March 21, 200521 yr you're being a hypocrit. You critisize republicans for advocating federalism in this case, which is against what the party stands. But you who does not usually advocate states rights is doing so now b/c it suits your own belief. 716619[/snapback] I really don't care if you think i'm a hypocrite. I have lost all respect for the Republican party, when it suddenly decides that they can use the political power they have to start getting involved in court cases they have no jurisdiction over. I hope that the Supreme Court steps in and strikes down this bill. If not, it will be a dark day in the politics of this country.
March 21, 200521 yr you're being a hypocrit. You critisize republicans for advocating federalism in this case, which is against what the party stands. But you who does not usually advocate states rights is doing so now b/c it suits your own belief. 716619[/snapback] I really don't care if you think i'm a hypocrite. I have lost all respect for the Republican party, when it suddenly decides that they can use the political power they have to start getting involved in court cases they have no jurisdiction over. I hope that the Supreme Court steps in and strikes down this bill. If not, it will be a dark day in the politics of this country. 716637[/snapback] what makes this legislation painful is that it is federalizing a states' rights issue. however, theres absolutely nothing wrong legally with what congress is doing. And by the way I know many people think Congress is overstepping its power boundaries here, and they may be right, but IMPO and in the opinion of many other people involved with political science, the const. is so vague in the powers enumerated to the judicial system that there may be no true legal standing in turning down what congress has done. Again I'm not saying turning back this legislation is impossible. What I feel is that it is impossible for the SCOTUS to overturn the law based on the fact that congress overstepped its boundaries in seperation of powers.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.