May 1, 200620 yr The highest profile international signing that I've been aware of was the Mets' signing of Fernando Martinez over the summer and he cost them close to $2 million, and this is for a 17 year old who is incredibly raw. So raw he is tearing up the Sally League and might be #1 in that league as well. For $2 million, I'd hope he's hitting in rookie ball...even the Mets can't be that far off. He's currently in Low A ball (sorry I don't understand your post or what you meant by it) Also BA says if Fernando Martinez where eligible to enter the 2006 draft he would be a top 5 pick. Ryan Braun last #5 pick got 2,450,000. Care to post a link to that assessment? Only thing I've seen on him from BA is saying that the Mets felt he made sense since they didn't have a second or third round pick and he matched up pretty well with high-school outfielders in this past year's draft. Background: In their first year under Omar Minaya, the majors? lone Hispanic general manager, the Mets were extremely aggressive in mining Latin America. Their biggest splash was Martinez, who signed for $1.4 million. New York, which lacked second- and third-round picks in the draft, believes he matched up with any U.S. high school outfielder taken in the draft.
May 1, 200620 yr Author Just to be clear, this isn't about race or ethnicity. I don't know why TSwift would bring that up. This is about continuing to have access to a pool of talent that the rest of MLB is taking advantage of. So you're pretty much saying you have no response? I'll just say that I agree with Juanky. His response was well-written and well-argued. And I disagree with you for the same reasons Juanky outlined.
May 1, 200620 yr Miggy is also a much more talented player than Hermida. Miggy at 18 would have been the first pick in the draft in the states and would have commanded about 3-4 million. Hmmmmmm...doubtful he would have been the #1 pick. He wasn't even the #1 prospect in our organization while he was a youngin'. A lot of these guys are much more expensive hit and misses than any college or high-school player because it's unclear what the quality of competition is, and it's almost impossible to just NFL combine a baseball player. I agree with Primento here. At 18 Miggy would have been either the #1 overall pick or a top 5 pick just based on his tools, if he where eligible for the draft. Also at age 19 Cabrera was the #1 prospect in our organization.
May 1, 200620 yr Just to be clear, this isn't about race or ethnicity. I don't know why TSwift would bring that up. This is about continuing to have access to a pool of talent that the rest of MLB is taking advantage of. So you're pretty much saying you have no response? I'll just say that I agree with Juanky. His response was well-written and well-argued. And I disagree with you for the same reasons Juanky outlined. Then thanks to Juanky for fighting your battle for you. It still comes down to money and simply playing the draft makes a lot of sense for us, more than trying to hang with the Mets/Dodgers/Yankees/Angels in the Caribbean.
May 1, 200620 yr The highest profile international signing that I've been aware of was the Mets' signing of Fernando Martinez over the summer and he cost them close to $2 million, and this is for a 17 year old who is incredibly raw. So raw he is tearing up the Sally League and might be #1 in that league as well. For $2 million, I'd hope he's hitting in rookie ball...even the Mets can't be that far off. He's currently in Low A ball (sorry I don't understand your post or what you meant by it) Also BA says if Fernando Martinez where eligible to enter the 2006 draft he would be a top 5 pick. Ryan Braun last #5 pick got 2,450,000. Care to post a link to that assessment? Only thing I've seen on him from BA is saying that the Mets felt he made sense since they didn't have a second or third round pick and he matched up pretty well with high-school outfielders in this past year's draft. Background: In their first year under Omar Minaya, the majors? lone Hispanic general manager, the Mets were extremely aggressive in mining Latin America. Their biggest splash was Martinez, who signed for $1.4 million. New York, which lacked second- and third-round picks in the draft, believes he matched up with any U.S. high school outfielder taken in the draft. Mets outfielder Fernando Martinez is off to a strong start at low Class A Hagerstown as a 17-year-old, hitting .323/.408/.538 with one homer, eight RBIs and three steals in 17 games. If Martinez were a high school senior right now, where would he likely be drafted in June? Jason Phillips Boston Martinez signed for $1.4 million out of the Dominican Republic last summer. Though he was a free agent then and would be restricted to negotiating with one team in the draft, he'd do better this June. In a draft crop that's very thin on position players and is getting the worst early reviews since the 2000 bunch, Martinez would be coveted. Realistically, he's at least three years away from the major leagues, so that might keep him from going No. 1 overall, but he'd likely be one of the first five or 10 picks. He's better than any high school position player available, and you could argue him against the top college position players. Martinez has a higher ceiling than Long Beach State third baseman Evan Longoria, and scouts believe he's a safer bet to hit than Texas outfielder Drew Stubbs. Martinez already is an advanced hitter and he also has above-average power potential. With solid speed and a strong arm, he projects as a quality all-around right fielder. For the sake of comparison, he's outperforming the other 17-year-old phenoms in the South Atlantic League, Braves shortstop Elvis Andrus (.221/.279/.284) and Yankees outfielder Jose Tabata (.329/.342/.452).
May 1, 200620 yr Author Just to be clear, this isn't about race or ethnicity. I don't know why TSwift would bring that up. This is about continuing to have access to a pool of talent that the rest of MLB is taking advantage of. So you're pretty much saying you have no response? I'll just say that I agree with Juanky. His response was well-written and well-argued. And I disagree with you for the same reasons Juanky outlined. Then thanks to Juanky for fighting your battle for you. It still comes down to money and simply playing the draft makes a lot of sense for us, more than trying to hang with the Mets/Dodgers/Yankees/Angels in the Caribbean. Well, there's nothing more for me to say. I agree 100% with Juanky. What the hell do you want me to do? Make something up just for the sake of argument? Coincidentally, me and Festa were discussing this earlier and we came to the conclusion that someone would try to make this into a racial/ethnic thing when it isn't at all. It doesn't surprise me that you were the one that did it.
May 1, 200620 yr Just to be clear, this isn't about race or ethnicity. I don't know why TSwift would bring that up. This is about continuing to have access to a pool of talent that the rest of MLB is taking advantage of. So you're pretty much saying you have no response? I'll just say that I agree with Juanky. His response was well-written and well-argued. And I disagree with you for the same reasons Juanky outlined. Then thanks to Juanky for fighting your battle for you. It still comes down to money and simply playing the draft makes a lot of sense for us, more than trying to hang with the Mets/Dodgers/Yankees/Angels in the Caribbean. Well, there's nothing more for me to say. I agree 100% with Juanky. What the hell do you want me to do? Make something up just for the sake of argument? Coincidentally, me and Festa were discussing this earlier and we came to the conclusion that someone would try to make this into a racial/ethnic thing when it isn't at all. It doesn't surprise me that you were the one that did it. And what does that mean? Are you calling me a racist? And how exactly could I be the one to make it racial if you're the one who cares about the lack of HISPANIC PROSPECTS. If that's not racial, I don't know what is...call it INTERNATIONAL PROSPECTS, dumbass.
May 1, 200620 yr Just to chime in again. On the question of expenditures to other countries, it does cost a bit more to fly from Miami to Colombia. But let's not pretend it doesn't cost money to fly to California to see a hot shot high school pitcher. There's always going to be outside money involved, the only difference is that you have to draft while you don't have to scout internationally. However, for a team that's so budget conscious, it would actually make sense to scout more heavily outside of the country because the potential payout is three years of slave labor from an all star and three more years of reasonable salary before they depart for a team that actually believes in paying its employees (assuming, of course, that their time here doesn't coencide with firesale #3). And since you can look around the majors and see a higher percentage of the players signed internationally succeeding than the percentage of those drafted, it makes sense to put money into this area of player searching. The only reason you see international scouting fall apart is because this team is forced to have draft picks. Since they're so money hungry they choose to use the scouting finances in the place where they have to make a pick anyways instead of in another area where they can actually have a higher chance of finding an incredible stud but they're not forced. Life's a bitch.
May 1, 200620 yr Just to chime in again. On the question of expenditures to other countries, it does cost a bit more to fly from Miami to Colombia. But let's not pretend it doesn't cost money to fly to California to see a hot shot high school pitcher. There's always going to be outside money involved, the only difference is that you have to draft while you don't have to scout internationally. However, for a team that's so budget conscious, it would actually make sense to scout more heavily outside of the country because the potential payout is three years of slave labor from an all star and three more years of reasonable salary before they depart for a team that actually believes in paying its employees (assuming, of course, that their time here doesn't coencide with firesale #3). And since you can look around the majors and see a higher percentage of the players signed internationally succeeding than the percentage of those drafted, it makes sense to put money into this area of player searching. The only reason you see international scouting fall apart is because this team is forced to have draft picks. Since they're so money hungry they choose to use the scouting finances in the place where they have to make a pick anyways instead of in another area where they can actually have a higher chance of finding an incredible stud but they're not forced. Life's a bitch. You're forced to draft. You're not forced to sign internationally. If the Marlins have only a few million committed to scouting/signing, they can't afford to sign an international player worth a spit and a first round pick. It would make a whole lot more sense to just internationalize the entire draft like the NHL/NBA, but it is what it is, and what it is to me is a system that says small money teams can't afford to run with the big boys in the Caribbean and Japan anymore (not that they could in Japan to begin with).
May 1, 200620 yr Author unless having Hispanics on the team makes you sleep better at night. I don't understand the concern that we aren't Hispanic enough. This is what you said. You were the first one to bring this up. I am not calling you a racist, at all. You were the one that made it seem like some of our concerns that we weren't involved enough in Latin America was based on our desire to have a more Latin team. We just want to produce talented players, and the fact of the matter is that Latin America is producing a great deal of the up and coming talent in MLB. You'd have to be blind not to see that a significant percentage of the game's stars are from Latin America. And we're not active in trying to sign them. That's bad.
May 1, 200620 yr You know, for all the talk, the best 6 players of the past 20 years have all been drafted, not signed internationally: Griffey, Maddux, ARod, Pujols, Clemens, Bonds...all taken on draft day. Now, you had to suck to be high enough to pick Griffey, ARod, etc. but Pujols was a late round steal...hence the importance of domestic scouting as well.
May 1, 200620 yr Author Why the name-calling, TSwift? I think everyone here knows you're the idiot. I said specifically Latin America because, let's face it, they produce better talent than other parts of the world. I'm not going to recommend that the Marlins increase their scouting in freakin China. Give me a break. Korea? Sure. But I would prefer we spend more of our resources in Venezuela and the Dominican Republic than in Korea.
May 1, 200620 yr Just to chime in again. On the question of expenditures to other countries, it does cost a bit more to fly from Miami to Colombia. But let's not pretend it doesn't cost money to fly to California to see a hot shot high school pitcher. There's always going to be outside money involved, the only difference is that you have to draft while you don't have to scout internationally. However, for a team that's so budget conscious, it would actually make sense to scout more heavily outside of the country because the potential payout is three years of slave labor from an all star and three more years of reasonable salary before they depart for a team that actually believes in paying its employees (assuming, of course, that their time here doesn't coencide with firesale #3). And since you can look around the majors and see a higher percentage of the players signed internationally succeeding than the percentage of those drafted, it makes sense to put money into this area of player searching. The only reason you see international scouting fall apart is because this team is forced to have draft picks. Since they're so money hungry they choose to use the scouting finances in the place where they have to make a pick anyways instead of in another area where they can actually have a higher chance of finding an incredible stud but they're not forced. Life's a bitch. You're forced to draft. You're not forced to sign internationally. If the Marlins have only a few million committed to scouting/signing, they can't afford to sign an international player worth a spit and a first round pick. It would make a whole lot more sense to just internationalize the entire draft like the NHL/NBA, but it is what it is, and what it is to me is a system that says small money teams can't afford to run with the big boys in the Caribbean and Japan anymore (not that they could in Japan to begin with). Your forced to draft but not forced to sign the players. What some teams reach for players and pay them less than slot money. Did you read what I posted? Why sign a Evan Longoria in the draft for more money when you can sign Fernando Martinez for less and he has more potential? I think the draft is just fine how it is personally.
May 1, 200620 yr Why the name-calling, TSwift? I think everyone here knows you're the idiot. I said specifically Latin America because, let's face it, they produce better talent than other parts of the world. I'm not going to recommend that the Marlins increase their scouting in freakin China. Give me a break. Korea? Sure. But I would prefer we spend more of our resources in Venezuela and the Dominican Republic than in Korea. I'm the idiot who at least makes my own argument instead of letting someone else do it for me. You're just furthering the idea that it is hispanically motivated, Prin. A decade ago, someone would have laughed at you if you suggested that Japan would produce the like of Ichiro and Johjima. Teams like the Marlins have to be scouting countries that are untouched. Give me a Chinese player if that's what it takes to be cost effective.
May 1, 200620 yr You're forced to draft. You're not forced to sign internationally. If the Marlins have only a few million committed to scouting/signing, they can't afford to sign an international player worth a spit and a first round pick. It would make a whole lot more sense to just internationalize the entire draft like the NHL/NBA, but it is what it is, and what it is to me is a system that says small money teams can't afford to run with the big boys in the Caribbean and Japan anymore (not that they could in Japan to begin with). I know you're forced to draft.....I think I made that pretty clear in my post. The fault lies with the club for only budgeting enough to cover the United States and falling behind on the international level, especially when they have the built in advantage that they play 81 of their games in (or close to, rather) Miami. Internationalizing the draft might not be a bad idea.....but until then it would be a good idea for the team to spending the extra money necessary to actually have a presence in Latin America. Then again, that'd be too much to ask.
May 1, 200620 yr Just to chime in again. On the question of expenditures to other countries, it does cost a bit more to fly from Miami to Colombia. But let's not pretend it doesn't cost money to fly to California to see a hot shot high school pitcher. There's always going to be outside money involved, the only difference is that you have to draft while you don't have to scout internationally. However, for a team that's so budget conscious, it would actually make sense to scout more heavily outside of the country because the potential payout is three years of slave labor from an all star and three more years of reasonable salary before they depart for a team that actually believes in paying its employees (assuming, of course, that their time here doesn't coencide with firesale #3). And since you can look around the majors and see a higher percentage of the players signed internationally succeeding than the percentage of those drafted, it makes sense to put money into this area of player searching. The only reason you see international scouting fall apart is because this team is forced to have draft picks. Since they're so money hungry they choose to use the scouting finances in the place where they have to make a pick anyways instead of in another area where they can actually have a higher chance of finding an incredible stud but they're not forced. Life's a bitch. You're forced to draft. You're not forced to sign internationally. If the Marlins have only a few million committed to scouting/signing, they can't afford to sign an international player worth a spit and a first round pick. It would make a whole lot more sense to just internationalize the entire draft like the NHL/NBA, but it is what it is, and what it is to me is a system that says small money teams can't afford to run with the big boys in the Caribbean and Japan anymore (not that they could in Japan to begin with). Your forced to draft but not forced to sign the players. What some teams reach for players and pay them less than slot money. Did you read what I posted? Why sign a Evan Longoria in the draft for more money when you can sign Fernando Martinez for less and he has more potential? I think the draft is just fine how it is personally. You're comparing one signing to the weakest draft in recent memory. The Marlins took Adrian Gonzalez as a reach with the #1, the Padres did the same with the alcoholic short-stop (name's escaping me). You can't take a reach pick every year in the draft, unless you just want to run your team into the ground.
May 1, 200620 yr The Marlins took Adrian Gonzalez as a reach with the #1, the Padres did the same with the alcoholic short-stop (name's escaping me). Bush.
May 1, 200620 yr Author Hispanically motivated? I didn't realize hispanically was a word. You're an idiot.
May 1, 200620 yr You know, for all the talk, the best 6 players of the past 20 years have all been drafted, not signed internationally: Griffey, Maddux, ARod, Pujols, Clemens, Bonds...all taken on draft day. Now, you had to suck to be high enough to pick Griffey, ARod, etc. but Pujols was a late round steal...hence the importance of domestic scouting as well. International scouting wasn't that big of a thing 20 years ago. 20 years ago how many teams had academies in the Dominican Republic and Venezuela? Lets see how the new list 20 years from now is going to look like.
May 1, 200620 yr Hispanically motivated? I didn't realize hispanically was a word. You're an idiot. What an intelligent retort. So glad you're bringing so much to this discussion...and even more proud it took you so long to think that up. Keep at it. You know, for all the talk, the best 6 players of the past 20 years have all been drafted, not signed internationally: Griffey, Maddux, ARod, Pujols, Clemens, Bonds...all taken on draft day. Now, you had to suck to be high enough to pick Griffey, ARod, etc. but Pujols was a late round steal...hence the importance of domestic scouting as well. International scouting wasn't that big of a thing 20 years ago. 20 years ago how many teams had academies in the Dominican Republic and Venezuela? Lets see how the new list 20 years from now is going to look like. International scouting was still prevalent 20 years ago. Not to the extent it is now, but Roberto Clemente, Orlando Cepeda, Tony Perez, Dave Concepcion and the like were the first wave of a large movement of international scouting. I fail to see the point in that argument, though...the hispanic influence has been around for a long time, the winners are those who either refuse to overpay or have the disposable money so overpaying isn't an issue. If the international scene is such a concern, the Marlins need to find the next Japan instead of trudging around and struggling to get their money's worth on the mid-level signings (since I think it's foolish to suggest they're just going to go around handing out $2 million signing bonuses).
May 1, 200620 yr I think that for the most part, the talent pools in both Japan and Cuba were extremely overrated during the period of 1995-2004 or so. If you look at how many Japanese players have succeeded, it doesn't go much further than Ichiro, Kaz Suzuki (played only 4 seasons), Tad Iguchi, and Hideki Matsui. The first Japanese player in the majors since the 1950's, Hideo Nomo, was off and on. The Yankees threw everything they could at Hideki Irabu, who came over a little while after Nomo. He finished his MLB career with an ERA over 5. Looking at the Cuban talent pool, the only players defecting from that country in the past 10 years who have had an impact are Livan Hernandez, his brother Orlando, and Jose Contreras. No hitters of note at all.
May 1, 200620 yr You're forced to draft. You're not forced to sign internationally. If the Marlins have only a few million committed to scouting/signing, they can't afford to sign an international player worth a spit and a first round pick. It would make a whole lot more sense to just internationalize the entire draft like the NHL/NBA, but it is what it is, and what it is to me is a system that says small money teams can't afford to run with the big boys in the Caribbean and Japan anymore (not that they could in Japan to begin with). I know you're forced to draft.....I think I made that pretty clear in my post. The fault lies with the club for only budgeting enough to cover the United States and falling behind on the international level, especially when they have the built in advantage that they play 81 of their games in (or close to, rather) Miami. Internationalizing the draft might not be a bad idea.....but until then it would be a good idea for the team to spending the extra money necessary to actually have a presence in Latin America. Then again, that'd be too much to ask. I agree it would be great to not fall ridiculously behind in Latin America, but it isn't easy. I'd rather see the Marlins struggle to sign international players and just go ahead and do well on draft day than to find a player like Cabrera (who, by the way, how many more did Ferreira turn up in the 7 years since he was signed) and shoot yourself in the foot every draft. You can go three, four, ten years between substantial international signins (since Cabrera's and Vlad's just don't go on trees) while there are plenty of talented players available (and more readily available) every draft, except in unique circumstances. To me, if it's one or the other, it's a no-brainer...of course you'd love to have both, but the Loria led Marlins will absolutely not. I think that for the most part, the talent pools in both Japan and Cuba were extremely overrated during the period of 1995-2004 or so. If you look at how many Japanese players have succeeded, it doesn't go much further than Ichiro, Kaz Suzuki (played only 4 seasons), Tad Iguchi, and Hideki Matsui. The first Japanese player in the majors since the 1950's, Hideo Nomo, was off and on. The Yankees threw everything they could at Hideki Irabu, who came over a little while after Nomo. He finished his MLB career with an ERA over 5. Looking at the Cuban talent pool, the only players defecting from that country in the past 10 years who have had an impact are Livan Hernandez, his brother Orlando, and Jose Contreras. No hitters of note at all. That's also because of 'posting' rules and political pressure. Just saying...
May 1, 200620 yr Well Swifty, when you're forced to do one and not the other it's easy to choose one even if you're not guaranteed anything in either. Since they don't have the money (or claim to, anyways) then I guess it's just us throwing around philosophical questions if we're talking Marlins. I think that for the most part, the talent pools in both Japan and Cuba were extremely overrated during the period of 1995-2004 or so. If you look at how many Japanese players have succeeded, it doesn't go much further than Ichiro, Kaz Suzuki (played only 4 seasons), Tad Iguchi, and Hideki Matsui. The first Japanese player in the majors since the 1950's, Hideo Nomo, was off and on. The Yankees threw everything they could at Hideki Irabu, who came over a little while after Nomo. He finished his MLB career with an ERA over 5. Looking at the Cuban talent pool, the only players defecting from that country in the past 10 years who have had an impact are Livan Hernandez, his brother Orlando, and Jose Contreras. No hitters of note at all. Well, first off, there are other countries in Asia and Latin America besides Japan and Cuba. Second off, go watch WBC tape and tell me there aren't studs waiting to be Major Leaguers on both those teams. They did meet in the finals for a reason. Third, Cuba has this communist thing going. Prevents people from going in and out of the country. Might want to look in on that. Fourth, Kendry Morales is not a pitcher. Neither is Rafael Palmeiro, nor Mike Lowell. And Mr. Matsunaka from Japan, as well as Akinari Otusaka, beg to differ with your hating on their talent pool.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.