May 25, 200422 yr Marriage is putting a ring on someones finger and telling them you will be with them the rest of your life. That's a very simple right all people are entitled to.
May 25, 200422 yr Letting gays marry wouldn't have anything to do with me. Gays are people, they have the same rights as everyone else, they just can't marry. People are so quick to change things not thinking about the consequences. If you change marriage now, then what stops radical changes in the future??? It's a never ending chain of events, and no, change doesn't always mean progress. Martha Burke can't play at the Masters, Gays can't marry. That's the way it's always been, that's the way it should stay. Why must we always change things? And that's the way I see it. Call me hard headed, closed minded, whatever. If you can't accept that's the way I see it then you yourself are being closed minded.
May 25, 200422 yr Marriage is putting a ring on someones finger and telling them you will be with them the rest of your life. That's a very simple right all people are entitled to. Yes it is. But do they have to call it marriage and do it in a church or anywhere else for that matter. No, they don't have to.
May 25, 200422 yr actually marriage is not a right the taxation issues associated with marriage along with dual filings and such are the rights.
May 25, 200422 yr actually marriage is not a right the taxation issues associated with marriage along with dual filings and such are the rights. Yes, and we should just reform those things.
May 25, 200422 yr Letting gays marry wouldn't have anything to do with me. Gays are people, they have the same rights as everyone else, they just can't marry. People are so quick to change things not thinking about the consequences. If you change marriage now, then what stops radical changes in the future??? It's a never ending chain of events, and no, change doesn't always mean progress. Martha Burke can't play at the Masters, Gays can't marry. That's the way it's always been, that's the way it should stay. Why must we always change things? And that's the way I see it. Call me hard headed, closed minded, whatever. If you can't accept that's the way I see it then you yourself are being closed minded. Now you have cornered yourself into the argument: it will open the door to bad things. Sorry, that does not justify ridding people of a right they are entitled to. That's like saying "if we give women the right to vote, we will have to give pets the right to vote next, arg!" Seriously, after gay marriage, what other issues are there to deal with?
May 25, 200422 yr Detroit you make a solid argument and in the end its a matter of opinion. as a libretarian i am against the theory that allowing somehting will open the door to allowing more and more things, which is an argument used for legalization as well.
May 25, 200422 yr for a second I thought you said "As a librarian." In the end, what can gay marriage lead to? Polygamy? But that already exists. Marriage to animals? Well, that is and will remain illegal. I see no further logical consequences.
May 25, 200422 yr Its funny that we (soriano and I) have been arguing about this we are both for gay marriage just for different ways of getting to the same end.
May 25, 200422 yr Will one of you pro gay-marriage people tell me how we are going to pay for it? You cannot be seriously concerned about finances when you support the 200+ billion war for Iraq.
May 25, 200422 yr Its funny that we (soriano and I) have been arguing about this we are both for gay marriage just for different ways of getting to the same end. I understand, but I'm telling you, it is a matter of principle!
May 25, 200422 yr Its interesting that people complain about the cost of the iraq war when we spend 5 or 6 times that amount of money a year on outdated entitlements such as many of the social welfare programs and certain public education programs which keep getting money pumped into them after 40+ years of ineffectiveness
May 25, 200422 yr 1. It isn't rights alone, otherwise you would support calling one man's vote different from another's. 2. I'm mostly a libertarian besides when it comes to education. Sadly, if we were to trust the people with paying for their kids education, we would have a more efficient and effective system, but people are stupid and the rich would get smart and bring their kids to school and the poor would do the opposite. Kind of like now, but worse. Medicare, social security, congressional and executive staffs, regulatory bureaucracies...those are BY FAR the largest wastes of money and need to go. I already have a solution for education: bussing
May 25, 200422 yr Letting gays marry wouldn't have anything to do with me. Gays are people, they have the same rights as everyone else, they just can't marry. People are so quick to change things not thinking about the consequences. If you change marriage now, then what stops radical changes in the future??? It's a never ending chain of events, and no, change doesn't always mean progress. Martha Burke can't play at the Masters, Gays can't marry. That's the way it's always been, that's the way it should stay. Why must we always change things? And that's the way I see it. Call me hard headed, closed minded, whatever. If you can't accept that's the way I see it then you yourself are being closed minded. Now you have cornered yourself into the argument: it will open the door to bad things. Sorry, that does not justify ridding people of a right they are entitled to. That's like saying "if we give women the right to vote, we will have to give pets the right to vote next, arg!" Seriously, after gay marriage, what other issues are there to deal with? In the case of women to vote, there had to be change there. The true opinion of ALL of America wasn't being voiced. Same with Black being able to vote. Yes, it could lead to pets having the right to vote, but that's not logical, now is it? After gay marriage there are many things to deal with in terms of the structure of marriage. Things that all of the extreme anti-gay marriage people are comparing gay marriage to. Polygamy and such. There's no denying it. We change marriage once, we can change it again, and again, and again. If it's not broke, don't fix it.
May 25, 200422 yr So you are taking the position cangelosi is taking? Give them all the rights of marriage but call it something else? If thats not what your saying then the alternative is something that is "broke."
May 25, 200422 yr In a way, yes. Give them the insurance, tax benefits, blah blah blah. The symbol of marriage is not broke. Straights can do it, gays can't. Leave it that way.
May 25, 200422 yr In a way, yes. Give them the insurance, tax benefits, blah blah blah. The symbol of marriage is not broke. Straights can do it, gays can't. Leave it that way. Do you think marriage has deterioted to a laughingstock of an institution without the influence of gays? Whats it a symbol for?
May 25, 200422 yr In a way, yes.? Give them the insurance, tax benefits, blah blah blah. The symbol of marriage is not broke.? Straights can do it, gays can't.? Leave it that way. Do you think marriage has deterioted to a laughingstock of an institution without the influence of gays? Whats it a symbol for? Yes, and that's a whole different issue. Marriage (in America) is a symbol of a man and a woman committing their lives to each other till death do them part.
May 25, 200422 yr In a way, yes. Give them the insurance, tax benefits, blah blah blah. The symbol of marriage is not broke. Straights can do it, gays can't. Leave it that way. Screw the symbolism, that's not the problem. They can call it whatever they want, as long as they do not receive the same health care, bennies, etc... that a married couple can. Besides, isn't this all about love and enduring companionship, not creating eligibility for spousal benefits?
May 25, 200422 yr In a way, yes. Give them the insurance, tax benefits, blah blah blah. The symbol of marriage is not broke. Straights can do it, gays can't. Leave it that way. Screw the symbolism, that's not the problem. They can call it whatever they want, as long as they do not receive the same health care, bennies, etc... that a married couple can. Besides, isn't this all about love and enduring companionship, not creating eligibility for spousal benefits? :lol That should get a response.
May 25, 200422 yr In a way, yes.? Give them the insurance, tax benefits, blah blah blah. The symbol of marriage is not broke.? Straights can do it, gays can't.? Leave it that way. Screw the symbolism, that's not the problem. They can call it whatever they want, as long as they do not receive the same health care, bennies, etc... that a married couple can. Besides, isn't this all about love and enduring companionship, not creating eligibility for spousal benefits? :lol That should get a response. :whistle Actually I'm not trying to troll, just venting a bit. I am so sick and tired of other people trying to come up with new and inventive ways to tax me more and make my cost of living higher. Gay marriage this, free healthcare that. Where TF you think all this money comes from, for chrissake's? Who is going to shoulder that burden? Can't someone just go out and actually earn a f*ucking living and pay for services instead of pandering for it. God I am pissed.
May 25, 200422 yr In a way, yes. Give them the insurance, tax benefits, blah blah blah. The symbol of marriage is not broke. Straights can do it, gays can't. Leave it that way. The symbol. That's a symbol in a limited amount of people's minds and you know in time it will change anyway. Why continue the oppression?
May 25, 200422 yr Besides, isn't this all about love and enduring companionship, not creating eligibility for spousal benefits? Then lets give no benefits to straights, that's even cheaper! If you don't support that in particular fish you either hate gays or you are a hypocrite...or both. That's like saying a company can pay out health insurance to its employess only if they are black, because it is cheaper just to have insurance for blacks than for everyone else, like asians, arabs, whites, and ect. I'm sorry, but that is just stupid. Give benefits to everyone that deserves it or give it to no one.
May 25, 200422 yr In a way, yes. Give them the insurance, tax benefits, blah blah blah. The symbol of marriage is not broke. Straights can do it, gays can't. Leave it that way. The symbol. That's a symbol in a limited amount of people's minds and you know in time it will change anyway. Why continue the oppression? haha...funny. Limited amount of people's minds. Ok. Not letting gays marry is hardly oppression. The fact that they can't get life insurance policies, etc. is not good, I agree. The fact that they can't marry doesn't change anything. I'm stopping here, because I'm tired of repeating myself. Apparently my english teachers have all been failures because I haven't presented my opinion well enough.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.