Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

jonnylons

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by jonnylons

  1. Hooper deserves a shot, at least a ST invite - and if I remember correctly, he raised a lot of eyebrows last ST. Nunez, he had an unfortunate injury in ST last year, otherwise he would have made this team as a 5th OF - something I remember debating heavily with Keyswayne last year (he did not like Nunez). Again, I think Castillo's value is not what it used to be - he is about to demand way too much money for his abilities. We could spend that money elsewhere, and I am actually quite happy to hear that we may not sign him (and that he may land on a big market club). Lowell is the real deal. The most consistent hitter on this club, is not the best (anymore, that would be Cabs) but is among the top 3 3B in ALL of baseball (if not the top - and Cabs would be right there too). NO ONE IN BASEBALL AT HIS POSITION MATCHED HIS LEVEL OF PRODUCTION.
  2. Nunez came back last summer, late, after a lengthy period on the DL. He came back and hit like a man possessed. You have to keep in mind he had a dozen more than 200 at bats in 2003. To put that in perspective Derrek Watham had 473 ABs. I think at one point in his first hundred or so at bats he was hitting .350-.370 or more, he was on fire. Then he fell off a cliff and ended the season batting .311. He probably didn't average .250 in his last 75 at bats. Had he continued and had 350-400 at bats he probably would have hit .260-.270. He's got this big sloppy swing, last time I saw him he just never settles into the batters box. Everything's in motion, sort of Willie Mays Hayes the first time he steps into the battersbox. Jello. Maybe Treanor or someone on the 'Topes got him out of that bad habit, I hope so. Maybe he can hit .300 in the majors or at least deliver something approaching Cabs rookie year but I think we'd hear more about the guy if he was the real deal. There's no question he has home run power, but the bottom line is he's an inconsistent hitter at best. That's the thing about him that drives you crazy. He's such a streak hitter. When he came up at the end of 2002 he was god awul. He embarrassed himself every time he came to bat. I'd like to be proved wrong. He'll do nicely for a 4th OF. Especially on a financially strapped team. I have always liked this guy too, and it is good to see others like his talent. He has speed and power - probably wont hit for average. Good for .260-.270 but with 20/20 (and about 100+K's). All in all, give him the opportunity to play as our 4th. As for Hooper, I like him too. I think he will be a good replacement for Fox and/or Mordecai. He is capable of spelling both mid-IF positions, and that is very valuable. Plus, he is a hustler and a smart player. Both, two important pieces for our team and will help us contend in 2004.
  3. I think the Marlins should have made Castillo their #1 priority and offered more money to him and less to Lowell. Why is a Braves fan posting on our site, I often ask... I agree with Fish Fry above, Castillo is costing us too much money and limiting ourselves in making this team better both financially and by keeping us from going after players. I say let him go because his value is not good - he makes too much money for the amount of production he will put up. I will hate to lose him, but I am also not totally sold that he is healed. If Castillo signs elsewhere, the Marlins could regret dealing first baseman Derrek Lee to the Cubs for Hee Seop Choi and a minor-leaguer on Tuesday. They made that salary dump under the impression a Castillo pact was highly likely, even pressuring Castillo for an answer in the days leading up to the trade. Disagree - the Marlins made a smart move by taking on Choi's contract AND his talent is on par with Lee's. But Castillo's waffling, if we read this correctly, is hurting our organization, and it is still early. I say cut him loose, go get players you need.
  4. It could actually help us. Think about it, The Yanks need to make a big move to match the Red Sox so they could either take Millwood from Philly or trade for Javi Vazquez from Montreal.Or if they get desperate they could go after that Maddux guy... Exactly. That is what I am looking for from you guys... This deal IS going to have an impact on us - indirectly.
  5. I have to agree with the naysayers on this topic. Stokes couldn't break a .320 OBP at A-ball. Since that article was written mid-season, I think that BA overreacted to a hot month and ranked him #3 based on his '02 potential more than his '03 performance. I think had the article been written now, there's no way that Stokes would even make the top 10. So far, Gonzalez has shown himself to be better than Stokes, but neither one of them is any good. I'd take Choi over either one of them. Unlike Stokes and Gonzalez, Choi has nothing left to prove at the minor league level. A .621 SLG at AAA is just sick! So, the ranking was composed this year for 2003? Or is it from 2002?
  6. In response to my previous post, there are some modifications: You would let go: Pudge save $7M (not $10M) Castillo $6M Redmond $1.1M Redman $3M Enc (non-tender/trade, already accounted for) Savings = $17.1M Replace with: Castro $.4M 2B (FA/Prospect) $2M Backup $.5M Spot Starter/Prospect/FA $1M Vlad $13M Total = $16.9M I corrected Pudge's totals (accounting for the deferred) and raised Vlad's yearly pay up $3M.? Still saving about 200K and that is projecting the replacements at maximum spending.? May save another $1M if worked out right.? And we still meet our payroll requirement - or at least HotCorner's projection.? Let me know what you think... the "savings" = "replace with" argument is so severely flawed because you're forgetting that a number of players would have to be cut just to hit $49mil--WITHOUT vlad. the takeaway/giveaway doesn't account for the big picture. if you can post a roster with realistic salaries then i'll tell you what i think. but right now you're just regurgitating ramp's worksheet but this time claiming it hits our payroll mark. Allright, here we go: Hampton 8,000,000 Pudge 3,000,000 Juan Pierre 2,300,000 2B (replacement for Castillo) 2,000,000* Hee Sop Choi 350,000 Mike Lowell 7,000,000 Alex Gonzalez 2,500,000 Miguel Cabrera 300,000 Jeff Conine 3,000,000 AJ Burnett 2,500,000 Spot starter (for Mark Redman) 1,000,000 Brad Penny 3,000,000 Josh Beckett 2,100,000 Carl Pavano 2,500,000 Dontrelle Willis 375,000 Braden Looper? Chad Fox 1,000,000 Spoonybarger 300,000 Tommy Phelps 300,000 Nate Bump 300,000 Michael Tejera 300,000 Backup C (for Mike Redmond) 500,000 Mike Mordecai 300,000 Bench IF 500,000 Brian Banks 300,000 Bench OF 500,000 Total 44,225,000 Savings $15,775,000 Of this, you have to squeeze Looper - if you want him - or find a cheaper replacement. The 2B replacement does not have to reach $2M, could be lower, but could save another $1-1.5 at most. Signing Vlad @ $10M - 13M could be worked out, defer money over the next 2-3 years with a stipulation around the stadium deal (if done, 2005). This would hit $60M on the mark. There is no telling whether or not if this is a hard and fast cap or if Loria frees up some extra money to get extras. Either way, you have to lose Pudge, Castillo, Enc, Redman, Redmond to make this happen. Now, you will probably want to argue what the core of this team is...
  7. i'm clear. you're correct. the yankees are the 2003 world champions. No, your wrong, The Marlins won the World Series - they beat the Yankees in 2003.
  8. So the rankings are old, as of 2002. Why would you bring up that point unless you were trying to say Gonzalez is better than Stokes? You STILL have yet to be clear that this is what you are trying to say, so I will help you - who do you think right now is a better 1B, Stokes or Adrian Gonzalez? And please state why. Secondly, you never said that I said Stokes was ready now. I will concede that as long as you try not to argue your way out of something you shouldnt have to argue about. But I dont think you know what you are trying to say. I said Stokes should be ready by 2005, you seem to agree with me by saying he is not ready now and that you are concerned about his injury. Why you continue to argue over the point, I have absolutely no idea. You can say I am being uncivilized, but it is you who are on the defensive here which only indicates you are frustrated. And seeing you have yet to say anything of substance, it must be attributed to your lack of a good point. Let me save you some time - should we be worried about Stokes injury? Yes. But looking at his 2003 stats, it seems that he can still produce while being not totally healthy. Hopefully, he will rebound and put together a good 2004 - if that is the case, you see him in Sept, before expected. But still, make a case for why you want to rank Gonzalez higher than Stokes, if that is your point. (As I asked you in this post) And finally, AAA is greater than A. But Gonzalez got demoted from AAA to AA, which is still better than A. But I will be patient and see who puts together the better numbers. Stokes is still very young and so is Gonzalez, but I dont see Gonzalez putting up the power numbers Stokes will. I also dont see Gonzalez being a better hitter because he has yet to put up better stats - or near comparible stats - that Stokes has put up.
  9. 1% chance Vlad will sign with the Fish.Acquiring Choi made Fish future plans more obvious.Choi will be 1b and Conine will play OF. alright, fine. i'll concede you 1%, jonny. Umm...minus said that, not me, alky.
  10. In response to my previous post, there are some modifications: You would let go: Pudge save $7M (not $10M) Castillo $6M Redmond $1.1M Redman $3M Enc (non-tender/trade, already accounted for) Savings = $17.1M Replace with: Castro $.4M 2B (FA/Prospect) $2M Backup $.5M Spot Starter/Prospect/FA $1M Vlad $13M Total = $16.9M I corrected Pudge's totals (accounting for the deferred) and raised Vlad's yearly pay up $3M. Still saving about 200K and that is projecting the replacements at maximum spending. May save another $1M if worked out right. And we still meet our payroll requirement - or at least HotCorner's projection. Let me know what you think...
  11. Alkazoid, you arent making an effort to see ANYONE's point but your own. Ramp has posted his theoretical payroll to get Vlad. Pretty much everyone has had some version which consisted of shipping off Lee, Castillo, Pudge, Redman, Enc - or some version whereby a couple of them are let go. This is done to free up money and grant us flexibility in order to sign Vlad. That said, I have not been one of the biggest believers in that we are signing Vlad. I have been, however, one of the biggest believers in that we COULD sign Vlad. It is not beyond the realm of possiblity, which is what you propose. We have the payroll flexibility needed to work out a deal for him, and we have a market that could support our needs in filling in for departing players (like the list mentioned above). We even have the players to step in available on our own roster: Castro for Pudge Hooper/Medrano/Valdez or FA for Castillo Choi/Conine for Lee Burnett/Spot starter (Wayne? FA?) for Redman Vlad (of course) for Enc Again, it is not out of the realm of possibility that the Marlins could sign Vlad. Is it likely, probably not - but even that I am hesitant to say because of what happened last year with Pudge. And a Wild Card birth after being 10 games below .500. And us winning the World Series - over the Yankees. And McKeon being Manager of the Year. And Dontrelle Willis becoming ROY... jonnylons: you must be the most obstinate person i've encountered on this entire board. you were probably in my top 3 on another board i used to lurk on. NO s*** we could afford vlad if we made a whole slew of additional cuts. i don't know who you could possibly find to argue such an obvious point with. my whole argument is that it's not prudent to make those cuts because you'd gut the entire core of the team. judging from your brilliant posts, it's obvious you haven't made the slightest effort to see anyone's point of view other than your own vision of vlad, since you continue to spew the same ol' without breaking down the numbers. ramp's theoretical payroll is not an accurate measure of the cuts we'll have to make, and if you can't accept that, you'll have to pardon me for laughing at your call for objectivity here. if you're going to use that as the basis for your argument, i'll stop here. as much as i'd love to outline why those examples aren't realistic, i'd rather just refer you to my post in http://www.marlinbaseball.com/forums/index...showtopic=10168 . it's post #3. if you can break down a roster with realistic figures that can fit vlad in a payroll of $49 million AND you can do it without gutting the team, i'll applaud you. until then, i'll continue to call your vision imprudent and unrealistic. i'll leave it at that. if you really want to continue with this argument, i ask that you read that post #3 before you post. otherwise, i'll continue to believe your viewpoint is "imprudent and unrealistic" and ask that you to be less closeminded before you accuse others of having this same quality. If by obstinate you mean 'difficult to control', then yes, I suppose I am for you. But here is my response - stay with me here: Here is the original post (by Hotcorner): According to my expert figures, I think this saves enough $$ for the Marlins to keep everyone else. They could even up Pudge's offer to 7 million per year. and raise Castillo's offer to 6 million per. Not saying they'd accept the deals, but they'd be more attractive certainly. Hampton 8,000,000 Pudge 10,000,000 Juan Pierre 2,300,000 Castillo 6,000,000 Hee Sop Choi 350,000 Mike Lowell 7,000,000 Alex Gonzalez 2,500,000 Miguel Cabrera 300,000 Jeff Conine 3,000,000 AJ Burnett 2,500,000 Mark Redman 3,000,000 Brad Penny 3,000,000 Josh Beckett 2,100,000 Carl Pavano 2,500,000 Dontrelle Willis 375,000 Braden Looper 3,000,000 Chad Fox 500,000 Spoonybarger 300,000 Tommy Phelps 300,000 Nate Bump 300,000 Michael Tejera 300,000 Mike Redmond 1,100,000 Todd Hollandsworth 1,000,000 Mike Mordecai 300,000 Bench IF 500,000 Brian Banks 300,000 Bench OF 500,000 Total 61,325,000 Just some estimates, & there's still a few holes to fill. Plus they can obviously replace Hollandsworth, Redmond, etc, if they choose. Correct me if you think I'm wrong on these numbers.... maybe I'm mistaken. I'm not saying they should stick with this list, just saying they have the resources to do it if they want to. Here is my response: Ok, I see now. Pudge's salary this year would be $7M + $3M deferred = total $10M. Castillo is making $6M = total $16M. Call me crazy, but I think we would be better off by putting Castro in there (yes, he has to be found innocent) at roughly 300-400K. Then you let Redmond go and replace him with a cheaper backup, around 300-500K. Next, replace Castillo with minor leaguer/FA/prospect. That could be anywhere from 300K-$2M. Then, sign Vlad at about $10M this year, and increase it over the next several years (3 years total?) to get him what he wants financially. It would look something like this: Pudge 10,000,000 Castillo 6,000,000 Redmd 1,100,000 total 17,100,000 Castro 400,000 bckup 500,000 2B 2,000,000 Vlad 10,000,000 total 12,900,000 Still save about $4M AND get, in my opinion, a better team. Vlad is easily the best hitter on this team - put him in the middle of the lineup. Castro could replace Pudge - and even improve in some categories of offense (more power). Find a capable backup, and there are plenty around, for catcher; could even retain Redmond if you chose. There are plenty of options for 2B out there that wont hurt our team either - trade for Roberts (O's), sign Reese, Young, or even work a deal out for Alomar (which I DONT suggest), or possibly go with Medrano/Hooper/Valdez(?). Either way, there is actually a lot of flexibility and this could get done. Remember, that is maximum figures I proposed above, and you could even use the extra money to increase Vlad's pay. Another thought: You could even trade Redman and sign a spot starter for the meantime or bring someone up out of ST (Wayne? Doubt it...but possible). That would save us even more money and not kill this team. So far: Pudge Castillo Lee Encarnacion Redman (?) all gone None would be irreplaceable, in fact, I would think the only one that makes baseball sense to keep is Lee. Everyone else we could find a replacement for. Then some objections: Farmer Fran: why the obssesion with Vlad? The last move basicaly set the table for keeping the OF as Status Quo (Conine, Pierre, Cabrera). Unless we decide to go ahead and trade Lowell. Why change a proven winning combination? With all those moves you suggest, it is pretty much a brand new team. FreshFish: That's what I've been saying for the past month. Keep this team together. We didn't win with high priced superstars. We won with pitching and defense. Let's just say we sign Vlad to a 6 year $15 million contract. What are we going to do when our staff is due to get the big bucks, because you know they will, they're that good. With Vlad's huge contract on our payroll our chance of signing them is slim to none. Keep the team together, we know it's capable of winning, why risk our future with Vlad? And my response: We are not going to sign Vlad to a 6 year deal @ $15M per. We dont believe in long term deals like that - look around at this roster. No one is signed past 2005. 3 years tops per player I think. Vlad will get the same - if he gets a deal it will be deferred anticipating a stadium is built. We deal all those guys I mentioned away because we have capable replacements to step in for cheaper. So if this teams philosophy is winning with pitching and defense, tell me how my proposal effects that? If you are as astute as you believe, you would notice that it only increases our resources of keeping the core of this team together - Beckett, Burnett, Penny, Willis, Cabrera and Lowell.
  12. I would like links to examine these stories myself... It seems too early to tell on anything.? The Shim scenario is pretty much speculative - of course we can expect to contact him after this season.? Why not?? He came here for ST in 2003, but wont be available until 2005.? There is too much in the air about that situation, I think it is safe to say we can expect anything at this point.? No news there. jonnylons, your right about Shim Jong-soo Shim it was just talk with a couple of guys who over heard it talked about once the Choi deal was complete. As for the Maels Rodriguez story I would think you would hear about it or read about it tommorrow. But I would also think there would have to be a link about his defected to El Salvador already??? and quotes from his agent Thanks Ed. I find it interesting that since we traded for a Korean (Choi) now all of a sudden we may be a player in the Korean market. I dont know if this follows or not, but it certainly becomes speculative. Not really let just say the guy that brought up the topic works for the team :whistle BUT I would have to say IMO it was base more on finding ways to make Choi feel more comfortable knowing the possibility of one of his countryman playing with him was a good start I thought that with the guys we had in S.T. last year, we were in the Korean market before Choi came here. I know it had been discussed. One thing is for sure, the Marlins will crawl the planet looking for talent. The fact we are way off in the Korean market I think is good, but from a marketing standpoint a little difficult. Miami is not know for its Asian population... Yes, Gee, you are certainly right to think we are in 'the market' for Korean players considering we had 2 of them (Lee and Shim) here in ST this past year. That said, I think that really put us on the map, but not in the market. Choi certainly gives us some credibility and currency if we are thinking of trying to get these Korean prospects to come here. It is very exciting to see the world involved in baseball though, and I would welcome any players in any market to come here and win. Another place I would like to see us turn to is Europe - especially, believe it or not, Italy. Baseball is growing there, not quite as popular as soccer, bicycling, or maybe basketball, but it is getting there.
  13. Sigh...I just wish people could make their arguments without getting all emotional about it. You, alkazoid, have yet to answer my question. And to add to the confusion, it is you who seems to need a lesson in comprehension. You said: but if you think the guy is almost ready for the big leagues, then i think you're the one posing as an expert. I said that I never said he was ready now. I said by 2005, and I dont see why that is such a longshot given he comes back this season (2004) healthy. He has this whole offseason to get back into shape and get the rest he needs. But you said: you said he'd be ready by 2005, and i later responded by saying i'm not so sure of that considering his injury and very poor progress. i questioned you for making projections since you questioned me for "posing" as an "expert." i never accused you of saying "he is ready to play now," so i'll ask that you work on reading for comprehension before you make your arguments. If you never said that I said he is ready to play now, then what do you mean? Because now would indicate opening day, 2004, and you didnt accuse me of that. When at the earliest, you could argue that I said opening day 2005 - because I said 2005 Stokes will be ready. So if you didnt say that I said he was ready to play now, than what exactly are you trying to say? It would seem, seem if you could get around YOUR hurt ego, that you would agree with me. Because if you arent saying he is ready now, and neither am I, then you have to agree that in the future he will be ready - which I have said as much too. We both dont think he is ready to play in the big leagues this upcoming season - 2004. Fact. So tell me, what are you trying to say? What are you disagreeing with here? The other point that you made, in which you have yet to really answer, is regarding Stokes vs. Gonzalez. You seem to think that his 2003 ranking is not right because it should (you feel) have him ranked lower than Gonzalez due to Stokes' injury. That might be so, but I dont think you have given a good look at stats: Gonzalez: 449ABs 121H (.269AVG) 20 2B, 4 3B, 5HR, 51RBI, 39BB, 77K Stokes: 462ABs 119H (.258AVG) 31 2B, 3 3B, 17HR, 89RBI, 36BB, 135K Tell me, are you wanting to rank AD Gon higher because of less K's? Ok, that is your choice...but make an argument and use stats not just to disprove a point, but to prove a point. The stats for Stokes and Gonzalez are similar except in 3 basic areas - K's, 2B's and HRs. All of which Stokes has a lot more of than Gonzalez. So again, I disagree with you - Stokes had an off year, but due to injury and still was able to rebound with a solid performance. That said, I dont see why his ranking in '03 should be any lower than '02 because no one surpassed him - including especially Gonzalez (who had to get demoted from AAA by the way).
  14. 3 @ $13M per is very good. But I seriously doubt that the Boss will stand pat - there are going to be some ramifications. It may not effect us directly, but it will effect the market and should effect us in some way.
  15. Schilling traded to the Red Sux makes me think of one thing: Steinbrenner's big wallet. Does this mean now that FA's everywhere will start clamoring for NYC in order to get a big contract - or perhaps drive up the prices of their peers'? It seems so, at least in my mind. Red Sux and Yanks offseasons are comparable to the US - USSR Cold War years. It isnt how they perform so much as who they get that is important in most cases. Schilling is going to cause the Yankees to counter - which could drive up prices for FA's like Castillo (whom, as far as I know, has not been contacted by the Yanks but by the Mutts) and even Vlad (whom some think we are in the running for and I would stress he wont sign with NY but will probably use them to price his contract). Also, Colon may be a target as well as Vazquez but that could help us in the value assigned to a guy like Redman - who we may be looking to trade to free up money. What do you guys think?
  16. I would like links to examine these stories myself... It seems too early to tell on anything.? The Shim scenario is pretty much speculative - of course we can expect to contact him after this season.? Why not?? He came here for ST in 2003, but wont be available until 2005.? There is too much in the air about that situation, I think it is safe to say we can expect anything at this point.? No news there. jonnylons, your right about Shim Jong-soo Shim it was just talk with a couple of guys who over heard it talked about once the Choi deal was complete. As for the Maels Rodriguez story I would think you would hear about it or read about it tommorrow. But I would also think there would have to be a link about his defected to El Salvador already??? and quotes from his agent Thanks Ed. I find it interesting that since we traded for a Korean (Choi) now all of a sudden we may be a player in the Korean market. I dont know if this follows or not, but it certainly becomes speculative.
  17. Alkazoid, you arent making an effort to see ANYONE's point but your own. Ramp has posted his theoretical payroll to get Vlad. Pretty much everyone has had some version which consisted of shipping off Lee, Castillo, Pudge, Redman, Enc - or some version whereby a couple of them are let go. This is done to free up money and grant us flexibility in order to sign Vlad. That said, I have not been one of the biggest believers in that we are signing Vlad. I have been, however, one of the biggest believers in that we COULD sign Vlad. It is not beyond the realm of possiblity, which is what you propose. We have the payroll flexibility needed to work out a deal for him, and we have a market that could support our needs in filling in for departing players (like the list mentioned above). We even have the players to step in available on our own roster: Castro for Pudge Hooper/Medrano/Valdez or FA for Castillo Choi/Conine for Lee Burnett/Spot starter (Wayne? FA?) for Redman Vlad (of course) for Enc Again, it is not out of the realm of possibility that the Marlins could sign Vlad. Is it likely, probably not - but even that I am hesitant to say because of what happened last year with Pudge. And a Wild Card birth after being 10 games below .500. And us winning the World Series - over the Yankees. And McKeon being Manager of the Year. And Dontrelle Willis becoming ROY...
  18. Starks put that non sense out there too. I seriously doubt Cabrera will be a 1B - that would be a waste of his athletic talent. We already have his big bat - he is more valuable playing a position in which it is a little more difficult to get offensive production. OF is pretty good for that purpose, and with Conine and Choi, we got 1B covered. Our needs now are the bullpen, re-signing Castillo (or a replacment), extending Lowell's years here, and fixing the catching situation. Not listed in any particular order...
  19. Adrian did not get a jump, I dont think he is projected to hit anywhere near 30 homeruns like both these hitters - Stokes and Choi - DID. If Choi works out, and I think he will, watch for Stokes to play RF.? Then, in '05 - Cabrera LF, Pierre CF, Stokes RF.? Conine, 4th OF/platoon/1B?? Gives us more options... dude, the ranking is old. you honestly think adrian is only the #6 1st baseman now that we know who has taken a dip? if that's the case, i'd love to have a taste of your crippy. oh yeah, and jason stokes was, by far, the worst hitter on his team during the fall league. Stokes, Jason, 1B: .145 Avg, 18 G, 62 AB, 5 R, 9 H, 1 2B, 1 3B, 2 HR, 5 RBI, 1 BB, 22 SO, 1 SB, 0 CS, .290 SLG, .169 OBP, 4 E he strikes out more than 35% of the time and has only 9 hits and ONE walk in 63 on plate appearances for a miserable .169 OBP. oh yeah, and he can't field for s***. tell me he's the #3 prospect 1b out there... geez. i'll be surprised if he's ready by 2005. Well, I hope you enjoy the taste. Because let me ask you a question, since you want to pose as an expert here. Look at Stokes stats in '02 then look at his stats in '03. Then, consider that his wrist injury was significant, that he may have rushed himself back and was perhaps, never totally healthy. As the season went on, he tried to compensate, but couldnt. Then the AFL followed, he still hadnt rested, but in fact was fatigued even more because of this whole past season of struggling and compensating and not being healthy. Then tell me, where does he project? If you think AD Gonzalez projects better than Stokes, fine - say it now so in 2005 when Gonzalez is batting .280 with minimal pop and Stokes is launching balls off the yard you can eat my 'told you so'. Was Stokes terrible this past year, he was bad, yes. But I think you dont go from the level of production to where he went this past season without an injury. And look at Choi's numbers and tell me honestly you think AD Gon's are better. You are being ridiculous. Patience... And, havent you considered the reason why his 2002 ranking is listed is to show how he has moved up/down in 2003 vs. 2002? In other words, Stokes is exactly in the same spot of the rankings that he was in '02 despite his 'terrible' numbers at the time. But I think that these writers gave credence to the effects of his wrist injury. how am i posing like an expert? i said stokes sucked during the AFL and i backed it up with numbers. his 2002 ranking is listed as REFERENCE. there is a reason why they precede the word "ranking" with the word "2002". the text in that profile is also old and had high hopes for 2003. the purpose of my post was to point out that the 2002 rankings were not accurate rankings of 1B since both Stokes and Choi have dipped in stock significantly this year. the 2002 rankings were before their injuries! i also pointed out that i doubt that stokes would be ready by 2005 (after one season), ESPECIALLY considering his injury and his extremely poor play of late. no s*** he'll be good someday; i never said that wasn't the case. but if you think the guy is almost ready for the big leagues, then i think you're the one posing as an expert. i don't know how my pointing out the obvious means i am "posing like an expert", but it's definitely better than someone making farfetched projections of a guy's readiness while disregarding injury and poor play. if a ranking is made before a guy's serious injury, how hard is it to believe that he probably wouldn't be ranked as high today? if someone is a poser for pointing that out, then i'll gladly have to accept my poserness. Umm...try reading my posts on another thread that discussed Stoke's wrist injury. Then come back and make accusations about me saying he is ready to play now. What I got from your rambling was that Adrian Gonzalez should be ranked higher than Stokes. I think you are wrong, if I interpreted you correctly. And you are wrong, if that is the case - because NEVER, EVER has AD Gon put up the numbers at ANY level that Stokes OR Choi HAVE. If you have anything to say beyond that, you are starting your own, new argument. If I misunderstood you, then take into consideration that you are not clear about what you are saying. Have a point...and stick to it.
  20. if only people would be aware of what a player does aside from the stat sheet. *sigh* yeah, geez...
  21. I would like links to examine these stories myself... It seems too early to tell on anything. The Shim scenario is pretty much speculative - of course we can expect to contact him after this season. Why not? He came here for ST in 2003, but wont be available until 2005. There is too much in the air about that situation, I think it is safe to say we can expect anything at this point. No news there.
  22. Adrian did not get a jump, I dont think he is projected to hit anywhere near 30 homeruns like both these hitters - Stokes and Choi - DID. If Choi works out, and I think he will, watch for Stokes to play RF.? Then, in '05 - Cabrera LF, Pierre CF, Stokes RF.? Conine, 4th OF/platoon/1B?? Gives us more options... dude, the ranking is old. you honestly think adrian is only the #6 1st baseman now that we know who has taken a dip? if that's the case, i'd love to have a taste of your crippy. oh yeah, and jason stokes was, by far, the worst hitter on his team during the fall league. Stokes, Jason, 1B: .145 Avg, 18 G, 62 AB, 5 R, 9 H, 1 2B, 1 3B, 2 HR, 5 RBI, 1 BB, 22 SO, 1 SB, 0 CS, .290 SLG, .169 OBP, 4 E he strikes out more than 35% of the time and has only 9 hits and ONE walk in 63 on plate appearances for a miserable .169 OBP. oh yeah, and he can't field for s***. tell me he's the #3 prospect 1b out there... geez. i'll be surprised if he's ready by 2005. Well, I hope you enjoy the taste. Because let me ask you a question, since you want to pose as an expert here. Look at Stokes stats in '02 then look at his stats in '03. Then, consider that his wrist injury was significant, that he may have rushed himself back and was perhaps, never totally healthy. As the season went on, he tried to compensate, but couldnt. Then the AFL followed, he still hadnt rested, but in fact was fatigued even more because of this whole past season of struggling and compensating and not being healthy. Then tell me, where does he project? If you think AD Gonzalez projects better than Stokes, fine - say it now so in 2005 when Gonzalez is batting .280 with minimal pop and Stokes is launching balls off the yard you can eat my 'told you so'. Was Stokes terrible this past year, he was bad, yes. But I think you dont go from the level of production to where he went this past season without an injury. And look at Choi's numbers and tell me honestly you think AD Gon's are better. You are being ridiculous. Patience... And, havent you considered the reason why his 2002 ranking is listed is to show how he has moved up/down in 2003 vs. 2002? In other words, Stokes is exactly in the same spot of the rankings that he was in '02 despite his 'terrible' numbers at the time. But I think that these writers gave credence to the effects of his wrist injury.
  23. Alright, I am confused. If Castillo is "set" to sign with us, why does this article say that he's searching for more options? For one thing you have to consider the source of the information that Castillo is "set" to sign. It was Berardino. He's on the outs with the Marlins, and has no dependable source of info there, so he's always quoted unknown baseball sources, and is frequently wrong. Very frequently. I don't know why more people aren't catching on the the fact that Berardino is a lousy reporter. Just because someone can get an article published doesn't mean he always knows what he's talking about. I repeat, he frequently doesn't. At any rate, there is no advantage for Castillo to sign until he has to. Unless the fish attach an ultimatum deadline prior to Dec 7th he can continue to gauge the market, and even if he wants to stay, he can weigh that into his negotiations. If the Sox and the Yankees both want him, someone will overpay. This is the kind of situation where a player's agent sometimes overplays his hand and winds up closing the door on the team the player reallywants to play with, for a few more dollars. I really don't see Luis thriving in the big apple, and he's probalby not an ideal leadoff man for Fenway, especially if you already have Johnny Damon. Yes, I agree. Another indication is why would the Marlins give Castillo a 4th year option if he was 'close' to signing? The Marlins had to up the deal to make it more competitive for what Castillo is looking for. He is the best (stastically) 2B on the market. We are going to have to pay for it - I am not sure this is good value, but we will see. But yes, Castillo may be closer to signing with us, but this is not a done deal - yet. I do think he will sign sooner rather than later. People may begin to speculate about his hip and drive his price down at ANY given moment.
  24. Wow, you mean we can't afford Vlad? This is a very sudden shock I must say. its funy how jonny posted his salary thing u ppl sho less confidence now. 1st of all u maybe can squeese him in at 13 mill a yr insted of going 1--12-16-22 like jony says. 2nd of al he might not want to go to california and acept our deal for less $ cuz of his mom or somthing. plus we got the guy who sign him outta DR. u ppl just change ur minds bak and forth and never give good reason to belive vlad will cum. u jus say "oh we will get vlad, i dunno how but we will!!!" :banghead yeah, i was really hoping for inspired responses to my post. The only one I got was Pubes. Despite my post, I still think Vlad could be coming here. I think the market is being tested/set. Vlad is going to make his decision, and it wont be totally based on money. He is not going to California, I am sorry. Too far away from what he feels is his home. For that, he would just go to Baltimore and get the money Anaheim is offering. But I feel he REALLY wants to come here - and Loria may pull another 'special money' deal for him. You cant say it is out of the realm of possibility because how many of us here thought Pudge was coming here? In fact, there were really no indications that he was - no public discussions and we appeared to not have the money. Sound familiar? Granted, indications point to Vlad not coming here, but I cant help but feel otherwise - and I have tried to dismiss this for the reasons the nay-sayers are: no money, no public talks/rumors. I think right now, Florida could be #1 on the list and Vlad's agent is trying to get other suitors just to have options. Sounds like me and my grad school choices...
  25. jonnylons replied to G.C.0806's topic in Miami Marlins
    I'm guessing he will have a good future with us plus he has some pop. yep.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.