July 30 - Cardinals vs Marlins
Even if you dislike the deal (and it seems a majority do), any clubhouse is going to get a boost when the players feel like management is going for it by dealing non active players for reinforcements. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
2016 Trade Deadline Thread
Just making the point that this wasn't only a rental like the Urbina deal, which involved Adrian Gonzalez who by himself was a better package than what we just traded. Rea could also help us this year. I'm not commenting on this deal anymore. I respect all of your opinions on the deal and fully get it. In my opinion, I like that we went for it. I think we overpaid as I have said from the beginning but that was the price in this market. I don't like the cash part either, but do not believe that was why we included Capps in the deal, by a long shot. Go Marlins. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
Analysis: Marlins Acquire Cashner and Rea
The cash part is on Loria not Hill. And do you forget how close we were at times to NOT winning the WS in 2003? It's all about trying when you have the window of opportunity. We just added 2/5 of our rotation - that's more than a closer. And we added a couple long term pieces this time. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
2016 Trade Deadline Thread
Guerrero is nothing but an intriguing arm, but there is some potential. The point of this deal was to help now. Naylor, Castillo and Capps can't help now. Paddack couldn't help now (and could be hurt). It's not easy projection prospects outside the top 100 or guys coming off TJ with a history of arm issues. It is easy to say we added 2/5 of our rotation in a playoff push. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
Analysis: Marlins Acquire Cashner and Rea
I agree that $ was a factor, but a small one. Not equal to getting Capps. And I disagree by how you think people in support of the deal are evaluating it. If it helps our team win now, Naylor and Castillo can be good players and it won't matter. Like the Urbina deal and countless other trade deadline deals around the league over the years. You don't add pitchers for free. Orioles and Rangers were in on Cashner, just to name a couple clubs. Plus, this is not an Urbina situation because Rea has long term potential and Guerrero is intriguing. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
2016 Trade Deadline Thread
I was actually right about Capps being included because I have known for weeks that every conversation with teams for a starting pitcher included Capps. Every one - once guys from the starting roster were excluded. And by the way, here's an actual prediction - Capps' career will be known more for potential and injuries than for success. His elbow will never be right. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
2016 Trade Deadline Thread
He wasn't the final name added. He was the final name reported. It's shocking to me that people don't realize Naylor and Castillo were throw ins here. Every deal was always going to begin with Capps. Be objective. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
2016 Trade Deadline Thread
I know you are angry with the trade, but you don't honestly believe we could have gotten Cashner, Rea and Guerrero for Naylor, Castillo and Cosart had we kept the contract. Capps was the only way, and was always going to be the only way, we added a starter, let alone two, in this market. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
Analysis: Marlins Acquire Cashner and Rea
We added two starting pitchers,, one who could be in our rotation for years, and minor league arm with potential. With or without the cash, no chance of getting this deal done without Capps. Naylor and Castillo are not even top 100 prospects. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
Analysis: Marlins Acquire Cashner and Rea
Even if it is barely better, a couple games could. be the difference. And I believe it's more than barely better. Cashner and Rea are capable of being much better than what we had. We had to go for it. Starting pitching is the only way to upgrade this team. We paid the price in the current market. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
7/29 - Cards at Marlins - 7:10
I'm watching. I'm sorry that I disagree with everyone else on the board. I am an avid fan too. I know that we tried to get many starting pitchers in this process and only had the assets for this move, which brings us two arms - one under control. I don't think we could upgrade our starting lineup or bullpen so we did the only thing we could to improve our chances this year. Just because I respectfully disagree with you doesn't make me wrong (or right) or less of a fan. I'm happy we went for it. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
7/29 - Cards at Marlins - 7:10
Shocking that Urena isn't throwing a shutout? It's amazing to me that anyone thinks Urena or Cosart was the solution. We haven't sniffed the playoffs in years and here we are in the cusp. Cashner and Rea helps us a lot and we paid the price we had to pay for them. I'm confused by all the negativity. We traded one known asset and he's hurt and he's at a position we are deep in. We are going for it. I'd take one playoff series and 3 bad seasons over 4 mediocre seasons. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
2016 Trade Deadline Thread
Guerrero could pitch for this Fish this year by the way as well. He's got work to do, but has elite stuff. Kind of like Capps a few years ago. We weren't getting starting pitching for free people. We paid a steep price but why does it not matter that Rea could be in our rotation for years to come? That doesn't mean anything? If he is our #4 starter for the next 3-4 years, plus we make a playoff run this year plus we add a bullpen arm who can throw upper 90s, why such negativity? Rea starts for us Saturday and Cashner on Sunday, and we are fighting for a playoff spot. We gave up low minor leaguers and a guy out for the year. And good riddance to Cosart. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
2016 Trade Deadline Thread
It's funny, I was the only one to state that we'd be dealing Capps away in this process. When I did, people said no way, he's hurt. You do understand that we didn't have the goods to add more than Cashner/Rea. Ervin Santana, who I wanted, was our only shot because of the $. Plus, the team rightfully wanted a controllable asset, instead of a pure rental, and got 2. I love Capps, but you do realize that other than him, we didn't give up much. And we have Ramos, Rodney, Phelps, Wittgren, Ellington, etc. - lots of controllable righty arms. We had to make a move for starting rotation depth especially with Chen out. And we didn't have the assets to do better than this. I preferred Bud Norris for Paddack and pieces than Rodney. But that shipped sailed. So, if this is what the market dictated, and I believe it did, for us to add starting pitching, then I am on board. Cashner and Rea will be much better with our defense and pen than they were in SD. Maybe Capps is great next year and maybe it wouldn't matter because Jose gets hurt and we finish under .500. You never know. You have to play for this year and we traded (as I predicted weeks ago) the only assets we had. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
2016 Trade Deadline Thread
I am surprised. Nobody realizes that we probably just added 2/5 of our starting rotation while making a playoff push and lost nobody who could help this year other than Cosart. Guerrero has a really live arm by the way, who some project as an MLB closer. Cosart, Naylor and Castillo for Cashner, Rea and Guerrero would be robbery by us in this market. Adding Capps tips there scale in their favor. I love Capps. But righty relievers are our strength. And completely disregarding the TJ factor, especially with a guy using a herky jerky motion is just not fair. Repeat TJ's are way up. 35% of TJs in 2014 were repeats. And for next year, I was using Ellington as an example for a bullpen arm who can take Capps's spot. Right now, I take Rea and Ellington over Capps for just next season for our team. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
2016 Trade Deadline Thread
People seem to completely disregard Rea. He's had a couple very nice stretches this year on a team with bad defense. He's controllable for several years. He will likely be in our starting 5 next year. Capps coming off TJ next year will be used so delicately that Ellington could have a more productive season. We all know we overpaid. However, we dealt a relieve coming off TJ, 2 non top 100 prospects (Castillo not top 200) and Cosart to give us a chance this year to make the playoffs! And we get a starter for next year. We have helped our team for the next 2 seasons. You may call me shortsighted, but nothing we have up is of top shelf quality. I can live with it. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
-
2016 Trade Deadline Thread
It's funny, when I said we'd be dealing Capps you all said no, that nobody would want a guy coming off TJ. Now that we move him, it's like we traded Yelich. We have a very could, young offense. We have an excellent, deep bullpen. Our rotation is bad, but now Cashner gives us a boost. Yes, he is a boost. He throws hard and will play well in meaningful games with our defense and bullpen. And Rea is another arm to help with depth. I love Capps, but a guy who throws like that coming off TJ is a big risk and we have a lot of righty bullpen arms. Like I said, if Cashner pitches in the post season it's a good deal. I am surprised you all don't appreciate how hard it is to have a window like this. The NL East is only getting better. We can make the playoffs! All this doom and gloom is unwarranted. We are better today than yesterday. Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app