January 20, 200521 yr All I wonder is where does one get these intangibles? Can you buy them? What store did LoDuca and Lenny Harris buy theirs at (certainly not the same as Mike Redmond and Mike Mordecai)? Are they compatiable with other franchises? Because I read Pudge had a brand that did not work until he moved into the Marlins and Tigers' clubhouse; and that Pierzynski guy's intangibles shortcircuited when he moved into the geriatric clubhouse of San Francisco. Or do you have to you earn them? I don't know about the rest of you, but I would work real hard to be a average catcher offensively and below-average defensively, subjecting myself to the whims of an organization, to get a $2 million raise despite no clear improvement over the past year and a disturbing future career track. Cash money.
January 20, 200521 yr we should've went after AJ that being said, we had to have a quality backstop 661076[/snapback] Not really. The offensive production from Willingham, Delgado and platoon in rightfield would have supplied enough to offset their defensive liabilities, atleast for the regular season. The same for a good-field no-hit shortstop, catcher, etc. As long as you are adequately stocked at other positions you can take the risk.
January 21, 200521 yr we should've went after AJ that being said, we had to have a quality backstop 661076[/snapback] Not really. The offensive production from Willingham, Delgado and platoon in rightfield would have supplied enough to offset their defensive liabilities, atleast for the regular season. The same for a good-field no-hit shortstop, catcher, etc. As long as you are adequately stocked at other positions you can take the risk. 661097[/snapback] we'd need to get delgado first if we get him, then this signing goes from questionable to totally unnecessary in my mind i think they should've went to arby with him and signed him later, that way if we did get delgado, we could free up some cash by letting him go
January 21, 200521 yr there are reasons people only give him 2 mil a year.. because nobody wants him. i have a lot of friends who are white sox fans and NONE of them like the signing we already have 2 'emotionally fragile' pitchers... the last thing we need is a catcher like Pierzynski for them. 660739[/snapback] really?.... all my White Sox fans love the signing... They havent had a decent hitting catcher since before Ron Karkovice was there 660745[/snapback] Miguel Olivo?
January 21, 200521 yr we should've went after AJ that being said, we had to have a quality backstop 661076[/snapback] Not really. The offensive production from Willingham, Delgado and platoon in rightfield would have supplied enough to offset their defensive liabilities, atleast for the regular season. The same for a good-field no-hit shortstop, catcher, etc. As long as you are adequately stocked at other positions you can take the risk. 661097[/snapback] No no No, we cannot risk a liability behind the plate like we did last year. Willingham cannot be our starting catcher. Then we have to run the risk of trading for another one at the break and lose more prospects. Keeping lo duca is a good idea, solid catcher, much better than just average offensively, and a much better alternative than willingham/treanor. This team as it is now is stacked. We are solid at every position. We cannot afford a question mark behind the plate like we did last year.
January 21, 200521 yr Well, Samson said himself yesterday that "The Marlins cannot afford to sign players that will not potentially perform up to what they are being paid." Lo Duca will never be a $6 Million per player.
January 21, 200521 yr Wild Card and Ramp, was the 8 mil (7 for him, 1 for salary, yes I know before someone tries to play semantics) salary for Al Leiter fair?
January 21, 200521 yr Author there are reasons people only give him 2 mil a year.. because nobody wants him. i have a lot of friends who are white sox fans and NONE of them like the signing we already have 2 'emotionally fragile' pitchers... the last thing we need is a catcher like Pierzynski for them. 660739[/snapback] really?.... all my White Sox fans love the signing... They havent had a decent hitting catcher since before Ron Karkovice was there 660745[/snapback] Miguel Olivo? 661567[/snapback] you mean .234 career hitting Miguel Olivo?
January 21, 200521 yr Author Wild Card and Ramp, was the 8 mil (7 for him, 1 for salary, yes I know before someone tries to play semantics) salary for Al Leiter fair? 661633[/snapback] Yes, because there were no other alternatives out there. It seems like ANY pitcher who is decent was getting this kind of money anyway.
January 21, 200521 yr Well, Samson said himself yesterday that "The Marlins cannot afford to sign players that will not potentially perform up to what they are being paid." Lo Duca will never be a $6 Million per player. 661630[/snapback] Obviously the Samson and the rest of the franchise's organizational executives disagree or by their own definition they wouldn't have signed the guy.
January 21, 200521 yr Wild Card and Ramp, was the 8 mil (7 for him, 1 for salary, yes I know before someone tries to play semantics) salary for Al Leiter fair? 661633[/snapback] Yes, because there were no other alternatives out there. It seems like ANY pitcher who is decent was getting this kind of money anyway. 661660[/snapback] This is exactly the same as lo duca. What are the alternatives?
January 21, 200521 yr Well, Samson said himself yesterday that "The Marlins cannot afford to sign players that will not potentially perform up to what they are being paid." Lo Duca will never be a $6 Million per player. 661630[/snapback] Obviously the Samson and the rest of the franchise's organizational executives disagree or by their own definition they wouldn't have signed the guy. 661675[/snapback] I guess they do disagree. I love our front office, but signing Lo Duca to that deal was a moronic move. Wild Card and Ramp, was the 8 mil (7 for him, 1 for salary, yes I know before someone tries to play semantics) salary for Al Leiter fair? Yes, because, like Ramp stated, it seemed as if everyone on the market that has had 5 wins in a season was receiving $5+ Mill a year, and Leiter was the only one year option. I'd rather be tied down to a mediocre pitcher for that much cash per for just one season opposed to three or four.
January 21, 200521 yr ^^ What would you have done? Not sign lo duca and cross you fingers with willingham?
January 21, 200521 yr no way on pierzynski.. the guy is a first class a**hole 660736[/snapback] I agree, he seems to be a douche bag, but he is the same player as Lo Duca, but younger and a lefty..... and he is $4mil cheaper.... $4mil!!! 660738[/snapback] I agree 100%. As a GM, you have to factor in the financial side of this. Is Lo Duca a $6 Million per year player? Heck no. Is A.J. P a $2 Million per year player? Yes. Is the difference on the field significant? Not really. Is the difference in the wallet significant? Very. In fact, the Marlins could throw a 'lil more money Delgado's way if they had that $4 Mill. So, in essence, the difference on the field could be extremely significant if you view it my way. 660837[/snapback] Look, I feel very comfortable in saying this. Lo duca will be worth EVERY CENT of that $6M - you will just have to wait and see. AJ P is crap. Sorry, you dont poison the well to save money - that is how you get bad situations. I dont think the Marlins overpaid for Lo Duca based on what his future production will be. You can run stats all you like, but compare Lo Duca's numbers to others in his price range at his position and you may find that he is worth it, right now. There are other factors to consider beyond just on-field stats, too.
January 21, 200521 yr we should've went after AJ that being said, we had to have a quality backstop 661076[/snapback] Not really. The offensive production from Willingham, Delgado and platoon in rightfield would have supplied enough to offset their defensive liabilities, atleast for the regular season. The same for a good-field no-hit shortstop, catcher, etc. As long as you are adequately stocked at other positions you can take the risk. 661097[/snapback] No no No, we cannot risk a liability behind the plate like we did last year. Willingham cannot be our starting catcher. Then we have to run the risk of trading for another one at the break and lose more prospects. Keeping lo duca is a good idea, solid catcher, much better than just average offensively, and a much better alternative than willingham/treanor. This team as it is now is stacked. We are solid at every position. We cannot afford a question mark behind the plate like we did last year. 661620[/snapback] Why would you need a good starting catcher if the other 7 in your lineup are getting the job done?
January 21, 200521 yr Why would you need a good starting catcher if the other 7 in your lineup are getting the job done? 661706[/snapback] Obviously you are asking this rhetorically because you're smart enough to already know the answer.
January 21, 200521 yr no way on pierzynski.. the guy is a first class a**hole 660736[/snapback] I agree, he seems to be a douche bag, but he is the same player as Lo Duca, but younger and a lefty..... and he is $4mil cheaper.... $4mil!!! 660738[/snapback] I agree 100%. As a GM, you have to factor in the financial side of this. Is Lo Duca a $6 Million per year player? Heck no. Is A.J. P a $2 Million per year player? Yes. Is the difference on the field significant? Not really. Is the difference in the wallet significant? Very. In fact, the Marlins could throw a 'lil more money Delgado's way if they had that $4 Mill. So, in essence, the difference on the field could be extremely significant if you view it my way. 660837[/snapback] Look, I feel very comfortable in saying this. Lo duca will be worth EVERY CENT of that $6M - you will just have to wait and see. AJ P is crap. Sorry, you dont poison the well to save money - that is how you get bad situations. I dont think the Marlins overpaid for Lo Duca based on what his future production will be. You can run stats all you like, but compare Lo Duca's numbers to others in his price range at his position and you may find that he is worth it, right now. There are other factors to consider beyond just on-field stats, too. 661698[/snapback] Agreed. In addition, Willingham is not the answer if we want to win now.
January 21, 200521 yr Author I dont think the Marlins overpaid for Lo Duca based on what his future production will be. You can run stats all you like, but compare Lo Duca's numbers to others in his price range at his position and you may find that he is worth it, right now. There are other factors to consider beyond just on-field stats, too. 661698[/snapback] care to give us some numbers?
January 22, 200521 yr no way on pierzynski.. the guy is a first class a**hole 660736[/snapback] I agree, he seems to be a douche bag, but he is the same player as Lo Duca, but younger and a lefty..... and he is $4mil cheaper.... $4mil!!! 660738[/snapback] I agree 100%. As a GM, you have to factor in the financial side of this. Is Lo Duca a $6 Million per year player? Heck no. Is A.J. P a $2 Million per year player? Yes. Is the difference on the field significant? Not really. Is the difference in the wallet significant? Very. In fact, the Marlins could throw a 'lil more money Delgado's way if they had that $4 Mill. So, in essence, the difference on the field could be extremely significant if you view it my way. 660837[/snapback] Look, I feel very comfortable in saying this. Lo duca will be worth EVERY CENT of that $6M - you will just have to wait and see. AJ P is crap. Sorry, you dont poison the well to save money - that is how you get bad situations. I dont think the Marlins overpaid for Lo Duca based on what his future production will be. You can run stats all you like, but compare Lo Duca's numbers to others in his price range at his position and you may find that he is worth it, right now. There are other factors to consider beyond just on-field stats, too. 661698[/snapback] Agreed. In addition, Willingham is not the answer if we want to win now. 661722[/snapback] I think we're one hitter short of winning now. Without another bat, we'll do exactly what we did last season. I'd rather win 75-80 games with Willingham behind the plate at $300K instead of winning 80-85 with Lo Duca calling the pitches for $6 Million. Either way you're not in the post-season, but if you go with Josh you A) Save $17.7 Million which leads to B) More money to put a much better team on the field next year. Worst case scenario Willingham is a bust and we bounce around with mediocre guys for the season until we can sign a replacement in '06. Best case scenario Willingham works out, we have a bargain at catcher and create more spending money going toward other needs.
January 22, 200521 yr I would have loved to have Pudge behind the plate, but thats water under the bridge right now and LoDuca proved his worth as a Marlin since his first AB. I'm more than happy to have him here.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.