Everything posted by dim
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
They can't/won't trade Nicolino, he's Heaney's replacement as our next major league ready starter. First off...that makes me mildly sad... Second, they can most certainly trade Nicolino. We still have Urena/German/Williams/Disco/Conley/Kolek in the system under this scenario. It's not ideal but we could get by without Nicolino. That said if we're in "now" mode you need to trade 2nd tier pitcher like Nicolino (aka a #3 or 4 starting pitcher at best) for a guy like Morneau at a crucial position. Jose is signed to 2019, Cosart isn't a free agent until 2020, Alvarez isn't a free agent until after 2018, Eovaldi isn't a free agent until after 2018, and Koehler isn't a free agent until after 2019. Basically, if we want to keep all of these guys they are all signed to the team for another four years. At the very least it feels like Jose and Alvarez are good bets to be consistently good, Eovaldi has the stuff to bounce back to a #3, Cosart even at his worst at Marlins Park is a #4/5, and Koehler is improving. I think this team could definitely get by trading Nicolino barring injuries. There are a few college pitchers we just drafted this year (Mader/Holmes off the top of my head) that look really good and can move up the system quickly. Basically I'm saying the long term success of the team isn't hurt by trading Nicolino. The short term success of the team IS hurt by not trading for Morneau.
-
Winter Meetings 2014
If all it cost to get Morneau was Adam Conley or Anthony Desclafani this deal would be done already. That's a really low price for somebody who batted over .300 with an .840 OPS away from Coors Field last year. THAT is the kind of short term thinking deal that would actually be worth it. Morneau is better than Morse, and if all it cost to get him was a Disco or Conley I'd do that trade a thousand times over signing Morse. The biggest reason I was against that trade originally was because I thought it would cost Heaney. I honestly believe the discussion involves Eovaldi. Disco or Conley is way too little for a decent 1st baseman nowadays.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
Keep in mind there was a report that the Dodgers asked for Nicolino over Heaney and Marlins said no... Both of those things should tell us something. I'd like to imagine that rumor is BS perpetuated by Marlins personnel to try and bump up the value of Nicolino in a potential Morneau trade.
-
Winter Meetings 2014
He's not that hot This picture disagrees
-
Winter Meetings 2014
I have no idea what we have to give for Morneau. I'm guessing Eovaldi? That's taking away an asset at one position to gain at another. I don't think the Marlins would trade Nicolino for him. After that I have no idea what the Rockies would want from us.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
The lesson tomorrow is gonna be "Debating the Dee Gordon Trade 101" Every student on the test is given a grade of 'D+", since that's what we got in the trade.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
That is definitely the part that decides the trade. Hernandez/Barnes/Hatcher are all MLB players but none of them are real game changers at the MLB level. Heaney's the only guy with potential #2 starter stuff. But his stuff at the major league level was incredibly bad, and there's was nothing that showed why he was so good in the minors and why he was such a highly regarded prospect at one point last year (#1 lefty pitching prospect in ALL OF BASEBALL). I'm just frustrated they traded so low on Heaney, but in the Marlins eyes I see the front office thinking they got value for him before he fell off to where he has little value at all. It's the exact same argument we all had here when the Marlins traded Moran for Cosart and Co. That trade so far has worked out great for us, and while I've said Dee's lack of walking ability is a truth the Marlins seem to be ignoring, I said before and I'll say now that he's a very useful player to have at the majors next season and is a real improvement over Solano (improvement over Hernandez is to be determined). The whole "shit in the air" comment was clearly a joke and I see Gordon being a fun player to follow all next season. If his OBP was ever in the .340-350's I'd feel so much better about this trade. I'm cool with wait and see mode. But Heaney was our last real trade asset. Despite what the Marlins think, Nicolino doesn't have the kind of value in the open market that Heaney would've had if they didn't diminish it by making it quite clear just how much they wanted to get rid of him. It's not so much the return. It's not that I see Heaney becoming Clayton Kershaw. It's that we might have one of the worst farm systems in all of baseball now with no real guarantee of a playoff spot or even a winning record next season. It's pretty much the front office, in their own minds, going all in next season. It just feels like it's going about it all wrong, selling everything and the kitchen sink for somebody's who career (and his second half of the season) doesn't match his "All Star" first half.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
This deal really needs to play out before we make any judgements. As of right now there is a LOT still in the air. Someone must've farted because it smells like shit in that air.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
His metrics in limited time last year were great. He often came into games late as a defensive replacement for Hanley. He makes Hech look like Tulo with the bat though. Yeah he posted a 1.0 WAR in 149 AB's while posting .463 OPS. Either his defense is really really good or I've been reading WAR wrong for quite some time.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
That dodger lineup is kinda ugly LOL can't talk sh*t when their lineup is pretty equal to ours if not a bit better.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
This is just a cheap organization being cheap. Yeah...it sounds to me like it was basically Heaney/Hernandez for Gordon and Barnes/Hatcher for the $12 million that Loria will pocket for Haren NOT to play for us (aka get Haren out of their hair). Will that money be redistributed back into the team? LOL that's a funny question. Although I do see some of that money going towards a contract for Morse if he chooses us over San Francisco.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
For the record, Dee Gordon's nickname HAS to be Steals McDee. Trade worth it now. This comment is gold Jerry. GOLD
-
Winter Meetings 2014
Bob Nightengale @BNightengale The Miami #Marlins and Texas #Rangers are now in active trade talks with the #Dbacks for Wade Miley after talks stalled with #Redsox. I don't know how much of the farm system we have left over to give in a trade for Miley.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
I can't get over that Gordon hit worse than Hechavarria the second half of last season. It's the same damn criticism we've had about McGehee and we've had people rationalizing it for Gordon because he's fast. It's Bonifacio all over with better base stealing ability. The only difference is we gave up our top prospect, a top 10 prospect in Barnes, and two starters last season in Hernandez and Hatcher to get him.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
Yeah...think some of you guys are doing the opposite of what you're saying the FO is doing, overvaluing our own prospects and undervaluing other team prospects. I do agree we gave up a bit much, but it's not as bad as some are saying. I'm just thinking in two years we've essentially traded our 2012 and 2013 first round draft picks for Jarred Cosart and Dee Gordon. In a bubble you could say we turned two first round picks into a starting pitcher and a starting 2nd baseman in the majors, which isn't all that awful. I just think when you're draft 6th and 9th that you want those picks to turn into cornerstone pieces of your team. I can't say Cosart and Gordon are key pieces of a championship caliber team. But then again top draft picks can easily bust out, so whatever. Hernandez/Barnes/Hatcher are casualties on the side of turning draft picks into major leaguers. On the small scale trading Heaney and Co. for Gordon/Haren doesn't seem all that good (although if Haren for whatever reason chooses to play for us and we're paying him nothing that deal gets a lot better), but in terms of turning assets into majors leaguers NOW the front office did alright. The problem is I don't see this team as a playoff team next year as currently constructed. Their on the verge, but there not in position to trade future pieces for a "Now" run, since that Now run is more likely an 80 to 85 win season. I don't want to look back and see Heaney being a great #2 starter and Hernandez is starting at 2B for somebody with Barnes doing his thing somewhere and being like "Those guys would look great in Marlins jerseys right now".
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
So if/when Haren retires, Loria just got $10 million for keepsies. nah dawg.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
With the inclusion of hatcher and kiké Marlins may have been looking to open spots for the Rule V draft as well They should go after that Mark Canha guy he would fit well with this team.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
What does that even mean.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
Dee Gordon posted a .648 OPS the second half of the season. For reference Adeiny Hechavarria posted a .688 OPS in the second half of the season. Literally Hechavarria was a better hitter than Gordon to end last season. I think I hate this trade more than I hated it twenty minutes ago, and I really hated it then.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
I'll be super thankful if Haren threatens to retire and torpedoes this deal. It just blows my mind that you would add players to a deal to trade for a guy who has made it pretty clear he will retire if you trade for him. Unbelievable. It won't derail the deal. It'll just force the Marlins to find another team to trade Haren to similar to when we traded Yunel Escobar to the Jays for Dietrich.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
Fun fact. Dee Gordon walked just four times in the entire second half of last season. FOUR TIMES. For reference there have been just over 100 players in MLB history that have walked 5 times...in a single game.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
Frisario says its Gordon & Haren and 1 minor leaguer for Heaney, Hatcher, Barnes, Hernandez. I mean was Gordon for Heaney not enough?? Jesus. The frustrating thing is this exactly. It feels a little lopsided with just a 1 for 1 trade of Heaney for Gordon. I think we all would've accepted this trade since we've pretty much accepted the Marlins view Heaney less than they did in June and probably helped to kill his trade value through talks. We all would've liked Gordon and thought Heaney was a bit high but we were fine since it would've fit a big need and helped form the lineup. But we gave up Hernandez, which basically would've been Gordon's insurance plan and an insurance plan for a few positions since he's versatile (and a decent hitter too). Barnes was probably a year away from the majors but he's a pretty good hitter every step of the minors and the Marlins never seemed to view him properly (as an example he posted a .900+ OPS in a short time in Jacksonville after getting called up...only to be sent back down to Jupiter for doing so soon after.) And Hatcher we all know about given last season. It's frustrating since it feels like a desperation trade where Hill/Jennings felt like they HAD to leave the meetings with something and Friedman was toying with them that idea, and finally it feels like they caved. It doesn't feel like we got even close to the best offer we possibly could have. And we also traded a lot of useful players. #1 overall prospect, our starting 2B to end last year, our 7th inning guy last season, and a potential good utility guy and another potential starting 2B/backup catcher in 2016. You don't replace that kind of ability with Dee Gordon and whatever minor leaguer we get on the side (and maybe Dan Haren, but who the hell knows what's going on with that).
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
Barnes was not going find any playing time here. they're sold on Salty and Realmuto Barnes plays 2B too. He's capable of playing a few positions actually. That isn't the issue. If we wanted to we could've found a spot for Barnes. It's annoying how we sold super low on literally four players.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
This is all of course everyone assuming that we're done after this trade. We don't know. Really Heaney is the only real piece we gave up, and its not a small piece either. That's BS. Hernandez was set to be our starting 2B and he's actually pretty useful outside his so so first stint with the Marlins. When not accounting for stolen bases he could definitely surpass Gordon in total WAR and other statistics next season. Barnes is an undervalued player in our system and should probably be in AAA and possibly even the majors already. At the very least he's a very useful utility guy. Hatcher was one of the keys of our bullpen last season surprisingly and we know that it can be damn hard to find a consistent bullpen guy at times. We gave up value. Not A+ value outside of Heaney but solid B value with each player having a future in the majors next year. Even if Haren plays next year that's a lot of money to pay for a pitcher like him, and if he retires like he said he would it is just embarrassing for the team. Gordon is a decent addition, but this is the kind of thing that I was afraid of happening. The Marlins buying high on other teams players and selling low on their own players. They also need to learn to stop dealing with good GM's like Dombrowski and Friedman. If they're willing to take a deal from us it probably means we're getting f*cked in the butt.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
I can't believe how much Heaney's trade value fell off in the eyes of our front office. I can't believe how much Kike Hernandez's value fell of with our front office (he was the other major piece outside of Cosart and basically gave up Jake Marisnick to get him/Wates). I can't believe they NEEDED to give up Barnes on top of everything else to get him, although the Dodgers will probably value Barnes higher and use him properly since I trust in Friedman to do the right thing. I don't trust Hill to not undervalue our own players. The Marlins do this way too often. They undervalue their own players, sell them off when there value may be lowest and buy high on players who are bound for a dose of reality soon enough. I'm not saying Dee Gordon will become a replacement player, but that's a hell of a list of players to give up for a guy who can't even OPS .750.